I'm using a router sled to flatten end grain cutting boards, and cannot figure out why I'm left with a horrible finish. I'd love some feedback on what I'm doing wrong, or what I can do to improve… I've read so many posts about using a router sled to effectively flatten surfaces like this.
The sled functions well and the boards do come out flat. The problem is it appears that the bit is roughing or tearing up the end grain significantly (I'm not sure what to call this issue… tearout? fuzz?). See photos below. I've tried varying spindle speed and also the rate that I'm feeding the router over the board. Saw this same issue when routing pockets on the bottom of the board (not using the sled, following an edge guide)
The wood is leftover butcher block countertop from Ikea. Beechwood. I haven't had other issues working with it in table saw, circular saw, router to clean up edge of countertop, sanding, etc. http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/40057853/
Other thoughts: the chips that come off are quite small and gritty almost like cornmeal. The surface can eventually be cleaned up with a combo of a cabinet scraper and a ton of sanding… essentially have to remove enough material to get down to clean end grain.
I was going to go with a dull bit until you mentioned Ikea.
Many times they will call wood one type when it's actually another. A lot of the wood they use is "Mysterious Unknownus" wood and defies identification. I even got a piece of wood from a chair they sold that was so saturated with some kind of chemical that it was impossible to get a decent finish on it. It chipped out in the plane and in the table saw for no known reason. The only thing that made it like it was mahogany was the color and the grain, but as you cut into it, it would get lighter and lighter, like a stain or a dye hadn't gone all the way through.
Clamps - I just had the cutting board on the cast iron saw top (no clamps). One hand on the router, one hand on the board. It didn't seem to vibrate but I'll see if clamping helps. I also had some chip-out when routing the pockets (handles) when the board was clamped.
Water - Hadn't tried that. Should I just mist it on then quickly hit it with the router (to avoid the moisture further soaking in and warping the board.)
Depth of cut: Not very deep, likely ~.030" or 1/32". It appeared that deeper cuts made the issue worse.
Router bits: tried a 1/2" and 1.5" diameter. Both brand new Freud bits.
Ikea: maybe Dallas is onto something. Although I've not had other major issues with it.
Good catch, Dallas. I wouldn't make any judgments until you've tried it with known hardwood(s). You may be doing nothing wrong. If you think of pine, it, too, can be milled and cut with great results, but the end grain can act just like the "beechwood" you're using.
I have tear out issues when planning with a router sled, on hardwood, and on face grain. I have a 2" planing bit but I can't remember the mfr. I also tried a couple of 1" bits with the same results. Anyone have specific router bits and speeds they have used that did not create tear out, especially with oak? I would think the Freud bits would be good, so I'm very interested in any hardwood testing the op can do.
I just use standard straight bits-initially a 1/2 and later a woodriver 3/4. Flattened two big cherry slabs with no tear out. That's odd. Wish I had a good answer.
might try a bowl bit with rounded corners
and cutting into the grain
so there is more grain un-cut holding the fibers in place
the rounded corners will trim the grain down
as opposed to whacking them off at the base
Thanks all for the replies. I'm going to pick up maple and run some end grain through my current router flattening setup to determine if this problem is stemming from the Ikea "beeachwood".
Turns out my issue was feed speed (how fast I was moving the router over the work piece.) Tearout was very sensitive to feed speed on the end grain. I successfully used both a 1-1/2" and a ½" Freud bit. Was able to sand out the marks/lines left with a ROS with 80 grit, 100 grit, then 220 grit. Worked quite well and got the board dead-flat. The larger diameter bit
Just finished this one, had been wanting to do it for a while. 660 pieces!
Ok, I know this is years later but I am having the same issue with a bit I bought. It's supposed to be an awesome bit but when I used it in my sled on end grain it left a very rough surface like your pictures. I did pull the router pretty quick across the surface.
Thanks for the info. I just bout a bowl cutter bit yesterday to see if that helps. It's supposed to leave a smoother surface. I will give these a try on my next board. It will be an edge grain board. I'm thinking I can run that through the planer though.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
LumberJocks Woodworking Forum
2.5M posts
96K members
Since 2006
A forum community dedicated to professional woodworkers and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about shop safety, wood, carpentry, lumber, finishing, tools, machinery, woodworking related topics, styles, scales, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!