I am looking at getting a foot switch for my SS, but am not sure what type would be best.. either the momentay type or the push on/push off version. Was wondering what preference others have and why?
What is SS?
Saw Stop?
I use several foot switch from HF.
I use mostly on/off not momentary as they are a pain and sometime impossible to hold in as you work.
I would check to see if a footswitch can be used with a saw stop or not.I am just trying to decipher the use of a footswitch with such a set up I would check before buying in any case. Alistair
I have a foot switch on my scroll saw. I got the deadman's type where you have to hold it down to keep the saw going. It works well and I'd recommend it.
LOL - I figured that being posted in the scrollsawing forum, "SS" would be kind of obvious! Sorry about the confusion.. yes, I'm looking at getting a foot switch for my recently aquired Delta 40-601 scroll saw I was just curious about the pros and cons between the two types.
I used to recommend using a momentary switch with a scroll saw but maybe now that I'm getting older my foot gets tired of constantly pushing the pedal while cutting,I now wish I had a push on/push off foot switch instead.
heres a good thought. Do you sit or stand while cutting? If you sit is it in a position where you can reach the floor without getting up? I would think if you have to get up to hit the switch then how is that any different than using the factory switch?
I have foot switches on my scroll saw, drill press , belt sander and band saw. All are harbor freight click on and click off type. While using my scroll saw, near the end of my cut I depress the foot switch and the saw will continue to run until I release it. (Much like the dead man type) The best of both worlds.
Well, it's only been two years since I first asked this question, and I finally got around to picking up one of those foot switches today
Had a 25% off coupon from HF that expired today, so I ran over and picked up one of the push-on, push-off types. I have to admit, I waited way too long, and should have got it a lot sooner. I went with the push-on/push-off type mainly based on Ken and Jim's comments above - best of both worlds. It certainly makes things much easier, and at roughly $11 (after tax) for the switch and a free 20' tape measure, the price certainly was right!
Cheers,
Brad
PS: After using it a while, I now firmly believe that all scroll saws should come from the factory with a foot switch, not just the uber-expensive ones
What is SS?
Saw Stop?
I use several foot switch from HF.
I use mostly on/off not momentary as they are a pain and sometime impossible to hold in as you work.
The momentary gets the most work doing inlay and stringing work with routers and a Dremel, my ShopVac in between groups of pocket holes, and anything else I want on and off hands-free or in bursts.
I use the click on/off for my scroll saw, my HVLP turbine when I'm not using my RF remote, bigger handheld routing, and anything my foot would go numb holding down a foot switch.
With the on-off, I'll turn the tool off when my hands are free. I don't leave it live.
I checked out my foot switch at woodcraft it was close to $30.00 Harbor fright has the excavation same switch. For $13.00 therefore I have a H F switch and it works great. I thought the woodcraft one would have a metal case but they are both plastic. Why pay more?
"Well, it's only been two years since I first asked this question, and I finally got around to picking up one of those foot switches today "
Hello Brad,
Thanks for resurrecting your original post. I never gave any thought to a foot switch for my scroll saw but now I'm thinking about getting one ASAP before I use my SS again.
Marc
If you get the HF one, signing up for text coupons can get you a 20% off one item coupon right away. Then you can just text the stop code to make the texts end. I used that trick this weekend to save 20% on my highest priced item (which was a big package of zip ties, it was not a fruitful trip but it probably saved me the gas money to get there).
I have several foot switches (momentary switches, so on only when pressing) and use them with any tool whenever I'll be doing something where a catastrophic failure is a possibility. I have one that stays on, requiring a second step, to turn it back off. It was the first one that I purchased, and I don't like it, so don't use it. I want the tool to shut off as I'm heading for the door.
Charley
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
LumberJocks Woodworking Forum
2.5M posts
96K members
Since 2006
A forum community dedicated to professional woodworkers and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about shop safety, wood, carpentry, lumber, finishing, tools, machinery, woodworking related topics, styles, scales, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!