LumberJocks

Bosch/Makita

  • Advertise with us

« back to Power Tools, Hardware and Accessories forum

Forum topic by TigerUnderGlass posted 61 days ago 687 views 0 times favorited 26 replies Add to Favorites Watch
View TigerUnderGlass's profile

TigerUnderGlass

4 posts in 62 days


61 days ago

Hi, I’m brand new here and I’m sure this topic has been debated like crazy but I am really really torn on a purchase I need to make. I’d like to pick up a drill/impact driver combo set and two have really caught my eye but I can’t decide partly because I just don’t know enough.

1. Makita DLX2002SY1

This includes the DTD129 brushless impact driver and the DHP480 brushless ammer Driver Drill. Also 3 1.5ah batteries.

2. Bosch CLPK232-181 with the DDS181 drill driver and 25618 impact. Comes with 2 2.0ah batteries.

I have always liked bosch and that is what i was planning to buy, but I got into the store and realized that I could get brushless from makita for only an extra $30. I have no idea what to get.

I really need some opinions on these two kits or I will never make up my mind. :)


26 replies so far

View Mark's profile

Mark

393 posts in 600 days


#1 posted 61 days ago

Ya can’t go wrong with Bosch. Some of the Bosch tools are still made in Europe…Not sure if this one is.

-- Mark

View ColonelTravis's profile

ColonelTravis

571 posts in 519 days


#2 posted 61 days ago

I’ve got that Makita set and love it. Brushless apparently lasts longer. I don’t use mine a lot to really care about that very much, but there you go.
Got a Bosch router and love it.

Flip a coin.
Or a $30 bill.

View Loren's profile

Loren

7389 posts in 2273 days


#3 posted 61 days ago

Look at battery replacement costs.

Bosch is pretty slick on the tech. They make some impressive
claims for their battery technology, but maybe they all
do.

I have some Bosch stuff. I like the L-Boxx system too.

-- http://lawoodworking.com

View Rob's profile

Rob

275 posts in 1696 days


#4 posted 61 days ago

At a glance, both sets look nice to me.

First consider whether you’re likely to get another cordless tool, such as a circular saw (or weed whacker?) that shares batteries with one of these sets.

I have an 18v Bosch drill/driver and a 12v drill/driver+impact driver combo, and they work great aside from the 18v Bosch’s lame and useless excuse for a bit holder on the base of the drill. Between the two options you’re looking at, I’d be inclined to lean toward the Makita for the brushless motor (supposedly longer battery life per charge) and spare battery. That way you have always have a spare battery ready to go by the time you drain one of the other batteries.

On the other hand, if one drill is appreciably heavier than the other and you’ll be using them a lot, you might want to lean toward the one that’s easier to wield or add a 12v set to your collection.

View TheFridge's profile

TheFridge

693 posts in 111 days


#5 posted 61 days ago

It’s a crapshoot really. Bosch may be better quality, I have a makita brushed impact, hammer drill, and sawzall that I use heavily at work every single day. I’ve only sent the hammer drill for repairs, but a 6” hole saw will kill any typical drill. A couple people with my company have the brushless set but it’s really all the same. I’ve had the impact, which I use the most, for about 3-4 years and it is a champ. I use it with sockets, Allen wrench sockets, spade bits, and whatever else I can put in it.

If it’s just for use on the weekend I wouldn’t spend the extra money on a brushless. It’ll will make no difference on the long run.

-- "We build our workshops. Then we enjoy the fruits of our labor by laboring for more fruits." - Me

View TigerUnderGlass's profile

TigerUnderGlass

4 posts in 62 days


#6 posted 61 days ago

Thanks, I appreciate the assistance so far. I guess where I’m torn is on whether or not brushless is enough of a benefit to move off of the Bosch stuff I thought I was about to buy.

Those are good points about the other tools and batteries. I’m almost certain to buy some more tools down the road, but it’s been really hard to figure out who has better batteries.

View BentheViking's profile

BentheViking

1752 posts in 1189 days


#7 posted 61 days ago

i prefer my bosch 12v drilldriver over my makita

-- It's made of wood. Real sturdy.--Chubbs Peterson

View retfr8flyr's profile

retfr8flyr

187 posts in 294 days


#8 posted 61 days ago

I would recommend the brushless Mikata over the Bosch. Have you considered any other brands? I would highly recommend the new brushless Milwaukee Fuel line, both the M12 and the M18 are fantastic. I have these tools and you can’t go wrong with them. They cost more then the others but they are worth it. I don’t know if the Mikta brushless is as big an improvement over the old style as it is in the Milwaukee but with them it’s a major difference. The Fuel series is smaller, lighter, uses less power but yet they are more powerful then the old style.

-- Earl

View TigerUnderGlass's profile

TigerUnderGlass

4 posts in 62 days


#9 posted 61 days ago

To add a touch of further intrigue, it appears I can get the exact same makita set with two 3ah batteries instead of three 1.5ah batteries. On one hand, bigger batteries are better, but with the smaller I have a whole other battery and they are significantly lighter. I am so painfully indecisive.

Is there any good place to look for info on the batteries themselves? I’ve heard it suggests that Bosch had better batteries but I can’t find any solid information on the differences.

View Rob's profile

Rob

275 posts in 1696 days


#10 posted 61 days ago

Personally I’d go with the 3 lighter batteries over the 2 heavier ones, but that’s just me.

Still can’t decide? Flip a coin. :)

View OldWrangler's profile

OldWrangler

516 posts in 220 days


#11 posted 61 days ago

Before you buy either, check CPO Tools.com for reconditioned Bosch tools. I have bought several different Bosch tools from them and been very satisfied. The Bosch is a great, well-built tool and saving 20-30% on a factory recon. with a full guarantee sure helps my tool budget. And these are very smart and helpful people. And they have recons in other brands as well.

-- If trees could scream, would we still cut them down. We might, if they did it all the time for no good reason

View OldWrangler's profile

OldWrangler

516 posts in 220 days


#12 posted 61 days ago

I just went to their site and they have a big sale now on Bosch new tools with a healthy discount. One of the tools is the drill/driver combo. Be sure to check their prices. You pay no sales tax and usually no shipping charge and they get the tools out fast.

-- If trees could scream, would we still cut them down. We might, if they did it all the time for no good reason

View exelectrician's profile

exelectrician

1521 posts in 1053 days


#13 posted 61 days ago

I love both brands but I feel that I was stung when I went to buy a 3 Ah battery from Makita, close to $$100.00 Ouch! for one battery? ..... just saying.

-- Love thy neighbour as thyself

View MrRon's profile

MrRon

2788 posts in 1869 days


#14 posted 61 days ago

I can only relate to my own experience with both Makita and Bosch tools. The tools I have acquired recently (within 5 years), have not stood up to older Makita/Bosch tools acquired 20+ years ago. The durability just doesn’t seem to be there anymore. Today’s tools are becoming throw away tools. Repair parts are very expensive. A switch for my Bosch impact driver costs $46. I won’t fix it. I’ll probably buy a Milwaukee (Can’t afford Festool).

View AandCstyle's profile

AandCstyle

1286 posts in 882 days


#15 posted 60 days ago

I have 2 Bosch cordless drills. One is 14.4v and the other is 18v. I have had both of them for more than 6 years and both are still using the original pair of batteries. I always keep 1 battery in the drill and the other in the charger. They are stored in the shop which ranges between 60 and 80. I have been happy with them so far. FWIW

-- Art

showing 1 through 15 of 26 replies

Have your say...

You must be signed in to reply.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

GardenTenders.com :: gardening showcase