Which one do you like better

  • Advertise with us

« back to Designing Woodworking Projects forum

Forum topic by shipwright posted 06-10-2014 07:52 PM 1354 views 0 times favorited 54 replies Add to Favorites Watch
View shipwright's profile


6270 posts in 1886 days

06-10-2014 07:52 PM

I’m building a couple of nesting tables for a client and have done a prototype to show her some options and to finalize the design before getting into the good material. She wanted “open” aprons and one of the questions that came up is round or square on the apron bars. Here they are in full size to compare. Of course the final decision will be hers but I thought I’d ask ….. Which do you prefer? (I didn’t make an end in the round style.)

Thanks for any input.

-- Paul M ..............If God wanted us to have fiberglass boats he would have given us fiberglass trees.

54 replies so far

View Joe Lyddon's profile

Joe Lyddon

8541 posts in 3140 days

#1 posted 06-10-2014 07:58 PM

They both look the same to me… (??)

-- Have Fun! Joe Lyddon - Alta Loma, CA USA - Home: ... My Small Gallery:"

View Loren's profile


7967 posts in 2736 days

#2 posted 06-10-2014 08:02 PM

I like the round… it doesn’t look like it was just cut out
in a factory that way. Also there’s a little opportunity
to do some carving at the junctions to make a visual
effect of depth, sort of bas relief if you will.


View tsangell's profile


215 posts in 1781 days

#3 posted 06-10-2014 08:03 PM

Square, with a bit stronger overhang on the top.

The form looks very interesting!

View jinkyjock's profile


470 posts in 662 days

#4 posted 06-10-2014 08:03 PM

Personally I think the flat arches compliment the legs better.
What are options for the top ?

View dawsonbob's profile


1323 posts in 843 days

#5 posted 06-10-2014 08:04 PM

It’s the client’s call, of course, but the square cross-section looks better to me.

-- Mistakes are what pave the road to perfection

View Mike Lingenfelter's profile

Mike Lingenfelter

502 posts in 3202 days

#6 posted 06-10-2014 08:07 PM

I like them both. I really like the rounded apron but I think the “flat” goes better with the legs you have. I wonder if you could do some kind of bead or small groove on the flat apron to give it a little more visual character.


View sandhill's profile


2128 posts in 3012 days

#7 posted 06-10-2014 08:08 PM

Nice job paul, Here is my input.
I like the square aprons I would like it if the legs were not so heavy and the top could be a little bigger. I love the design but the proportions seem a little off. Are you going to do any Marquetry or carving on it? That could make a difference in what I said.
Just my 2 cents. can’t wait to see the out come.

View BrutalForce's profile


41 posts in 1377 days

#8 posted 06-10-2014 08:12 PM

I could go either way with the round vs. square, but I agree with sandhill that the top could be bigger or the legs smaller. It looks out of balance. Also is it intentional on the top version to be round on two sides and square on the other?

View HorstPeter's profile


121 posts in 1918 days

#9 posted 06-10-2014 08:14 PM

Definitely square as the round ones clash with the rest of the design, where roundness happens along the length of the legs, but not their profile. I could imagine that a diamond shape or quarter sphere profile might work too, but those are probably more hassle to do.

Not sure if you want any more crits, but in case you do, I feel the top looks a tad too thin compared to the rest of the table, especially with the thickness of the apron bars to compare it to. I’d probably thicken it/put thicker boards on the side and round or taper those a bit to go along with the vertical roundness of the design. Just my two cents, sorry if I was giving too much feedback already.

View TheFridge's profile


3286 posts in 574 days

#10 posted 06-10-2014 08:17 PM

Square, but she’ll prob want round since it looks feminine.

-- Shooting down the walls of heartache. Bang bang. I am. The warrior.

View jmartel's profile


4991 posts in 1238 days

#11 posted 06-10-2014 08:19 PM

I prefer the square. The round would look better if there were no hard edges on the legs at all.

-- The quality of one's woodworking is directly related to the amount of flannel worn.

View mauibob's profile


201 posts in 2155 days

#12 posted 06-10-2014 08:20 PM

Definitely prefer the square design, Paul. The round one does not seem to match any of the other design elements in the table.

-- Bob, Potomac, MD

View DocSavage45's profile


6701 posts in 1931 days

#13 posted 06-10-2014 08:24 PM

I’m for the client to call it since you have built both prototypes? For me I’m thinking a different table top as most of the visual lines in the piece are curved? I like movement in a piece even though my buildings are more straight line design. LOL!

-- Cau Haus Designs, Thomas J. Tieffenbacher

View madts's profile


1566 posts in 1428 days

#14 posted 06-10-2014 08:25 PM

Square plus more overhang on the top. Other wise I like it.

-- Thor and Odin are still the greatest of Gods.

View JAAune's profile


1261 posts in 1405 days

#15 posted 06-10-2014 08:29 PM

I’d probably go with square then make the top a tiny bit bigger and somewhat thicker. Probably something like 1.25” thick with some sort of mildly decorative edge that breaks op the surface so the thicker edge doesn’t look boring and flat.

A sweeping cove on the bottom of the table with a tiny cove on the upper edge is what comes to mind. I’d have to see it to make a determination.

-- See my work at and

showing 1 through 15 of 54 replies

Have your say...

You must be signed in to reply.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics