LumberJocks

Need Design input on table: Symmetric or Asymmetric?

  • Advertise with us

« back to Designing Woodworking Projects forum

Forum topic by Mammatus posted 149 days ago 494 views 0 times favorited 9 replies Add to Favorites Watch
View Mammatus's profile

Mammatus

20 posts in 592 days


149 days ago

OK – I’m building this table for my mom from a beautiful slice of a maple tree that was cut down on her property a few years ago. I finally got around to chiseling off all the bark and sanding it to a beautiful, smooth surface.

I’m trying to figure out how to design the legs. A few months ago I built a small play table for my daughters and I’m borrowing from the design of that to build similar legs for this table out of 3/4” stock.

With this new table, I have come up with two possible designs. I like the fact that the maple slice is not symmetric – on one side, it has a much steeper slope rather than just a 90-degree edge. I’d like to mimic that asymmetry in the legs, so I came up with this plan which would have the legs sort of mimic the angle of the slab. Note that only one of the three legs would have that exaggerated angle…the other three would all be just a few degrees off of vertical. That is option #1. Alternatively, I could just make all four legs be symmetric; that is Option #2.

I’ve mocked up the legs with some spare hardboard so I could get an idea of what the finished product might look like (note the finished legs will be thicker and a lighter shade more closely matching the maple top). So , I turn to you: Which of the two options do you like better:

[size=150]Option #1:[/size]

[size=150]Option #2:[/size]


9 replies so far

View Clint Searl's profile

Clint Searl

1379 posts in 956 days


#1 posted 149 days ago

#1

-- Clint Searl.............We deserve what we tolerate

View gfadvm's profile

gfadvm

10524 posts in 1285 days


#2 posted 149 days ago

Both designs look good to me. I want to know how you got that “cookie” dried without cracking?

-- " I'll try to be nicer, if you'll try to be smarter" gfadvm

View firefighterontheside's profile (online now)

firefighterontheside

3212 posts in 452 days


#3 posted 149 days ago

#2. I think that angled leg would be a problem since it sticks out past the edge of the table.

-- Bill M. I love my job as a firefighter, but nothing gives me the satisfaction of running my hand over a project that I have built and just finished sanding.

View richardwootton's profile

richardwootton

1071 posts in 550 days


#4 posted 149 days ago

Both look pretty good to me, but I’d go with narrower legs. +1 to wanting to know how that cookie didn’t crack.

-- Richard, Hot Springs, Ar -- Galoot In Training

View mrjinx007's profile

mrjinx007

1307 posts in 363 days


#5 posted 149 days ago

It is a beautiful piece with no cracks on it. Whatever you do with it, it should turn out nice.

-- earthartandfoods.com

View Mark Kornell's profile

Mark Kornell

471 posts in 1126 days


#6 posted 149 days ago

#1 – the asymmetry of the legs works well with the asymmetry of the slice. But what Richard said – make the legs narrower, maybe as small as half what your mock up uses.

-- Mark Kornell, Kornell Wood Design

View Mammatus's profile

Mammatus

20 posts in 592 days


#7 posted 137 days ago

Thank you all for the input.

The cookie was cut a few years ago from a healthy tree, but one that needed to be removed due to interference with utility lines. Within days of it being cut, a friend sealed both sides with a single thick coating of poly that was slopped on. Apparently that helped slow the drying down enough to minimize cracking.

So is the consensus for narrower legs, regardless of the design?

View LakeLover's profile

LakeLover

274 posts in 535 days


#8 posted 136 days ago

#1 with more of a hook at the end, to tuck it in a tad.

Maybe mock it up with thinner legs and a color closer to finished.

How thick are the legs ? You can play with the visual weight on how you treat the edges.

Gonna look great, post a finished pic.

View Mammatus's profile

Mammatus

20 posts in 592 days


#9 posted 136 days ago

What do you mean by more of a hook? Curve the far-reaching leg back in a bit on the outside edge?

I’m planning to use oak plywood for the legs…and I’ll add some oak veneer to the edges for the appearance of solid boards…and was planning on them being 3/4” thick.

Have your say...

You must be signed in to reply.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

GardenTenders.com :: gardening showcase