LumberJocks

Design Coincidence

  • Advertise with us

« back to Coffee Lounge forum

Forum topic by ChicoWoodnut posted 2086 days ago 907 views 0 times favorited 14 replies Add to Favorites Watch
View ChicoWoodnut's profile

ChicoWoodnut

904 posts in 2416 days


2086 days ago

I was cruzing around the internet today and came across this web site selling plans for an A&C Wine/Spirits cabinet.

Here is a picture of the cabinet from the site .

And here is a cabinet I designed and built in 2003

Click for details

I also blogged it here.

http://chicowoodnut.home.comcast.net/~chicowoodnut/WineRack.html

Now there are some obvious differences. The legs on theirs are tapered, mine has sliding doors, mine has breadboard ends and the wine bottle stretchers are curved on mine.

I find it mighty coincidental that the width and depth measurements are identical although theirs is a little taller.

I am in no way bugged by this. I know how much work it takes to draft plans and I hope they are making money at it. In fact, I think I drew my inspiration from some pictures(s) I saw somewhere. Design is like that; drawing inspiration from something else and making it our own.

Now I’m comparing the two and wondering if they got the proportions a little better (theirs is about 1 1/2” taller than mine)

I must say that I like my bottle stretcher and doors better than theirs. I think it is rather lazy not to put breadboard ends on an A&C piece. I’m a little ambiguous about the tapered legs though. I don’t think they fit the Craftsman style ;)

-- Scott - Chico California http://chicowoodnut.home.comcast.net


14 replies so far

View stanley2's profile

stanley2

305 posts in 2396 days


#1 posted 2086 days ago

Scott – I agree with you; most of us get inspiration from other objects we see – it’s pretty rare to have a new idea. Even G & G got their inspiration from the Japanese and Chinese cultures although they never went to Asia. I was in Pasadena for the Craftsmans Weekend and it was truly awesome and inspiring. I noticed that often their breadboard ends were proud of the surface, which I found interesting. I made a side trip and had the good fortune of meeting Sam Maloof after a tour of his property.

-- Phil in British Columbia

View MsDebbieP's profile

MsDebbieP

18615 posts in 2761 days


#2 posted 2086 days ago

very interesting indeed.

it is nice that you get the opportunity to compare and give yourself a pat on the back for different elements that you used.

-- ~ Debbie, Canada (https://www.facebook.com/DebbiePribeleENJOConsultant)

View USCJeff's profile

USCJeff

1044 posts in 2669 days


#3 posted 2086 days ago

I’m with you, don’t think I’d be too bothered by it. I suppose the only problem I’d have is if it’s a design to be sold by the original craftsmans that’s copied and sold in the same market so as to lower sales. Being an amatuer, I would see it as a pretty cool compliment.

-- Jeff, South Carolina

View Shopsmithtom's profile

Shopsmithtom

780 posts in 2796 days


#4 posted 2086 days ago

I like yours better. I agree on the breadboard ends and the legs.
I always browse lots of pics on the web before designing my stuff, so to some degree, I’m pirating a little bit here & there…oh well. -SST

-- Accuracy is not in your power tool, it's in you

View Allison's profile

Allison

819 posts in 2400 days


#5 posted 2086 days ago

And all I am going to say is when I clicked on the first link, the one that is not yours, it said 404 not found. But I guess it’s my computer but the others above me obviously were able to link on it, so I should probably just keep my big mouth shut ! LOL!!! But I do like yours. Gosh my father would love something like this!

Oops on my part here Okay I simply came from my e-mail from a buddy, I am guilty of not noticing that you posted the picture here, although I did just try again and did not get the link, but I definitely like yours better!

-- Allison, Northeastern Ca. Remember, Amateurs built the Ark. Professionals built the Titanic!

View ChicoWoodnut's profile

ChicoWoodnut

904 posts in 2416 days


#6 posted 2086 days ago

We see dead web pages <g>

-- Scott - Chico California http://chicowoodnut.home.comcast.net

View Napaman's profile

Napaman

5315 posts in 2678 days


#7 posted 2086 days ago

either way…nice project…I will have to bring you a bottle of Napa WINE…

-- Matt--Proud LJ since 2007

View jockmike2's profile

jockmike2

10635 posts in 2847 days


#8 posted 2085 days ago

Very cool Scott, nice job, I like yours better.

-- (You just have to please the man in the Mirror) Mike from Michigan -

View Topapilot's profile

Topapilot

164 posts in 2441 days


#9 posted 2084 days ago

The company that the top project comes from sells plans to other woodworkers products; i.e. I’ve purchased plans for Darrell Pearts Aurora Nightstand from them. I assume he gets a percentage of that. Could it be the original you drew your insperation from is what they are selling? Or is it simply “form follows function”?

BTW, I’m building the nightstand now, and the plans/instructions require through review and careful corrections before cutting. Lots of mistakes and inconsistancies; clearly no one took the time to review the package before printing them up and shipping them out.

View Grumpy's profile

Grumpy

19319 posts in 2452 days


#10 posted 2084 days ago

Looks like some opportunist thought you were on a winner Scott. I think they were right.

-- Grumpy - "Always look on the bright side of life"- Monty Python

View ChicoWoodnut's profile

ChicoWoodnut

904 posts in 2416 days


#11 posted 2084 days ago

As I recall the original had the sliding doors. My recollection is dim though. I have a pile of drawings with different versions.

I hope somebody is making money though. Heck, I made two and gave one away as a wedding present.

-- Scott - Chico California http://chicowoodnut.home.comcast.net

View Padre's profile

Padre

930 posts in 2090 days


#12 posted 2084 days ago

I like yours better!

-- Chip -----------http://www.penmanchip.com-----------------Micah 6:8

View LeeinEdmonton's profile

LeeinEdmonton

252 posts in 2182 days


#13 posted 2084 days ago

Heck, I copy all the time ! But original enough that when I do there is usually differences in the project. Sometimes due to my skill limitations, or equipment limitations, or just plain gotta be different. I do this even when I have book plans on wooden toys. My theory being that the author made his projects to sell & time is money. Me….time means nothing. Example: Everyone has seen and many of us have made the waddling duck pull toy. I always modify it when I make it. The wings are seperate from the body & of contrasting wood. The duck not only waddles but it quacks as well hence the head is also seperate from the body & of contrasting wood. A toymaker making toys to sell simply cannot spend that kind of time on such details & still make a living. As my toys are donated to inner city kids at Christmas, I would be surprised if the toymaker would feel bad about the way I treat his design.

-- Lee

View tbone's profile

tbone

256 posts in 2285 days


#14 posted 2083 days ago

Scott, I agree with you on the tapered legs. Theirs looks a little top-heavy, whereas yours seems well proportioned.

-- Kinky Friedman on gay marriage: "They should have the right to be just as miserable as the rest of us."

Have your say...

You must be signed in to reply.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

GardenTenders.com :: gardening showcase