LumberJocks

How to get started when space and budget is an issue...

  • Advertise with us

« back to Woodworking Skill Share forum

Forum topic by Ed_Wilcox posted 287 days ago 756 views 0 times favorited 25 replies Add to Favorites Watch
View Ed_Wilcox's profile

Ed_Wilcox

15 posts in 404 days


287 days ago

What would you recommend as the best options for someone wanting to get more involved in woodworking.

Here is my situation, I am in the military so budgeting and space (weight allowance) has always been an issue. Even now we are packing for Fort Hood… which is a blessing since Hood has a wood shop, but having access may be a problem.

I have been considering a few of my own options:

1. Stick to hand tools, but quality puts a dent in the budget. According to the Frau, a $100+ hand plane “is not in the budget”, but $80 hair cut and dye every month or two is.

2. Trade quality hand tools for the depot, lowe end budget power tools; i.e. Ryobi table saw starting around $299 is the lowest quality I would be willing to put my money into – but then space eventually becomes an issue.

3. To save space I recently discovered Shopsmith… I have to admit the concept is intriguing, and the reviews are typical… people either love it or they despise it for killing a loved one. Has anyone had experience with this contraption? I see several on Craig’s – none of the MK 7. But the idea of investing a couple hundred, and upgrading as I can appeals to me. I certainly couldn’t afford a new model at 4k.

So, out of curiosity, how did you get started? What would you recommend to the new kid on the block? – short of killing the wife… she’s a great cook.


25 replies so far

View knotscott's profile

knotscott

5154 posts in 1881 days


#1 posted 287 days ago

The budget issue is best solved with good used tools IMO (if the opportunity arises…watch Craigslist and the classifieds here). Going the route of cheap new tools will yield lesser performance, lower value, and more money wasted in the long run.

The space issue is tougher to tame, and will require some creativity and compromise. All big tools should be on wheels, portable versions may need to suffice, and some things may need to perform double duty. Ie: May workbench doubles as an outfeed table for my table saw. My TS has the router table built into an extension wing. One of the guided circular saw systems may need to play the role of a good TS.

-- Happiness is like wetting your pants...everyone can see it, but only you can feel the warmth....

View Smitty_Cabinetshop's profile

Smitty_Cabinetshop

9130 posts in 1124 days


#2 posted 287 days ago

There are Shopsmith lovers here. I suggest a ‘search’ within LJs will turn up a few. Here a projects tagged woth shopsmith; check for tags in blogs and you may be surprised.

http://lumberjocks.com/projects/tag/shopsmith

Send them a note and see what they think, good luck, and thank you for your service!

-- Don't anthropomorphize your handplanes. They hate it when you do that. -- OldTools Archive

View Gary's profile

Gary

6124 posts in 1938 days


#3 posted 287 days ago

Someone posted:
My wife and I had words
I didn’t get to use mine

-- Gary, DeKalb Texas only 4 miles from the mill

View Charlie's profile

Charlie

1001 posts in 792 days


#4 posted 287 days ago

Nobody has asked so I guess it’s up to me…

What do you want to DO with your woodworking tools? What do you want to build? Pretty tough to advise you without knowing that.

That being said…. or asked, as the case may be….

Hand tools are a great option. And a good hand plane doesn’t have to cost $100+. I didn’t pay more than $20 for any of mine except for a big Anant jointer plane that was one of the first ones I bought. A good cleaning, sharpen the iron, flatten the sole if necessary and away you go. The time spent getting to know the tools is every bit as important as the time spent using them.

GET A DECENT HAND SAW. They’re cheap. Doesn’t have to be a gold plated one. I have a mid-sized Dewalt hand saw that I think I got for less than $30 at Home Depot. In my opinion… and it may be worth what I’m charging for it…. who knows… a cheap table saw won’t give you the precision that you buy a table saw for. So learn to measure and cut accurately with the hand saw…

OR….

Get a decent circular saw and make some edge guides. You don’t need one of the fancy track saws. They’re nice, but we’re talking budget and space and all that. I’d suggest making at least 2 guides for your circular saw. A 4 ft one and one made to cut a 90 degree cross cut. A sliding miter on one of the fold-up rolling stands is a nice addition for later.

A good drill. I use the heck out of my cordless. It’s a 20v Dewalt. I have a drill press too. A small one. And it’s hard to do what a drill press does best without a drill press, but I got along without one for a long time until space and budget allowed me to get one.

Hand tools don’t have to cost an arm and a leg. And very often you’ll find you can accomplish something by grabbing a hand plane or a hand saw in less time than it would take you to set up a machine to do the job.

Which brings us back to…. what would you like to DO with your woodworking?

View BArnold's profile

BArnold

166 posts in 338 days


#5 posted 287 days ago

Many years ago, my father had a ShopSmith that he used extensively. His shop space was limited to half of a two-car garage. When he died, I inherited the ShopSmith along with the rest of his tools. I was just starting to do more advanced projects and quickly found that the tablesaw setup on the SS was not going to work for me. It had been fine for my father since her did smaller items. I began to purchase dedicated tools for the convenience and power they provide. So, the bottom line is as with all discussions of this type: decide what you’re going to do in the way of projects, then determine what tool lineup you want.

-- Bill, Thomasville, GA

View Ed_Wilcox's profile

Ed_Wilcox

15 posts in 404 days


#6 posted 287 days ago

Charlie, I’m glad you thought to ask, because I didn’t think to mention it. First I have been planning a workbench based on a folding design for myself. Many of the other projects my wife has asked me to do are simple designs. A couple plans from Anna White – a country diner table with bench and an outdoor patio set. Nothing too fancy, but I want to add a little style using dowels and wedges. That way I get some practice and it won’t look cheap.

After those, there are three other projects in the back of my mind that I think will eventually build off of those.

The first would be a coffee table/storage chest we both liked. It was a simple design with a split top that opened on drawer slides. The furniture store wanted $600. No way I’m paying for it when I can build it.

The last two I believe may require a lot more experience. Since I have been quarantined to two little drawers and one medium at the very bottom of the one dresser we share, I want a campaign chest/dresser drawer to match our current bedroom furniture with a couple features added in so that she knows it’s mine.

The third is a one-day-maybe project. I want to convert my mountain-bike into a trike for physical reasons, and if it’s possible, why not build the frame out of wood. I have a wood magazine somewhere that showed how to make an amazing rocker with, not simple, but basic joinery. I believe – one day – I might be able to use the same process to construct a light but solid frame.

It’s a goal to strive for anyway.

View 8iowa's profile

8iowa

1489 posts in 2267 days


#7 posted 287 days ago

Many years ago I started with a few hardware store tools and worked on the kitchen table in our small apartment. You know, at the time I didn’t feel disadvantaged. In ‘83 I purchased a Shopsmith model 500 with the bandsaw and 4” jointer. I only had 1/2 of a small garage to work in.

I suspect that the “inherited” Shopsmith mentioned above was a 500, with it’s small table. There has been considerable improvement in the tool since the era of the 500. Many Shopsmith’s on the used market today are the model 510 with the larger table, two floating tables and connecting tubes. This has transformed the Shopsmith into a big “jig” that can be configured many ways depending on the sawing requirements. With a helper, often my wife, I can rip 4’ x 8’ sheets of plywood.

Take a look at used 510’s, better yet a 520 if you can find one. They often go for under $1000 and often include some accessory tools such as the bandsaw and jointer. If you have any questions concerning a machine that you are considering send me a PM. I’ll be glad to help.

All this being said, Christopher Schwarz and his “Lost Art Press” have “infected” me with hand tool working. I now have a nice collection of older Stanley hand planes that I have re-furbed. The cost was minimal. Even my $9 Ace Hardware backsaw gives good service.

-- "Heaven is North of the Bridge"

View Don W's profile

Don W

13961 posts in 1073 days


#8 posted 287 days ago

I’m with knotscott. Good quality tools (especially vintage) can be found resonabley, especially if you don’t mind restoring them yourself. Some are the best quality and many good ones can be bought for the cost of a cup of coffee.

I tend to buy tools when they are cheap (not cheap tools, just good tools cheap), rather than when I need them. I make due with the tools I have had untill a deal comes along.

-- There is nothing like the sound of a well tuned hand plane. - http://timetestedtools.wordpress.com (timetestedtools at hotmail dot c0m)

View Straightbowed's profile

Straightbowed

717 posts in 803 days


#9 posted 287 days ago

buy 1 quality tool at a time learn to use handtools and as the money grows so will your choice of tools, if you buy a tool just say a tablesaw buy one that will last if you buy on the cheap it will fold on you when your tryin to do a big project, handtools will make your fit a hundred times better as you learn to use them, lets say you make a box and you just want to glue a bottom in if you use the tablesaw you will make many trips and then you may overcut but with a handplane you can take passesand get a flawless tight fit go the handtool route then your need for powertools will be easy because you will know exactly what you need

-- Stevo, work in tha city woodshop in the country

View Straightbowed's profile

Straightbowed

717 posts in 803 days


#10 posted 287 days ago

I started out with a 79.00 delta saw then I thought I really done a upgrade to a 179.00 crapsman will it blew up but my little delta kept on truckin it took me 6 years to get all good heavy tools but now I don’t have time to use them buy good heavy tools or the shopsmith could be your answer I like to build boxes I guess a shopsmith would have been the cats meow for me but I went heavy cause I wanted them to be there when I retire if I live that long craglist has tons of good quality tools and some really good deals and ebay for your handplanes you can get some great deals on the Ebay

-- Stevo, work in tha city woodshop in the country

View crank49's profile

crank49

3249 posts in 1476 days


#11 posted 287 days ago

A wood bike is definitely possible. The picture in my avatar is a bamboo road bike.

As far as military lifestyle restrictions are concerned I understand because my son has been in the USAF for 20 years and he has had to adapt and come up with mobile shop solutions.

One key is to think multipurpose. Like, a good power drill does more than just drill holes. Get a variable speed, reversing hammer drill and you can drill holes in concrete, wood, or metal and drive and extract screws as well.
Good power tools to handle most situations would be a circular saw, a jig saw, a 1/2” drill, a 2hp (1/2” collet) router with 2 bases, and a random orbit sander. I’d be reluctant to go used for power tools, especially battery powered ones. Don’t forget to budget for bits and blades.

As said before, good used hand tools are a great solution. the older hand tools are almost always better quality than the new stuff in the box stores unless you get into the really expensive tools. For example, a good old Stanley block plane is just as good as, or better than, anything you can buy new for 4 or 5 times the money.

Good set of hand tools would be a couple of planes, a block and a #4 or #5, couple of chisels, a 1/4” and a 1/2”, squares, bevel gauge, good straight edge and/or a steel rule. Note: be sure the graduations on the rule are etched and not just printed.

A Stanley “Sharp Tooth” hand saw, as available at Home Depot for about $12, is one of the few modern hand tools I would rather have than a vintage version. I like the wood handled version that’s about $23, but the plastic handled version has the same blade. A small, fine tooth Japanese pull saw is very handy as well. If you don’t start out with a powered jig saw, a coping saw is cheap and lets you cut curves.

Then there is the work place. If you are in base housing like an apartment you might have to use something like a Black & Decker Workmate. They are really pretty good to have even in a garage shop. They have a built in vise and fold up out of the way when not being used. Could even be stored in the back of a closet. These are often found on Craig’s list.

Finally, don’t forget the clamps. If you are near a Harbor Freight, pick you up a few of their aluminum bar clamps. Then for heavy clamping some pipe clamps can be made any size you need by just adding to the pipe. If you have to relocate, loose the pipe and keep the clamp parts. You can always get more pipe.

-- Michael :-{| Diapers and politicians both need to be changed often; and for the same reason.

View rfusca's profile

rfusca

155 posts in 349 days


#12 posted 287 days ago

I’ll echo the vintage sentiment – I picked up a number 4,5,6, and 7 hand plane for less than 100 total. Put in a little elbow grease and they’re wonderful. Ebay is practically overflowing with vintage saws.
You may even check out the ‘gems’ at Harbor Freight – some of their items are perfectly fine. Their blue clamps are good and the pocket hole (you did mention Ana White ;) ) jig there is better built and far cheaper than the Kreg.

-- Chris S., North Atlanta, GA - woodworker,DBA, cook, photographer

View a1Jim's profile

a1Jim

109540 posts in 2082 days


#13 posted 287 days ago

Hi Ed
Thank you for your service to our country.
I’m not a fan of tools that convert(like Shop smith) from one operation to another simply because once you set up to say saw you need to use a drill press you have to convert over to that tool and then back again to a saw or something else. The other thing deceptive about Shop Smith tools is that there taunted to take up a small foot print in shops but the thing people forget about when considering this type of tool is each accessory has to be stored when not in use.
The other issue is all of those accessories cost ,some almost as much as a free standing tools there suppose to replace. The cost of the main Shop smith plus accessories can cost more than good used tools that may do their prospective job better.
I don’t know what your budget might be or what kind of weight or space limitations are so my best guess is if you can get a table saw and some use hand tools that might be a good start. The type of table saw you could get will depend on what power you will have available ,how mobile it has to be and of course cost. There are some very light table saws that have folding stands that are used on job sites that might work but I must admit they would not be my first choice given the tops are small compared to more stationary saws. A little saw I owned years ago made buy Ryobi had a larger top and was light weight might work too, it was a bt3000 I believe sears sells a newer version,again not my top choice if you had more room in a at home shop. Knotscot has a very good blog about table saws that might be helpful http://lumberjocks.com/knotscott/blog/32154 .

After a table saw some basics will help like a circular saw,a hand held jig saw,cordless drill, a router and a few bits, a few clamps,a Radium orbital sander , some measuring tools like : a combination and framing square,6”rule and measuring tape,plus the bench you want to make should give you the most basic start. After you have some basics you can make things like outfeed tables and other jigs and fixtures that are much cheaper to make rather than buy. If I can help with questions feel free to send me PMs and I’ll be glad to help.

-- http://artisticwoodstudio.com Custom furniture

View DS's profile

DS

2085 posts in 926 days


#14 posted 287 days ago

Stolen from Steven Covey’s book; Take baby steps… Start with the end in mind.
Add a piece at a time until you eventually get to where you are going.

I set aside a portion of each project’s proceeds to upgrade tools, or my shop space.
I made do with a circular saw and a straight edge before i could afford a tablesaw.
Used tools are a miracle as well. Every few years I get to celebrate a terrific find on a quality used tool that changes the entire dynamic of my shop.

If I’m bidding a job I know will need a speciific tool that I don’t have, I usually add a little wiggle room in the bid to purchase that tool. It’s a great way to expand over time.

-- "Hard work is not defined by the difficulty of the task as much as a person's desire to perform it.", DS251

View fuzzface's profile

fuzzface

40 posts in 376 days


#15 posted 287 days ago

Let me add my 2ยข worth on the Shopsmith. I bought a 512 about 12 years ago. My workshop was confined to a 2 car garage. To the basic unit, I added a jointer, bandsaw and belt sander. During that time I built some very nice stuff, including a grandfather clock, sideboard, blanket chest, sofa table, headboard and dresser. I can tell you that the SS is very well built, and customer service is excellent. As you become familiar with it, you really appreciate the ingenious design. Setups can be a pain, but you learn to anticipate your needs to minimize this. Is it as good as dedicated machinery? Of course not. But the SS is not designed for someone with a 5 acre workshop. It is designed for those of us who have limited space. SS is an excellent way to get a lot of woodworking capability in a small area. For that, I thank them. I recently retired and built a ranch house with a 10 ft walkout basement. I’m in the process of ordering a crapload of dedicated machinery, but the SS will still occupy a corner of the new workshop. I’ll still us it as a lathe, drill press and horizontal borer. Hope this is helpful.

-- I'm a LumberJock and I'm OK.............. I sleep all night and I work all day !!

showing 1 through 15 of 25 replies

Have your say...

You must be signed in to reply.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

GardenTenders.com :: gardening showcase