Hatchet or Knife?

  • Advertise with us

« back to Hand Tools forum

Forum topic by Mike posted 459 days ago 830 views 0 times favorited 21 replies Add to Favorites Watch
View Mike's profile


289 posts in 1286 days

459 days ago

Well this might sound crazy to some of you, but here it is. I am picking up and just driving across the US since there isn’t any reason to stay where I am since there is no work. I’ll be camping in the backwoods in a lot of National parks for the fun of it. Here is my question; other than a tree saw which I might be bringing, what do you think I should bring? Would a hatchet be more useful than a knife (the multi tool is already coming but the blade is terrible)? Is there something I should be considering too?



-- look Ma! I still got all eleven of my fingers! -

21 replies so far

View jap's profile


1224 posts in 653 days

#1 posted 459 days ago

I would take both, they are not that big.

-- Joel

View Bill White's profile

Bill White

3343 posts in 2559 days

#2 posted 459 days ago

And sharpen everything well. Wassamater with the multi-tool?


View crank49's profile


3338 posts in 1570 days

#3 posted 459 days ago

Going to be stealth camping?
A small bow saw, spare blade, knife and hatchet would all be very useful.
Nylon cord and duct tape are also very handy to have.

-- Michael :-{| “If you tell a big enough lie and tell it frequently enough, it will be believed.” ― A H

View muleskinner's profile


662 posts in 1035 days

#4 posted 459 days ago

If by “camping in the backwoods” you mean you’ll be packing in to your campsite then leave the hatchet. Extra weight you don’t need, a lot of national parks restrict campfires, where there is adequate fuel for a backcountry fire dead branches are easily broken by hand and make a satisfactory fire. Even a small hatchet is too much weight given it’s usefulness in national park backcountry. I’ve gotten by for 40 years with just a 3” folding knife.

If car camping, take an ax.

-- Visualize whirled peas

View Mike's profile


289 posts in 1286 days

#5 posted 459 days ago

I’ll be packing in and out for the most part. I’ll be most likely driving to the trail heads. Yellowstone will be the first stop.

-- look Ma! I still got all eleven of my fingers! -

View TerryDowning's profile


998 posts in 716 days

#6 posted 459 days ago

if you’re packing skip the hatchet. muleskinner said it best.
a 3” locking folder with a smooth blade or a good multi-tool are much better options.
don’t forget something to sharpen with.

-- - Terry

View JoeinGa's profile


3094 posts in 606 days

#7 posted 459 days ago

Hmmmm, a small camper’s hatchet will lay flat on the rear floorboard of your car and take up very little room. Why not just throw one back there… “Just in case”

-- Perform A Random Act Of Kindness Today ... Pay It Forward

View Loren's profile


7234 posts in 2247 days

#8 posted 459 days ago

A Mora fixed blade knife will set you back about $20. It
is a superior little laminated carbon steel knife from Sweden
which takes and holds a superior edge and is very
tough to break.

While you can split kindling with a Mora or a robust
folding knife, a hatchet is the right tool for the job.


View muleskinner's profile


662 posts in 1035 days

#9 posted 459 days ago

Mike, considering your #5, a hatchet is dead weight.

-- Visualize whirled peas

View nwbusa's profile


1016 posts in 885 days

#10 posted 459 days ago

I’d personally have a fixed blade knife and a small axe.

-- John, BC, Canada

View moment's profile


2102 posts in 1280 days

#11 posted 459 days ago

You might also need a .357 in case you are bothered by a grizzly bear , and… ,even more important ,

plenty of t.p. and a good latrine shovel .


View BigYin's profile


228 posts in 1015 days

#12 posted 459 days ago

-a good quality 4 or 5 inch knife (loren is right about the Mora brand)
-a sharpener for knife & hatchet
-a good 1 pound hatchet with steel shank one piece forging
-a good pair of side cutting pliers
-water purification tablets
If your only going to take a knife take a Ka-Bar and get a Kydex molded sheeth ($15-$18) for it to protect the blade and you from the blade

-- ... Never Apologise For Being Right ...

View Bluepine38's profile


2876 posts in 1684 days

#13 posted 458 days ago

If you are asking these questions, it sounds as though you have not been camping very much, if at all. There
should be some area near you that allows camping. I would do some practice camping before you set off into
the wild blue yonder. A backpack stove will give you enough heat to cook meals. Primus is an old standby. I
have an old small Coleman (discontinued) that burns unleaded gas-readily available now- and this will eliminate
the need for a cookfire. It is and will continue to be cold in Yellowstone and other parks for a while. We
can get mountain storms in July, so you will need good clothing that can handle temps from -10 to 70 or more.
this will add some weight, REI and other scources can give you some info on camping. If you are going to
build a fire in the backcountry, you will need a shovel to clear the duff-burnable leaves, etc- from the fire pit
area or find a rocky area for your fire. A good folding steel camp shovel with a sharpened edge is a wonderful
tool and can substitute as a hatchet. You will need a good tent or a tarp with good grommets and rope.
plus a good sleeping bag. Once again do some practice camping. Being in the backcounty with no experience
and the wrong weather can be fatal. The wrong type of campfire can be trouble. The is an old saying,
The white man builds a big fire and stands far away, the Indian builds a small fire and sets close. I have done
lots of camping with my boys and others, done right it is wonderful, done wrong as McManus says it is “A
fine and pleasant misery.”

-- As ever, Gus-the 75 yr young apprentice carpenter

View JohnChung's profile


221 posts in 673 days

#14 posted 458 days ago

I am not sure to what extend do you want to live outdoors. But hiking will weigh you down with an axe. If you just need to cut branches I would suggest you bring a foldable saw instead.

View muleskinner's profile


662 posts in 1035 days

#15 posted 458 days ago

Mount Ferry and Ferry Basin

Picture for Mike

-- Visualize whirled peas

showing 1 through 15 of 21 replies

Have your say...

You must be signed in to reply.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics :: gardening showcase