workbench vices -- tail vs. double screw end

dpjeansonne, I have a tail vise on my Ulmia bench. It is used with the bench dogs for holding pieces on the top surfaces for various tasks. But that is definitely not its only use. The space in the “jaws” is extremely useful and I use it frequently. It has excellent holding power and because of its design, there is no wracking. A double screw vise on the end of a bench will perform pretty much the same functions. I have never used a bench with one, so I can’t offer advice on that. Having said that, I think a tail vise suits my methods well and don’t think I would trade it.

-- Mike

I have a face vise mounted on the end of my bench, near the front. I have dog holes in the top of the vise so I can clamp long pieces between the vise and dogs anywhere along the length of my bench.
I did it this way because I had my bench pretty much built before I thought about some kind of vise on the end.
At that point a tail vise would have been a major pain to install.

A twin screw would pretty much work the same way, but would have the advantage of being able to clamp boards vertically between the screws for cutting dovetails and such. My choice not to go with a twin screw was pretty much a financial one.

-- Michael :-{| Diapers and politicians both need to be changed often; and for the same reason.

I have both a Lie Nielsen tail vice and twin screw on my bench. As far as clamping a board between dogs, the tail vice is going to win out. It has more options for clamping different lengths. The sliding portion on mine has evenly spaced holes. On the bench they are variably spaced. This means I only have to move the vice an inch or two to line up with two holes. On a twin screw you may need to move the vice up to say 6 in.

The tail vice also allows you to clamp between the jaws at odd angles. With this said, the twin screw works very nice and adds clamping options that a tail vice can’t. My advice, get both, but if cost is a concern, you can get by with just using a twin screw on the end.