Rounded Tenons

Sounds like you are on the correct track. Usually for mortise and tenons that will not show I use the same method. The rounding of the tenon does not have to be perfect since the strength of the joint is the flat glue surfaces. For close to the shoulder I use a chisel to finish shaping the round.

-- Jesse, Saint Louis, Missouri

Eric,

Many people use a router jig with this, often horizontally mounted and/or with bearing guided bits.

The way you did this is a very popular way as well. I would make sure that you get a good wood rasp (as opposed to a file) to do the work. It shouldn’t take too long with the right tool(s).

BTW, I normally chisel the mortise square rather than to round the tenon…it becomes quick and easy with practice. I feel there is less guessing that way. And besides, I feel it’s an important skill to have when those tenons become the “through” variety.

Or, you could chicken out and just buy one of them fancy Festool Domino things. ;)

-- jay, www.allaboutastro.com

That’s the way I do it. Nothing wrong with your method, you can clean them up a little better if you rough w/ the rasp and finalize w/ a file and a bit of judicious work w/ a chisel.

-- Bondo Gaposis

Cosmic,
I can definitely see where you are coming from with the difference between a rounded tenon or squared mortise. I think I will give the squared mortise a try and see how that goes as well!

I didn’t figure there was a magic trick to it since it is so simple, I just had to question my methodology since I am such a novice :)

-- "Only put off until tomorrow what you are willing to die having left undone." -- Pablo Picasso

research rounded tenons and floating tenons. i believe, the standard historical basis on square mortise and tenons is because of the use of hand tools. rounded seems more practical if you will be using power tools.
from what i gathered, there is not “strength” difference from square to rounded. which also applies to floating tenons. if i were to be doing 10+ mortise and tenons on power tools, i would definitely consider floating tenons.

Wow, floating tenons sure would seem to be the way I need to go. I am going to have 16 MT joints and that would greatly help the process and accurate repetitiveness of all the joints. The only downside would be the initial set up time with creating a jig for the mortises but it seems like that would save time in the long run.

-- "Only put off until tomorrow what you are willing to die having left undone." -- Pablo Picasso