Dye Ambrosia maple - should i give it up?

I am not a staining expert and Charles Neil would probably be the best resource to drop a line to. However, I would personally avoid dye or stain in this particular case and, if my goal were to darken, I would probably lean towards a dilluted BLO mix. The piece is beautiful light and I would, at most, add dark wood accents and leave the color as is.

-- There is little that is simple when it comes to making a simple box.

Practice on scraps first and use many different types of finishes and
stains until you find one that you like.

A Wood Conditioner applied first prevents blotching.

Good luck Brobab and welcome to LJ’s.

Ack! I would say give up!!

I am definitely biased to a natural look for wood, but I think you get a wood like ambrosia maple for its interesting grain/character and staining it really kills that. I am with David, maybe try something like BLO that is slightly tinted, but other than that, I would leave it pretty natural.

Another vote for leaving it natural. :-)

-- "hold fast to that which is good"

Yeah, me too, go natural! A clear oil based finish will add a nice amber glow w/o making it blotchy or hiding the figure.

-- Bondo Gaposis

Danish oil or BLO will darken it somewhat and, IMO, enhance the natural beauty of the wood. I just don’t think stain or dye is a good choice for ambrosia maple. Maybe someone will post a link to something to prove otherwise..

-- Charlie M. "Woodworking - patience = firewood"

After, my last post, I did a quick Google search for images of both stained and dyed ambrosia maple. Most of the search results showed wood that had been only slightly darkened, as with an oil finish. The image below came up under the “dyed” search. It’s an interesting piece, but I don’t know if that’s what you want for your tabletop.

-- Charlie M. "Woodworking - patience = firewood"

Maple blotches a lot when stained. My preferance is to use the right wood and leave it natural.

-- Mother Nature created it, I just assemble it. - It's not ability that we often lack, but the patience to use our ability

Don’t stain it. Use a washcoat of shellac, which will help pop the figure. If you then want to darken it, use your color in the finish, not directly on the wood. You can use TransTint dyes with shellac/lacquer/water-borne varnish OR an oil-based stain mixed in some oil-based poly. As always, experiment on scrap.

-- jay, www.allaboutastro.com

Was just about to say what Cosmicsniper said. For a nice piece like that, it would be well worth getting a darker grade of shellac flake to make your own, so you can getting something with a deeper tone than the amber/oranges most commonly seen.

Thanks for all the quick replies. Very satisfying first post. I am going to leave this more natural – but play with it a bit as some have described above. Just got back from the lumber yard today with Mahogany to “re-make” the top. Lucked out and found some 13.5” wide 5/4 that has some interesting grain. I know it will be pretty and do what I need it to do for this project – just not as excited about the wood as I was with the ambrosia – on the other hand, I have a great project to crank out over the weekend!

Certain oils will darken maple up pretty well.. Danish Oil took some of my spalted maple and made it a perfect golden brown.. like a golden retriever’s coat

-- Dan, Rochester, NY

+1 to Superstretch. Before using any oil based products on maple, test and allow it to sit for a few days to a week as it will continue to darken and possibly yellow. If you look at my projects there are some spalted maple with an oil finish.

-- -- Rick M.