LumberJocks

Planer, dewalt dw734 or Makita 2012NB?

  • Advertise with us

« back to Power Tools, Hardware and Accessories forum

Forum topic by Iggles88 posted 957 days ago 8742 views 1 time favorited 15 replies Add to Favorites Watch
View Iggles88's profile

Iggles88

243 posts in 962 days


957 days ago

Looking for some help on choosing my planer, I can get the dewalt for 350 or the Makita for 525….from what I’ve read it sounds like the Makita is a very good unit, the dewalt has gotten mixed reviews from a lot of people….is the Makita worth the extra money? The Makita is where I’m leaning


15 replies so far

View Blakep's profile

Blakep

232 posts in 1404 days


#1 posted 957 days ago

I have had the 734 for almost 2 years now and so far no problems at all. For the price of the Makita you are getting into the range of the larger Dewalt (I don’t know the model number) but it has more features than the 734 and it just looks like more planner. I saw it on sale the other day, maybe at Lowes but I can’t remember for sure, for $500 and something dollars. I would probably look into it.

View NBeener's profile

NBeener

4806 posts in 1775 days


#2 posted 957 days ago

It’s the 735, and … it usually ranks as #1 in the category … IF you get/buy/make in/outfeed tables.

-- -- Neil

View zindel's profile

zindel

256 posts in 1251 days


#3 posted 957 days ago

well right now there is the dewalt 735x i think…that comes with the tables i have seen it on Amazon…However i have read 2 reviews from fine woodworking one on the 735 and one for the Makita sadly they don’t put them head to head, but the one where he reviewed the Makita made it sound like it was the best planer in the world. where the one where he reviewed the 735 it came in a tie with something else. I myself am gonna get the Makita. They sell it online at home depot for less than Amazon does. I have yet to read a bad review from the Makita. And i figure if i gets just as good or better of a cut as the 735 does then i will go with the Makita considering the 735 needs 3 blades where makita only needs 2. Same cut less blades sounds like better quality to me.

-- If you can't fix it with a hammer, You've got an electrical problem.

View knotscott's profile

knotscott

5369 posts in 1977 days


#4 posted 957 days ago

While I like the Makita, if I were spending that kind of money I’d either look to the DW735 or the Steel City with the helical cutter head. The 734 at $350 should a nice job for you…mixed reviews are often a result of selling a lot of units. I suspect the DW outsells the Makita by a wide margin, which increases the chance of someone getting a defective unit….folks are more likely to post a complaint than they are kudos. If you’re buying it new, it’ll have a warranty and possibly return privileges, so I wouldn’t worry too much.

-- Happiness is like wetting your pants...everyone can see it, but only you can feel the warmth....

View Blakep's profile

Blakep

232 posts in 1404 days


#5 posted 957 days ago

I would have to agree with knotscott. In most cases I like Makita over Dewalt but in this case I would take the 735 over the Makita. Also I would much rather have 3 blades than 2. The 734 also has three blades and as I said before I love mine but if money wasn’t a issue then I would have bought the 735 over the 734 any day. I just left Lowes a few minutes ago and the 735 was on sale for $569.

View Iggles88's profile

Iggles88

243 posts in 962 days


#6 posted 957 days ago

I gotta be honest guys Im really leaning towards the Makita, I have read a ton of reviews and the Makita seems like its a very high quality machine, and the 735 didn’t get good reviews…the Makita also had much more reviews then the 735 so the amount sold wouldn’t come into play….i didn’t even mention the 735 in the question because of the reviews. I love dewalt tools I have a few of them and love them so it’s not anything against dewalt I just usually go with reviews and they haven’t let me down yet

View Blakep's profile

Blakep

232 posts in 1404 days


#7 posted 957 days ago

In the end its all about what you want and what makes you happy because you are the one spending the money and the one who will be using it. I can only speak from my experiences with the 734 and they have been great. The only reason I mentioned the 735 is because it has the extra features such as the four post that locks and the two speeds and the fact that it was in the price range of the makita. If you are limiting it to the 734 and the Makita then its hard for me to justify $200 more for the Makita when they look alot alike and the Dewalt is a 3 blade planer and the Makita is a 2 blade. Which ever one you choose you will probably be satisfied and if it is the Makita then let us know how it works for you because I haven’t heard much about them. Here is a link I found for a review of the Makita if you would like to check it out. http://thicknessplaner.org/makita-thickness-planer-2012nb
If you look to the right of the page it has some reviews for other planers as well. Another one that I would have looked at when I got mine if it would have been out is the Delta. Its about the same price as the Makita. I haven’t ready much about them but they seem pretty nice. There are tons out there to choose from so just pick the one that makes you happy and start planing.

View live4ever's profile

live4ever

982 posts in 1611 days


#8 posted 957 days ago

From the prices you’ve listed, I’m guessing you’re shopping at Amazon. I took a gander at the reviews for the 735 and wow, I couldn’t believe it. Normally I rely heavily on Amazon reviews, but for whatever reason I didn’t look at them before getting the 735. If I had, I probably would have shied away as well. FWIW, there seems to be a huge huge discrepancy between those Amazon reviews and general experience on WW forums regarding the 735. Usually, that’s not the case – at least I haven’t seen it in all my tool research.

Aside from it being a screamer, I do enjoy my 735, but you won’t go wrong with either planer. If the review situation makes you feel better, by all means go Makita and start making some planer dust!!

-- Optimists are usually disappointed. Pessimists are either right or pleasantly surprised. I tend to be a disappointed pessimist.

View Tyler's profile

Tyler

174 posts in 1295 days


#9 posted 957 days ago

I have a Makita and have liked is so far. Snipe isn’t bad with the in/out feed tables (or trays) attached. Mine came with a nik in a blade so i try to avoid that side. Not sure if I can sharpen them or if I have to get new blades. I guess I’ll have to do some research.

Make sure to get the dust collector attachment!

View BullVictory's profile

BullVictory

56 posts in 1123 days


#10 posted 951 days ago

I have the 735 and its awesome except for the blades. Most of the negative reviews I’ve seen are about the blades. The stock dewalt blades don’t last very long and chip easily. Even running poplar on it they dull quickly leaving burn marks on the wood. Being double sided, and quick setup, you can’t have them re-sharpened. I recently got some third party blades from Global Tooling (http://globaltooling.bizhosting.com/products/knives-planer/portable-planer-jointer-knife-sets.html) which cost less than the stock dewalt replacements and seem to be lasting longer so far. I still need to run some more boards over them, but so far they seem to be be preforming better than the stock dewalts. I’ve heard that the dewalt planer head is machined to take their blades which are thinner than other manufacturers, which may cause them to dull quicker. When blades dull quicker you have to buy more blades, more blades means more money for the manufacturer. I mean what ever happened to the hundred year light bulb? I guess when you sell something too good you lose money.

View Howie's profile

Howie

2656 posts in 1524 days


#11 posted 951 days ago

I have a 735 (over 5 years now) and haven’t seen a planer yet I would trade it for. I’m with the rest when it comes to DeWalt replacement parts though. To darned expensive for what you get. As far as blades dulling quickly how quick is quick? I’m only on my second set and I run at least a hundred lineal feet of 8/4,5/4 and 4/4 poplar a week thru mine.

-- Life is good.

View SnowyRiver's profile

SnowyRiver

51451 posts in 2082 days


#12 posted 951 days ago

I have a 735 too and its been great. It is loud, but it sure gets the job done. I havent had any problems with the stock blades…I have run hundreds of BF of oak, walnut, cherry, through it and its still on the original blades and it still has a very smooth finish.

-- Wayne - Plymouth MN

View Iggles88's profile

Iggles88

243 posts in 962 days


#13 posted 951 days ago

I went with the 734 guys, I hope I don’t regret it (it’s on it’s way now) but I need to buy a jointer too and really needed that 200 for the jointer since a decent one is so expensive

View BullVictory's profile

BullVictory

56 posts in 1123 days


#14 posted 951 days ago

I was milling Qtr, Face Sapele, Pine, Poplar and Hard Maple and would estimate I didn’t get ~100 – 125BF (from flipping to new blades to dull) milled from 4/4 some 8/4 Sapele for the table legs. It’s loud yes, partly due to the blower, but it gets really loud when its dull. I about crapped myself because I started reading the reviews about the blades running out quickly and seeing how much they cost… it would add up quickly.

@Iggles88, I haven’t heard anything bad about the 734. My brother has one and seems to like it. You can’t go wrong with it.

View Viking's profile

Viking

857 posts in 1797 days


#15 posted 951 days ago

+1 on the DW 735. If you can budget a little more you would be very pleased with the Dewalt. Have had ours for about 2 years and still very pleased.

Have seen some decent deals on line to buy the 735 and get free outfeed / infeed tables and extra set of blades with free shipping. If you have the I/O tables and align carefully you almost completely eliminate any snipe.

http://www.amazon.com/DeWalt-DW735X-Two-Speed-Planer-Package/dp/B003OX9KME/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1324352515&sr=8-1

Good Luck!

-- Rick Gustafson - Lost Creek Ranch - Colorado County, Texas

Have your say...

You must be signed in to reply.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

GardenTenders.com :: gardening showcase