LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner

Stable or Not...

1K views 11 replies 10 participants last post by  ScottM 
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
The image below shows a coffee table that I'm making for my daughter. When I first showed the image to her she was good with it but now she decided that she could do without the shelf in the middle.

So now, without the shelf, I'm wondering about stability. The long top and bottom rails will be joined to the legs with bridle joints so that will be enough in the long direction but its's the short direction that I'm thinking about. There will be a short apron at the tops of the short sides but those will be just pocket screwed to the leg sections since she needs this to be able to come apart from time to time.

The top will be secured to the top aprons with standard "z" table top fasteners. The overall height is ~17.5". Does anyone see any issues as is or do you think I will need some sort of rail in the middle of the short ends?

Rectangle Parallel Drawing Table Roof
 

Attachments

See less See more
2
#2 ·
Not sure how often she may need to disassemble the table, but I would worry about pocket screws being used in place of knock down hardware.

As far as the stability goes I would certainly add something either to the lower ends or perhaps a support across the middle. Maybe a wide piece with a cutout to match the relief cut in the upper and lower apron pieces.
 
#5 ·
keep the shelf and move the bottom of it down to about 2" off the floor.

she says she doesn't need the shelf, you can remind her of it every time you go to her house and she has things stacked on it.. lol
 
#6 ·
keep the shelf and move the bottom of it down to about 2" off the floor.

she says she doesn't need the shelf, you can remind her of it every time you go to her house and she has things stacked on it.. lol

- rbrjr1
Ya know, I'm starting to lean more that way…. Just keep it for the strength the legs need and I know she'll need a place to put more crap. I'm still thinking on it….
 
#10 · (Edited by Moderator)
One possibility that would work is to make double sided legs so you get support in both directions at the top. It is not as good as stretchers lower down but it should work and you can always add a shelf later. It involves mitering the corner where the two parts meet to give it a clean appearance, tapering the leg pieces to the bottom and making the compound angle cuts at the top and bottom of the legs to get the angles in you illustration.
I drew a quick example in the attached image.
Product Rectangle Slope Font Line
 

Attachments

#12 ·
I gotta go with Woodshaver Tony.

Just add an additional "end apron" at the bottom.

or partway up or halfway up…........

- pete724
Yeah, I think that's what I've decided. This is my new plan. GR8HUNTER (also Tony) suggested adding the same profile cutout to them. I'll secure them with some threaded inserts and connecting bolts. Same with the top aprons instead of pocket screws.

Rectangle Parallel Font Diagram Roof
 

Attachments

This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top