Hi, I've been doing woodworking for over 35 years, and I have a fully equipped shop, but this is my first CNC. I had run CAD plotters with 2d XY movements. That was pretty simple, but 3d looks pretty intimidating. I am purchasing an Laguna IQ 4×4 system, but I'm not sure which software I should be going after. It come with VCarve, but it falls short of what I need to build, guitar necks. I was told by them that Rhino 5 is what I need. My question, is there a 3d software that will do what I want, and doesn't require a background in algebra? Or am I in over my head?
I have been at it almost 2 years and it took me about a year to get a decent hang at it.
To me the cutting skills took a lot longer than I anticipated. Learning feeds and speeds and tooling took some time. I'll highly recommend G-wizzard. Its a great jump starter. You put in parameters and it will get you the feeds speeds and ramp in/out.
2nd, as to 3-d capabilities. So many options you can go, You will find you can do a lot with v'carve pro, I got that with my Cnc routerparts 4×8. I've been trying diff ones in demo versions, and all i can say is it will be a learning curve. I'm a computer progammer/IT guy so thought it would be easy, it's not. Its a lot of time learning but beauty is no matter what you pic, youtube will be your friend. Rhino is very feature rich, but I could not justify the $$.
I got a note that autodesk's artcam was runnin a special 187$ for a year. It's based on a monthly subscription. Default is 45/month. I'm just not getting to what I'd call crawling.
I'd suggest you get demo's and try them. I'd suggest you spend some time learning the cutting aspect first.
I too looked at laguna's before going cnc routerparts route, so i know they have a lot of demo files you can download, and play with.
Great sites where you can buy a lot of art to use and integrate and get your feet wet so to speak.
Good luck and next you gonna want that plasma…..
cheers
Best of cutting with your CNC. I have the Laguna IQ- I am very satisfied with the machine and support.
You have VCarve Pro- I would think that Aspire 9 would be able to work.
I was afraid the learning curve would be a long and difficult one. At first I thought that VCarve may be able to do what I need, but then Laguna put me in touch with another guitar builder, and he advised me on Rhino software. My hesitation is that his shop is all Laguna tools, though he was very helpful. Now I'm wondering if the Rhino software will allow me to use it 2d until I can handle 3d. Thanks to both of you for your help. G
Good advice here. I'll echo what others have hinted at - walk before you run. The jump from 2D to true 3D is a big jump. You have a pretty steep learning curve ahead, not only in the software, but primarily in machining wood with a CNC, learning the proper feeds & speeds for the material, as well as fixturing your parts will take a while. I would focus on projects likes designing and making jigs and fixtures and learn to use the machine first. VCarve is much easier software to grasp than Rhino, IMO, and is a great stepping stone to Aspire for 3D.
Good advice here. I ll echo what others have hinted at - walk before you run. The jump from 2D to true 3D is a big jump. You have a pretty steep learning curve ahead, not only in the software, but primarily in machining wood with a CNC, learning the proper feeds & speeds for the material, as well as fixturing your parts will take a while. I would focus on projects likes designing and making jigs and fixtures and learn to use the machine first. VCarve is much easier software to grasp than Rhino, IMO, and is a great stepping stone to Aspire for 3D.
very true. When I bought mine with vcarve-pro, i got an upgrade to aspire within the year at just the diff. A year in there was nothing i needed that was missing. ....Now I have not added 4th axis yet, but it's coming.
Nothing to, but to do it … but it's easier said than done!
I don't often do this but I have to agree with the comments about Rhino!
The Vectric software is hard to beat!
I haven't gotten that far with Fusion 360 but my son, a certified CNC machinist/shop manager, has is and is way ahead of me with "our" CNC!
You can download the free demo for Aspire and try it out (with some limitations) just to learn if it will do what you want and also to learn by running the tutorial programs.
There is a learning curve, but results are usually achieved in equal measure to your efforts.
My machine doesn't arrive for about 8 weeks, till then I'm studying the software and my capabilities with it. Looks like I may not even need 3d after all, and I already have experience with xy programing. One fun little project I'm going to do with a friend of mine, is to reproduce the parts for a balsa wood model of a Stearman biplane, only 10 times the size of the original plans. should be a lot of fun!
VCarve is an awesome CAM program and CAN do a Guitar neck IF you have a model to import into it. VCarve cannot create the model. BTW - there are some people around that would create the guitar neck model for you for $25 - $75 with some detailed information from you.
Aspire CAN create the model. I would create that model with a 2 rail sweep in Aspire. Easy, once you are past the learning curve.
Lots of times you will see samples that people have cut in VCarve and yes VCarve CAN cut 3D BAS relief models. The Wolf, Horse, Flowers etc are all purchased models and not created in VCarve.
Rhino is by far more capable than Aspire - BUT - maybe you don't NEED that capability. For guitar necks and bodies you don't need it. Rhino also does NOT post out code for your machine. It is ONLY CAD, but very capable CAD, it is.
Aspire CAN create the guitar body AND neck AND post out the code for your machine.
RhinoCAM, is an add on to RhinoCAD so that you can post out code. Quite an awesome combination - wish I could afford it. It is fully 4 axis capable, and not simple axis swapping or wrapping. This combination is FAR more capable than Aspire. It is also FAR more expensive.
You cannot compare RhinoCAD/RhinoCAM to Aspire. They are just two completely different packages.
To my way of thinking - Aspire would serve you VERY well. You may be able to get it for the upgrade price from VCarve to Aspire.
BTW - I have been around all this stuff for 30-40 years professionally.
Cherrywood- I have a lot to learn about all this. But I have to start somewhere. By CREATE, do you mean the CAD program that will allow you to draw the piece? If so, then what your saying is the the VCarve will only draw the path of the tool for cutting and carving? If that's right then I will need to find a simple CAD program I can work with. However, I am interested in your model creating for $25 to $75. I may need that at first.
VCarve CAN create 2D vector VERY well. It is a very capable, and very powerful program. The VCarve program can toolpath the 2D vectors that you create in VCarve and also toolpath the 3D toolpath on imported models. VCarve has a LOT of potential and can make a LOT of VERY awesome stuff. It is perhaps a LOT more powerful than you can imagine just now.
There is skill involved is CAD and in CAM. There is a learning curve. I used VCarve for about 7-8 years before I upgraded to Aspire.
With the amount of learning involved, VCarve will keep you occupied for several years. The added features in Aspire to create the models is yet another added level of learning curve. Taking on all of it at one time is an extremely aggressive course of action.
So far I have been talking about a model. When I say "model", I am referring to the 3 dimensional shape with curved surfaces - ie, the curved shape of an acoustical guitar body or the curved, tapered shape of the guitar neck. Those "models" are created in Rhino, or Aspire or something that is capable of creating a 3 dimensional shape.
VCarve as well as Aspire and other CAD, like Rhino is capable of 2 dimensional drawing. Line lines on paper. Those are called "vectors". VCarve can create the Vectors but not the models.
With just a little ingenuity, watching - studying the Vectric tutorials, getting help on the Vectric user forum, you will find that even 2D software, can make 3D parts. Not all 3D needs to be a model with 3D curves.
Goss,
VCarve and Aspire are Vectric products. VCarve is the entry product which does 2D CAD/CAM and 2-1/2D CAD/CAM (V-carve or engraving whichever you choose to call it - it uses a V-bit to make what looks like chiseled, incised carving).
Aspire is the full product which will allows you to make 3D models and carve them.
Last I checked you could purchase VCarve and later on when you got comfortable with it, Vectric will allow you to upgrade for basically the cost difference of the two products.
I recommend the full product eventually. It's probably the best bang for the buck.
A partial seat of ArtCAM will cost you $360/year. A full seat will cost you nearly that much per MONTH. Used to be $10K per seat, plus about $1800/year for annual maintenance.
Compare at $2,000 for a full seat of Aspire, with NO annual maintenance costs.
ArtCAM is a subscription based CAD/CAM software that is now owned by AutoDesk, the makers of AutoCAD, that you pay for monthly. A Seat means you can use it on one computer. Not sure how they work now, but you used to need a dongle (USB key with a license code). With a dongle you need the dongle to operate the software. Vectric allows you to load the software in, up to 3 computers, without any hardware (dongle). Also, at this time Vectric is not subscription based.
I've been building cabinets for years, but I should be able to figure out the path to divide a 4×8 for the caresses. 10K is a lot of money, but I can see where a business could benefit. I've learned some thing from our conversation. Thanks
WOW! There's a lot of software! Well, I shouldn't be surprised.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
LumberJocks Woodworking Forum
2.5M posts
96K members
Since 2006
A forum community dedicated to professional woodworkers and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about shop safety, wood, carpentry, lumber, finishing, tools, machinery, woodworking related topics, styles, scales, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!