Need some advice on wood filler....don't cringe!

Well I know the minwax wood fill used to work great but I dont believe it comes in a maple color which is stupid.
Another thing you ccould do I make your own. Take some maple saw dust and add a small amount of glue then stir and enjoy.

-- thatwoodworkingguy.com ~Eagle America~ ~Woodcraft~

I always have a tough time getting wood filler to match anything once it is finished. Is it possible to actually accentuate the edge where the two meet? Maybe rout out a thin v groove “witness line”? Or possibly add a thin inlay and make it look intentional.

-- Entertainment for mere mortal woodworkers. http://www.WoodworkingForMereMortals.com

The best “filler” is typically sawdust and glue.

But, from looking at your work, you probably already knew that, and you want a push towards the right/better fix. I would strongly consider replacing a bit of that veneer with a dutchman patch. If you do it well, you can follow the grain of the wood, and it will hardly be seen. And, of course, if you used hide glue on the veneer, you can just lift the whole thing off with an iron and replace.

My advice … don’t cut corners, your reputation is invaluable.

Famo wood , either solvent or water base match maple better than any I know of.. I just t ried some on hard maple and it did as good as your going to get it.. a friend of mine just did some plywood panels banded in maple, he nailed the bands on and used this, it matched well

Just wondering, why fool with wood filler anyway, why not use 1/8” radius round over bit and ease the edge with the tearout, this makes finishing it easier also, you won’t risk “burning” through your stain when you sand the table, and you wont have a sharp edge that might chip out after the table gets delivered.

-- James

If you don’t have to use filler don’t either add wood or trim some and if you trim some score it first to prevent tearout again and or dampen it or put tape of it.

-- W James Brokenbourgh Custom furniture maker http://artisticwoodstudio.com/

Don’t know if it’s practical or appropriate for your specific piece – but I’ve used Stevinmarin’s approach a couple of times with good results.
Who’s to say that wasn’t part of your design plan all along——
“Only your hair dresser knows for sure.”

-- Those who insist it can't be done - should politely refrain from interrupting those who are doing it.

i think a good way to save it is to a small v groove and put in an inlay ..the saw dust is ok…but i think it might come out darker then what you have…just my 2 cents..

-- GRIZZMAN ...[''''']

Famowood does make the best wood filler. Sometimes with budget and time, that is the best and only option. I learned long ago that the little imperfections, we as builders and woodworkers see everytime we look at our finished piece, are never noticed 99.9% of the time.

-- http://www.niceashplanes.com/ http://www.efcabineture.com/

Actually Timbermate is my preferred, we use it for grain filling , it doesnt shrink , does excellent , but Famowood matches maple and most hardware stores carry it

I don’t care for Famowood, it never takes finish like other pieces. I recently started using some of the Timbermate and it seems to be much better. Had some chipout on a red oak ply cabinet and with the Timbermate you can’t even tell where it was (even with some Watco on the cabinet now). With Famowood my eyes always seem to go straight to the repair. Of course if the issue is small enough glue and sawdust are the best bet.

fine sanding dust and yellow or white glue is what I use.

-- In God We Trust

Famowood is good stuff but its pretty high on the toxic scale and flammable scale DO NOT use it in a unventilated space in fact use it outside if you use it at all.

I like the use of sawdust (finer is better) with glue. I think using white glue will be less likely to darken the color. Recently, I needed something for a very small ding in a project and I tried something. What I did was to fill the little ding with CA and then sprinkled fine sawdust into the CA and then just gave it a quick wipe. After light sanding the ding was almost invisible. It just looked like some interesting grain in the wood. It is in one of my projects posted here on LJ’s, but I will never tell which one.

-- Hey, woodworking ain't brain surgery. Just do something and keep trying till you get it. Doc

docholladay, won’t the white glue affect the way it takes fiinish?? Did the CA affect the stain and / or finish ?

-- "some old things are lovely, warm still with life ... of the forgotten men who made them." - D.H. Lawrence