« back to Joinery forum
06-24-2015 04:56 PM
|
Topic tags/keywords:
triple pedestal
farmhouse table
ana white
expansion
expand
wood movement
contraction
splitting
Hi All,
I’ve been lurking here for a bit, then hit a heck of a roadblock last week on a project…
Let me preface this with full disclosure: I’ve committed nearly every embarrassing woodworking sin imaginable in this situation, so feel free to let me have it, but also know I’m trying to make this right.
I picked up woodworking around 2 years ago after stumbling across this design: http://ana-white.com/2012/11/plans/triple-pedestal-farmhouse-table. I built one, it turned out OK, so I did what seemed (il)logical at the time: I posted an add on Craigslist selling these tables. Thankfully, I only fulfilled one order. I bought the lumber (SPF) from Home Depot, immediately started the build and in the winter of ‘13, delivered a 7ft version of this table to an excited couple.
You can easily predict the email I got 3 months later – “our table is cracking and splitting everywhere.” I promised to take care of the situation, but after an exceedingly tumultuous year, aided (luckily) by a couple with Maharishi caliber patience, I was not able to get to the replacement until 1 week ago.
OK, now that we have the history out of the way, a couple quick points:
- I owned a Kreg jig, 12” miter saw, scroll saw, corded drill and finish sander when I built this originally – that’s it.
- I’ve since added a PC biscuit joiner, 13.5 bench top planer, Stanley #4 bench plane, 10” table saw, dado blade set, a cordless drill finally (added that for humor), compressor, finish & brad nailer, and a bunch of the fun must have shop accessories.
I’ve completed the 2 tabletop panels (made of 1×6’s) using biscuits and now I’m ready to attach them to the 2×4 “frame”. Now I’m still very much a novice with only 5 projects under my belt, but I did finally learn you can’t build something like this without joinery accounting for wood movement with grain in opposite directions.
The make matters worse the first time around, I “kregged” everywhere AND I screwed the legs into the table top, in addition to building with wet lumber that hadn’t had a chance to acclimatize. For the rebuild, I have boards that have been sitting since that same winter and I’m guesstimating an MC of no more than 4-7%, so my main concern is that eventual expansion, not so much the contraction.
So long story already long – what is the best case scenario for attaching the panels to the frame? This was my initial idea:

I’m also considering a half-rabbet in the frame to drop the panels into, then securing with a brace on the underside for stability (brace joinery allowing for movement).
Thanks in advance for any wisdom and go easy on the lashes, even though I deserve it :)
Dean
|
6 replies so far
#1 posted 06-24-2015 05:41 PM
|
Ana White does not understand wood movement, her designs are terrible that way. Forget the frame, that is the problem, it is known among wood workers as the “panel of doom”. Almost every beginning wood worker thinks a frame around a panel is a good idea until about sixth months after it is constructed. If you must, construct a proper breadboard end that allows for wood movement. The other point of concern is how the top is attached to the base. Once again consideration for wood movement is crucial. You can use bolts or screws in slots or buttons or z clips, there are lots of good ways to do it.
-- Bondo Gaposis
|
#2 posted 06-24-2015 05:46 PM
|
Ana White is the problem. I’ve seen this identical post about a hundred times.
Jeez.
|
#3 posted 06-24-2015 06:00 PM
|
Thanks for the quick responses! I’m attaching the legs with the afforementioned slots/screws, so that’ll be one build error corrected. The most difficult part of fixing this flawed design is the board running across the center; I can’t modify that without changing the aesthetic of the table, otherwise proper breadboards would be an easy fix.
I had another epiphany this morning: I know this is sacrilege, but what about utilizing hardwood ply for the panels? That would solve most of the problems with the main drawback being it’s no longer a “solid wood” table. I don’t see pine really being an heirloom piece, so is that really a drawback? I don’t think so.
|
#4 posted 06-24-2015 06:33 PM
|
This is an impossible table, can’t possibly work. Crazy that anyone would encourage people to build this way. You might have done a bit better with drier wood, but it still would have eventually split and cracked like crazy. To build a new top you essentially have three choices: 1. Make a plain top with no breadboards, all solid wood planks joined together. 2. A plain top with breadboards. 3. Make the panels out of plywood.
My advice would be to explain to the client why the board along the middle was a bad idea (ie impossible, given the laws of physics) from the start and see if they’re OK with a table without it. You’re right that a bit of plywood is not the end of the world, but they may prefer solid wood over the piece in the middle of the table.
Seriously, though. I don’t get it – the table that Ana White made for that picture must have split into a million pieces too. But she still leaves it on her website (along with other photos taken by proud woodworkers 2 days after they finished the table rather than 6 months later when it’s cracking like mad)??
-- Jeremy, in the Acadian forests
|
#5 posted 06-24-2015 06:37 PM
|
Ana White does not understand wood movement, her designs are terrible that way.- bondogaposis
+1 on that!!
I see two possible approaches here:
1. Plywood panels as you suggest.
2. Use something like Ana White’s Plan B for the top: make the top out of individual boards, NOT GLUED together (T&G would be best, but a full-length spline would be ok too) and attached to cleats from underneath, so the shrinkage/expansion can happen in individual boards, creating small gaps between boards, but not big cracks in the top. (If your wood is bone dry, then leave small spaces—-1/32” or so between boards)
Ana White’s stuff tends to be structurally weak, heavily reliant on pocket screws and such. This particular design doesn’t provide much racking resistance in the pedestal base. Would be better with some shoulders on the rail-to-pedestal connection.
Next time, if you’re going to sell this stuff, sell “as is”
-- Jerry, making sawdust professionally since 1976
|
#6 posted 06-24-2015 08:25 PM
|
Thank you, gentlemen! I’m consulting with them now on the options above, focusing on steering them in the plywood solution.
There won’t be a next time – I’m embarrassed to have my name attached to this situation. Lesson learned!
On a side note, I’m hesitant to say anything derogatory about Ana White/Shanty-2-Chic designs because I wouldn’t have discovered such a reward and PRACTICAL hobby had it not been for them; I’m sure there are thousands of others with that same experience. That being said, some of their “how to’s” are borderline negligent because it would only take a few tweaks to not suck so bad. My favorite was a recommendation by Shanty to NOT use clamps – use duct tape :)
|
Have your say...
You must be signed in to reply.
|
Forum |
Topics |
Woodworking Skill Share
Your woodworking skills are displayed for several lifetimes in each project. Have you had to compromise your project...
|
12026 |
Woodturning
On the lathe, by the lathe: do you have questions? frustrations? tips? This forum is for all the woodturners out there.
|
2104 |
Woodcarving
Relief, 3D, chip-carving, whittling; carving knives, chisels, pocket-knives, power tools. If you are a carver or want...
|
431 |
Scrollsawing
Intarsia, fretwork, intricate design cutting and more! This forum is for scrollsawers: share your tips, ask questions...
|
340 |
Joinery
Have a question? a tip/strategy to share? a challenge, perhaps? Share your "joinery" discussion here.
|
1369 |
Finishing
The finish, whether paint, wax, stain, or something else, can make or break a project. What are your tips and questio...
|
4900 |
Designing Woodworking Projects
Looking for information on designing your projects? Having difficulties reading project plans? Looking for help with ...
|
6691 |
Power Tools, Hardware and Accessories
Are you unsure of which tools, or hardware, you need, or which brands to buy? Investing in tools and hardware can be ...
|
28039 |
CNC Woodworking
Questions and answers about CNC machines, tooling, best practices, and projects.
|
211 |
Hand Tools
Wood, your hand tools, you and a little know-how. Share your questions, tips and strategies for the use and maintenan...
|
5404 |
Jigs & Fixtures
Using a jig is like having a couple extra hands helping out. Show us your jigs, share your tips, strategies and, of c...
|
1417 |
Wood & Lumber
Different wood requires different woodworking strategies - from cutting to finishing. Share your tips and challenges ...
|
6224 |
Safety in the Woodworking Shop
Before you pick up those woodworking tools, take the time to ensure your safety in the shop! Eyes, ears, fingers, and...
|
1387 |
Focus on the Workspace
Are you looking for or do you have tips to share regarding the workshop? Storage, equipment placement, efficiency, an...
|
2153 |
Sweating for Bucks Through Woodworking
If you are selling your work, then you have entered a woodworking dimension with added complexity and stress. If you...
|
1185 |
Woodworking Trade & Swap
All of us are holding onto treasure in our shops, that we either don't need, don't want, or could part with if presen...
|
4753 |
LumberJocks.com Site Feedback
Connect with the Website Gurus and tell us what you are thinking, suggestions, problems, functionality issues, and so...
|
2200 |
Coffee Lounge
Need a break from all the standing and wood dust? Chat with your Forum Friends about their projects, their life, thei...
|
8842 |
|