| Review by kshipp | posted 17 days ago | 696 views | 0 times favorited | 11 comments | ![]() |
![]() |
- Rockler Bench Cookies Item Number 26357
- Brand: Rockler | Category: Other

I saw a lot of press about these online as I’m sure that many of you have. I was at Rockler one day picking up some other things and I picked these up also just to check them out.
I used them for the first time yesterday and I was really impressed. I was working on a 40” x 8” board so I put a bench cookie in each of the corners. I was able to use a random orbit sander and a belt sander with no problems at all. I’ll admit that I was nervous when I first set the belt sander on it because I didn’t trust them but I do now. I didn’t try them with edge-routing like they show in all the ads but I imagine they would work for that also.
The performance didn’t seem to be diminished by having some sawdust on them either. I just wiped them off on my shirt a few times during use to be sure.
I gave them four stars because I still don’t really feel like I trust they are going to hold all the time. But they have so far so maybe its just me getting used to them instead of an actual fault with the product.
-- Kyle Shipp, Michigan, http://battleshipp.blogspot.com

























11 comments so far
Lenny
home | projects | blog
124 posts in 418 days
posted 16 days ago
I have been hoping to hear from one or more LJers on this product. Glad to hear you made out well with them and thanks for the post.
-- And on the eighth day God was back in His woodworking shop!
a1Jim
home | projects | blog
16549 posts in 468 days
posted 16 days ago
Thanks for the review. There was a post a little while ago were someone made there own at a low cost he called his brownies.
http://lumberjocks.com/projects/22344
-- Jim from Heirloom Woodshop Southern Oregon
Pete_Jud
home | projects | blog
115 posts in 644 days
posted 16 days ago
I had a lot of 4 1/2 inch disks left over after making my dust collector pipe hangers out of 3/4 ply, and just glued some spinlock shelf liner pieces on both sides. I don’t know where I bought the spinlock, but it was only a buck or two a roll, and have used it on the boat for years as an anti slip shelf lining. It seems to be the same stuff that rockler and western tool sells as matts.
-- Life is to short to own an ugly boat.
Joe
home | projects | blog
101 posts in 285 days
posted 16 days ago
I also thought about how they would work after getting some saw dust on them? I guess you answered it.
-- Senior Chief
araldite
home | projects | blog
15 posts in 295 days
posted 16 days ago
My bench top is a little slick because it’s varnished. If there’s enough sawdust on there these cookies will slide around. If the bench is clean and the cookies brushed off they work fine under a ROS. I don’t trust them enough to use them with a router, but maybe I’m just overly cautious.
-- Vince in Greenville, SC
Bret
home | projects | blog
82 posts in 386 days
posted 16 days ago
I’ve got a set of 4 of these and use them almost every time I’m in the shop. They don’t lose adhesion no matter how dusty they get. Sure I could’ve made a set myself but for $12 it fell squarely (for me) on the buy side of the build/buy line. Kind of like the Bridge City KM-1 I just received in the mail and may be reviewing shortly.
-- Bret, Colorado
mikedddd
home | projects | blog
61 posts in 121 days
posted 16 days ago
I haven’t seen the bench cookies up here in Canada yet, but I’ve been using a left over piece of drawer liner for a mechanics tool box for awhile now, works great for sanding, I haven’t and probably won’t try it with a router.
http://www.sears.com/shc/s/p_10153_12605_9990000032266011P?vName=Tools&cName=Tool+Storage&sName=Tools+Storage+Accessories&sid=K-on-Sx20k061224x0000002
-- Mike
John Gray
home | projects | blog
1743 posts in 777 days
posted 16 days ago
I received a set of the Rockler Bench Cookies and like them so much that I bought another set. No problems here with sawdust they actually stick like little suction cups to my unvarnished Maple work bench.
-- Only the Shadow knows....................
kosta
home | projects | blog
371 posts in 246 days
posted 15 days ago
im gonna try that
-- kosta brownsville brooklyn my home
Rustic
home | projects | blog
1247 posts in 488 days
posted 13 days ago
I have used them with my belt sander and trim router and I love ‘em
-- There is no such thing as a mistake. Its called a design modification Rick Kruse, Grand Rapids, MI
dustyal
home | projects | blog
440 posts in 366 days
posted 12 days ago
I have and use four of these things… I thought they were a bit pricey as I can accomplish just about the same with non-skid mats. On the other hand they are convenient.
Generally I use them with ROS sanding. I haven’t really had the courage to try with router but I suspect they will work fine.
-- Al H. - small shop, small projects...