LumberJocks
DAILY DEALS Sure-Foot Plus™ 3/4'' Pipe Clamp  |  Makita Makita Recon LCT203W 10.8 Volt Lithium Ion Impact Driver 2 Pc Kit

Great for small shop using only one tool at time

Review by Eric_S posted 23 days ago 755 views 0 times favorited 21 comments Add to Favorites Watch
Great for small shop using only one tool at time No-picture-s No-picture-s Click the pictures to enlarge them

I don’t know how informative this review will be as it’s my first dust collector and review, but I’ll try. I was originally looking at the 50-760 after hearing lots of good reviews, but since I plan on only using one tool at a time and I dont mind rolling this around from tool to tool I didn’t mind something a little cheaper as I was trying to save money (or so I thought), quieter, and smaller.

Despite reviews I’ve seen on amazon, this thing was very simple to setup, but then again I’ve never had problems putting together anything, including futons from walmart with the worst possible instructions…it just takes longer ;) While the instructions weren’t specifically clear, the pictures helped a lot. The only difficulty is that they have you install the motor housing before the cross support beam which means its very wobbly while attaching the heavy motor. I think this is why they recommend doing it with it laying on its side but that too was a little difficult. A second hand would have helped. All in all, it took about an hour to put together. I purchased the CT version, which I dont know if that was a good decision or not. I didn’t realize the felt bag it comes with is 1 micron, while the cartridge filter is 2 micron. I hear cartridges though have more breathing room though so maybe it will help with suction? Can anyone confirm this?

The only difficult part I had was installing the cartridge as instructions say to put the included foam tape around as a seal before attaching. Well, the cartridge is so tight fitting that no matter what I was unable to attach the cartridge with the foam. Luckilly the cartridge has its own foam liner that should protect any dust from coming out around the seal, so I didn’t use the foam.

The max suction it states is 650cfm, and since I’m only using one tool at a time with a 6 foot hose it seems to be doing a great job so far with my planer (although I haven’t put anything more than 6” wide through yet) and bandsaw. Its also quieter than my shop vac so its much more pleasant to work with. The clear bottom bags are a nice addition too, very easy to attach and remove.

Now on to my regrets, I could have saved a hundred bucks I think if I got the regular 50-720 without the cartridge. Either way, it comes with a 1 micron felt bag so I really hope that although the cartridge is 2 micron, it will perform better. I hope someone can comfort me with this decision. Also, the 4’ duct that it comes with is a joke. I do agree with other reviews in that they should have at least included a 5 or 6 foot hose. The 4ft included hose has a lot of spring to it so it seems more like 3 feet. The wheels are also really tiny making it difficult to roll around the concrete floor so maybe I’ll upgrade those later.

All in all though, for a first dust collector I am very happy with it. I will probably have to upgrade though if I move and have a dedicated workshop where I can attach lots of ductwork. But for now, I am very happy with it and a big improvement over my crappy, noisy shop vac.

Eric

View Eric_S's profile

Eric_S

89 posts in 88 days



21 comments so far

View kkickback's profile

kkickback

234 posts in 108 days


posted 23 days ago

I also have this one and love it…I dont have the metal top tho….and is stead of using bags for the bottom I gut a 15 gal drum and use that for the chips and use a heavey bad to connect both of them with bungy cords alto faster that putting bags on and saves money over time I think I will post pics later so you all can see….

-- christoper Blanchard, Michigan

View sry's profile

sry

137 posts in 500 days


posted 23 days ago

Thanks for the review. This is one I’ve been considering, so I’m glad to hear yours is working out well so far.

-- Steve -- University Heights, Ohio

View Eric_S's profile

Eric_S

89 posts in 88 days


posted 23 days ago

Its great as long as you keep the hose short and don’t mind wheeling it around. I think im going to purchase the Rockler Dust Right hose and attachments though to make it easier to switch between tools. I’m still trying to decide though if the cartridge was worth the extra money. Although only 2 micron, I’ve heard they perform better.

View Todd A. Clippinger's profile

Todd A. Clippinger

5632 posts in 992 days


posted 23 days ago

I have no doubt that you will be fine with 2 micron collection so don’t sweat it.

All of the small 650cfm units have tiny wheels. But they are not heavy so it is not too bad and you can change things in the future as you said.

The dust collector will work great for the way that you are using it.

-- Todd A. Clippinger, Montana, http://amcraftsman.com

View NBeener's profile

NBeener

369 posts in 66 days


posted 23 days ago

I think you did a great job with your review.

After looking at your model, the next Delta up (760?), and a bunch of others, I finally ordered the 2HP Harbor Freight unit, on sale. Also ordered the cartridge filter from Wynn Industries.

Like you, I have no immediate plans to plumb/duct it, so a fairly long hose will be a must. I’ve also been getting by (?) with a Shop Vac, so I’m looking forward to a big improvement.

Best of luck working out the last few kinks!

-- -- Neil

View Eric_S's profile

Eric_S

89 posts in 88 days


posted 23 days ago

Thanks NBeener. Yeah I think Im going to keep the shop vac around for cleaning out car but that’s about it. I want to be able to hear my tools, not a jet engine. Let me know how the HF is.

Thanks todd. I’m sure the 2 micron will be ok, but is the cartridge really better than bag?

View Demowen's profile

Demowen

113 posts in 290 days


posted 23 days ago

I have this one too. I have been having a problem with wood chips collecting at the end of the hose. When I hook this up to my planer there are really small strips of shavings and they get caught on the cross piece that is over the opening where you attach the hose to. It has been a real pain. Any ideas?

-- Let the favor of the Lord our God be on us; establish the work of our hands- establish the work of our hands! Psalm 90:17

View Eric_S's profile

Eric_S

89 posts in 88 days


posted 23 days ago

Maybe problem with the planer?

View Demowen's profile

Demowen

113 posts in 290 days


posted 23 days ago

It does it with other tools too… I was contemplating breaking the cross piece but then there would be nothing to stop something too big from passing into the collector.

-- Let the favor of the Lord our God be on us; establish the work of our hands- establish the work of our hands! Psalm 90:17

View Eric_S's profile

Eric_S

89 posts in 88 days


posted 23 days ago

How long a hose are you using? I haven’t seen issues yet but I just got it this past weekend and only have used it for a few hours.

View Demowen's profile

Demowen

113 posts in 290 days


posted 23 days ago

its a 6’ hose (I believe)

-- Let the favor of the Lord our God be on us; establish the work of our hands- establish the work of our hands! Psalm 90:17

View Eric_S's profile

Eric_S

89 posts in 88 days


posted 23 days ago

Hmm, maybe kickback can help. Do you have bag or cartridge? Maybe its too clogged and causing suction loss?

View Demowen's profile

Demowen

113 posts in 290 days


posted 23 days ago

I have the bag. When it gets clogged there is almost no suction until I take off the hose and pull off the strings. If all you collect is dust (dust collector) then it is great, but inevitably my planer or table saw will cut small strands of wood that get caught.

-- Let the favor of the Lord our God be on us; establish the work of our hands- establish the work of our hands! Psalm 90:17

View dbhost's profile

dbhost

599 posts in 124 days


posted 23 days ago

The problem with planer / jointer shavings getting caught on the cross piece going into the impeller is not unique to this model. My HF 2HP DC did this before the pre-separator was put in. The long shavings would simply wrap around the cross piece and build up, QUICKLY… Just keep an eye out for clogging and you will be fine. Cutting the cross pieces out is a common remedy to that problem, but yeah, you are right. Every now and then a big chunk can get sucked up and BANG hit the impeller… The cross pieces are there for a reason…

This little Delta was an option, but the low CFM was too much of a concern to want to go with it. I am sure it is fine for machine to machine use, but I will be plumbing, and this DC is just too small for that.

To your question, is a cartridge really better than a bag. YES. The cartridges allow the DC to breathe much more freely, and in turn realize higher real world CFM (the advertised CFM ratings are with no hose, and no bags / filters attached. So the 650 CFM DCs with bags have substantially lower than 650 CFM actually delivered in use…

Adding the Wynn canister to my HF DC was like putting a supercharger on a car engine. WAY better performance, MUCH more effect.

And since you asked about how the HF DC works out… I have had mine for almost a year, and when I remember to hook it up (I am going machine to machine with a 20’ hose) it not only pulls all the dust I could want from the machine being pulled from, but it has noticeably reduced ambient dust levels. I would really love a Dylos meter to verify exactly how effective it is, but I can say without a doubt, that if I clean surfaces, such as the table to the band saw, then perform particularly dusty operations with the DC running, and leave it on for a few minutes afterwards, I get NO visibly settled dust within 48 hours after use.

Now forgetting to hook up and run the DC is dsiasterous (which is why the DC itself has a layer of dust on the base, I keep forgetting to hook it up to my table saw…)

-- Trying to follow the example of the master.

View Eric_S's profile

Eric_S

89 posts in 88 days


posted 23 days ago

Yeah I was thinking of adding a small cyclone type pre-seperator sometime. I’m glad to hear that the cartridge is worth it. Thanks for the input

View dustyal's profile

dustyal

443 posts in 367 days


posted 22 days ago

Thanks for the review. I am stepping up things a little at a time. Right now I use a 12 gal shop vac and it works fine… and I use it with a bag inside. Today I received my Oneida Dust Deputy. Quick assembly. Tomorrow I’ll try it out with my planer I have yet to us. Next step will be a unit like this Delta you reviewed or the Rockler wall mounted unit. Something portable to use at one machine at a time.

Again, thanks.

-- Al H. - small shop, small projects...

View Cato's profile

Cato

138 posts in 205 days


posted 22 days ago

Eric, congrats on the purchase. You will like having a DC unit. Good choice on going with a canister!

The canister seems to be the way to go these days no matter the make or model. Does the Wynn cartridge have the interior paddle and exterior handle to rotate and clean the pleats??

I had looked at the HF unit and adding the Wynn, as well as the delta units w/canister but ended up getting a 1.5hp canister unit from PSI. They all are in the same ball park in price, and the main thing is stepping up from a shop vac and taking control of dust into the machine and not your lungs!!

Now when I rip on the table saw or crosscut on the RAS, both are hooked up to the two intake ports, the table tops of the machines may only show a trace of any dust particles, and that’s so cool.

View a1Jim's profile

a1Jim

16598 posts in 469 days


posted 21 days ago

good review

-- Jim from Heirloom Woodshop Southern Oregon

View araldite's profile

araldite

15 posts in 296 days


posted 21 days ago

I have the 1HP model they discontinued when your model was introduced. I got it for under $100 because it was the last one in the store and they just wanted to get rid of it. It had the 30 micron bags, which I discarded and replaced with a 1 micron cartridge.

I had the same problem with clogging with the planer and by checking the forums I found it was common. There’s back and forth about cutting out the cross bars at the intake, but I went ahead and cut them out and the problem is solved. I don’t see how a big chunk of anything can get into it, I’m not vacuuming the floor, it stays hooked only to machines. I’ve been running it like that for almost a year and no problems.

My wheels also pick up dust and moving it can be a pain, but hey, it’s a bottom of the line machine for the budget minded. It keeps me healthy until I can afford a better unit.

-- Vince in Greenville, SC

View Boneski's profile

Boneski

7 posts in 25 days


posted 21 days ago

Hey great review, Eric.
I was originally looking at a 650CFM unit, but for not much more expense I picked up a 1200CFM unit here in Australia. I do recommend getting a cyclone type pre seperator as I am about to – I inadvertantly sucked a peice of steel into the hose the other day and If I hadn’t had the presence of mind to kick the hose off of the DC inlet, it would have gone straight through the impeller.

-- Blinded by brilliance

View NBeener's profile

NBeener

369 posts in 66 days


posted 21 days ago

Now forgetting to hook up and run the DC is dsiasterous (which is why the DC itself has a layer of dust on the base, I keep forgetting to hook it up to my table saw…)

Ahhhh. So it’s NOT just me.

No other machine … but the darned TS. MAN, can that thing blow dust FAR, too :-)

Does the Wynn cartridge have the interior paddle and exterior handle to rotate and clean the pleats??

dbhost has one. I don’t … yet … but … it doesn’t look like they do:

http://www.wynnenv.com/35A_series_cartridge_kit.htm

I presume a rigged wooden ‘scraper,’ along with careful use of the Shop Vac + upholstery brush … should do well. It does seem like a separator is a good idea in any case, but … one thing at a time ;-)

Adding the Wynn canister to my HF DC was like putting a supercharger on a car engine. WAY better performance, MUCH more effect.

WOO-HOO!

-- -- Neil

You must be signed in to post the comments.

  • View all advertisers
  • Advertise with us

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

GardenTenders.com :: gardening showcase