| Review by handi | posted 122 days ago | 636 views | 0 times favorited | 12 comments | ![]() |
![]() |
- Rockler Bench Cookies
- Brand: Rockler | Category: Router Accessories

I got the chance to try out Rockler’s new Bench Cookies over the weekend.
Bench Cookies are like hockey pucks with rubber faces. They act like a routing mat to keep parts from sliding around as you sand or rout them.
The difference is that Bench Cookies lift the part up about 1” off the work surface so that you have clearance for bearing bits or cut throughs.
They work surprisingly well, I sanded and routed parts on them with complete confidence. I even covered them in sawdust to see if that changed the effect. It does a tiny bit, but I piled dust on them. They still worked.
You can see the full video review on my website: http://consultingwoodworker.com/video_reviews
Ralph
-- www.consultingwoodworker.com Look me up on Twitter as ConsultingWood

























12 comments so far
Durnik150
home | projects | blog
536 posts in 218 days
posted 122 days ago
I’ve got two sets of these that will be delivered on Monday. I’ve talked to a couple folks who have used these as well as seen several on-line reviews. Everyone has been very positive about their experience with these pieces. I’m glad to see another positive since I’ve already bought them!
-- Behind the Bark is a lot of Heartwood----Charles, Centennial, CO
rmora76393
home | projects | blog
9 posts in 505 days
posted 118 days ago
They go on sale at Rockler stores on Saturday 8.1.09 … $11.99 for a set of 4
F Y I … also going on sale is the Porter Cable trim Router for $49.99 reg price is $99.99
I’m getting both this weekend as soon as the doors open! I’m like a kid on xmas morning!
be safe
Bob
a1Jim
home | projects | blog
16910 posts in 473 days
posted 118 days ago
Thanks Ralph totally new to me.Thanks for the review.
-- Jim from Heirloom Woodshop Southern Oregon
handi
home | projects | blog
41 posts in 1335 days
posted 117 days ago
Jim,
New to everyone. Rockler only unveiled them at the AWFS show in Mid-July. I just happened to be first out with the video :)
Ralph
-- www.consultingwoodworker.com Look me up on Twitter as ConsultingWood
rroades
home | projects | blog
51 posts in 405 days
posted 108 days ago
Ralph – I’m a skeptic, so though I was a Rockler employee (Burnsville, MN store), our guys at the store did the same thing – cake them up with sawdust and they did rather well. 1 out of 4 was a bit loose, but we just turned them upside down, one tap on the table and back under the workpiece and it was like new – no slip even though there was still some sawdust on them. I bought a set that day….
-- There are many tempting parking places on the road to success
PineInTheAsh
home | projects | blog
194 posts in 164 days
posted 108 days ago
With the seemingly endless variety of bench dogs, clamps of every configuration, hold downs/holdfasts, and sticky drawer liners, these cookies might seem to be up against reliable and proven competition.
Still, the new cookies seem a good product that’s easy to fall in love with and destined for success. Created and launched very carefully: Easy to understand; easy to use; and at an easy to accept pricepoint.
Not sure if I’d change my shop’s work-holding habits—those grip mats trimmed to fit under the entire workpiece are just so elegantly damn good!
However, what about an unintended or secondary benefit of the cookies?
I wonder how effective they might be as isolation pads?
Such as a motor mounted on a board with rubber washers/grommets, and then place a set, or a series of these cookies under the board to dampen sound and vibration.
Best,
Peter
handi
home | projects | blog
41 posts in 1335 days
posted 108 days ago
Peter,
I have all sorts of hold downs too, but I was trimming a bunch of edgebanding recently with the router. (like shown in the video) I was able to lay a side down, trim it, pick it up and flip it over, all with one hand. Really speeded up the process not having to clamp and unclamp every cut. For the price, I can save a lot of time and effort.
Ralph
-- www.consultingwoodworker.com Look me up on Twitter as ConsultingWood
Gene Howe
home | projects | blog
334 posts in 324 days
posted 101 days ago
Mine arrived before we left on vacation. Tried them yesterday. Edge routing. Work well. set them on a piece of drawer liner. Very secure.
Gene
-- Gene
TheDane
home | projects | blog
209 posts in 559 days
posted 98 days ago
I thought I had everything for my workbench … then Rockler came out with ‘Bench Cookies’, and all of a sudden they became a ‘must have’.
I have used them to route profiles around the outside edges of raised panels without the use of any clamps, hold-downs or dogs, which means there is nothing to get in the way of the router bearing. Since the raised center of the panel is proud of the rails & stiles, I couldn’t route the profile on my router table, and when I would do the profile on the workbench, I could only do half of it before stopping and rotating the workpiece in the bench dogs. The ‘Bench Cookies’ solved that problem.
I was initially concerned about sawdust buildup on the rubber surfaces, but so far that hasn’t been a problem. I used them to sand maple and oak with 400 grit sandpaper, and just used my ShopVac to clean the rubber surfaces to look like new. And they seem to grip well even with a pretty generous amount of sawdust on them.
Another great idea from Rockler!
-- The only place success comes before work is in the dictionary. -- Vincent T. Lombardi
Jerry
home | projects | blog
80 posts in 434 days
posted 65 days ago
Great “tools” and a very good video review
Thanks!!!
-- Jerry - Rochester, MN *Whether you think you can or you can't, you are probably right*
poroskywood
home | projects | blog
198 posts in 260 days
posted 65 days ago
LOVE EM’
-- There's many a slip betwixt a cup and a lip.--Scott
DaveH
home | projects | blog
372 posts in 674 days
posted 13 days ago
I bought 3 sets and decided to make my own version. MDF and black rubber like shelf liner from Lows and a little contact cement. I made 30 for about 10 cents apiece. I cut the block to size after gluing every thing up. Took about an hour.
-- DaveH - Boise, Idaho - “How hard can it be? It's only wood!”