LumberJocks

Impressed, good value so far

  • Advertise with us
Review by momalle3 posted 02-05-2016 08:28 AM 3748 views 0 times favorited 7 comments Add to Favorites Watch
Impressed, good value so far Impressed, good value so far Impressed, good value so far Click the pictures to enlarge them

I had for years been using an old Delta 12 inch saw that I got on Craigslist. It was wearing out in multiple ways all at once and all the problems were hard to fix since it’s long discontinued, plus it only has a 6 inch resaw capacity and for most of what i do eight would be about right.

I did a lot of research, including reviews here, and settled on the Craftsman BAS 350 which is the same as the Rikon 10-321, only @200 bucks cheaper. I was thinking about the Rikon 10-325, but it’s more than twice as much. I ended up paying $407 for the Craftsman saw, which the household budget likes.

So the saw comes in a single big box. I was able to get it out of my station wagon and onto a handtruck and into my shop with little trouble. Unboxed it and assembled the base. I needed to use a drift pin to get the holes that mount the saw to the base to line up. One problem: the thrust bearing for the upper guide assembly had fallen out in shipping, and for a moment I thought it was lost. But I found the parts and it was easy to figure out how it went together. I was able to lift the whole saw myself (without the table attached) and set it on my workbench to do some of the assembly. I built a mobile base, and then was able to muscle the saw onto the base and bolt it down. Then bolt the table on.

Things I like

In general, the fit and finish seems very good. The table is heavy, generously sized and checks flat. The unit runs smoothly and quietly. The blade guide lowers and raises smoothly. The saw tracked very well out of the box. The dust port (there are two: a 2 inch and a four inch I’m using the 2) is well placed and very effective. There’s a nice little allen wrench holder that screws to the saw so you can keep the adjustment wrenches handy. it ships with the wrenches. The 1/4 blade it comes with is very good. It is orders of magnitude better than my old saw.It cuts better, quicker, and more smoothly

Things I don’t like
The lower blade guide is a pain to set—it’s poorly designed, I think. I got it set correctly, but it took a lot of fussing and some awkward reaching to hold the hex bolt head in place while tightening the lock nut. The knob for adjusting the blade guide up and down is too small—I want it to have a crank on it. I would turn a replacement on the wood lathe if I could figure out how to get the stock knob off—it appears to be glued onto the shaft. The tension adjustment knob is on top, which is common but a pain, and it would also really benefit from a crank handle. I may be able to rig something. I do wish it had the quick blade release that’s on the 10-325. The table insert is a little low and doesn’t sit flush with the top. I made a new one out of a piece of Padauk I had on hand. The trunnion casting is a little rough—the table doesn’t tilt smoothly

I haven’t tried any heavy resawing yet. When i do I’ll report back. The work i have done has been a joy. It did bog down once as I was sawing up a large log for our small woodstove.

It’s a basic saw with few convenience features and some ergonomic shortcomings but the key thing—sawing—works very well: I’m pretty impressed wth the level of value for the money. I ordered a Rikon fence for it, which hasn’t arrived yet. So far, very impressed with the price to value ratio here and with the saw’s effectiveness

Note: I added a couple pictures. The two things that bothered me most, once I got the lower guide set up, were the blade tension knob and the guide adjustment knob. The blade tension knob was sort of a pain because it took a lot of turns. I made a simple crank out of scrap and dowels, following a post someone made here. Now I can tension /detension very quickly and easily

The guide adjust knob was annoying—it never felt right, it took too many turns to move it down. It’s a small knob glued onto a shaft—there’s no way to remove it without destroying it. It has a removable cap, but there’s nothing behind the cap but hollow space.

I took a piece of scrap cherry, and started a hole using a hole saw in my drill press. I didn’t go all the way through. Then I used a router bit with a bearing guide to rout out a cavity that fit over the existing knob. Then I drilled a 1/4 hole through the whole thing, using a long 1/4 bit I had on hand, and a 1/4 hole for the handle. After that cut it to round, about an inch all around wider than the existing knob, rounded it over with a router bit, and then filed grooves into it with a round rasp.

I clamped the wooden knob to the stock knob and drilled a 1/4 hole through it using the holes in the wooden knob as a guide. Then I filled the cavity of the stock knob with epoxy putty and inserted a 1/4 steel rod though the whole thing, pinning the wooden knob to the stock plastic knob. Turned a new crank knob on the wood lathe and attached. Basically the wooden knob is just a larger knob covering the old knob, and pinned to it. Sounds complicated and it’s a little ridiculous, but the saw is much much more pleasant to operate now and the improvements were basically free.

Still very impressed with how well it cuts

-- Dreading the midas touch of expertise




View momalle3's profile

momalle3

12 posts in 959 days



7 comments so far

View Puffball's profile

Puffball

43 posts in 1329 days


#1 posted 02-05-2016 02:28 PM

Good review. I have the same saw and I like it for the price. It meets my expectations.

Blade changing can be a PITA, as you have to remove the fence if you have it installed. Not terrible, but just one more step.

Adjusting the the lower blade is a pain. Its doable, but not very inviting.

Resaw-wise. I have been pretty successful with a 1/2” Highland Woodslicer bade on it. I can get good results up to 6”. >6” and i get lots of wavy, tapered cuts.

Its a nice, no frills saw that does the job. For anybody in the < $500 range for a bandsaw its a good saw.

View Mvg2's profile

Mvg2

19 posts in 1503 days


#2 posted 02-05-2016 04:58 PM

Got one too and agree with the statements. The lower guides are fussy for sure. Not sure about yours, but my upper guides always need adjustment whenever I raise or lower them.

It’s a pain but, but for the price, as you said, it’s a great saw. With a nice blade it made quick work for my batch of wavy cutting boards.

Oh, and the dust collection works pretty well too.

Glad your enjoying yours as well :)

View momalle3's profile

momalle3

12 posts in 959 days


#3 posted 02-05-2016 10:53 PM

Thank you, I’ll try one of those woodslicer blades

I made a crank for the blade tension knob, just out of scrap wood and dowels as I saw in a thread here. Makes that a much faster and more pleasant thing.

I really would like to get rid of the blade guide adjustment knob. It feels too small to me—I have fairly big hands—and it feels kind of unpleasant to turn. It seems to be glued to the shaft, and the only way to get it off would be to destroy it, as far as I can tell. Then I’d have to clean up the glued-on remains and find or make a suitable crank wheel, and the saw would be out of commission while I waited. It’s a trivial thing, but i can tell it’s going to nag at me!

-- Dreading the midas touch of expertise

View Grumpymike's profile

Grumpymike

2289 posts in 2432 days


#4 posted 02-06-2016 01:08 AM

Alex Snodgrass has a really good how to on bandsaws. Catch him on U-Tube.
In one segment he addresses the lower guide bearings … Just remove the table, a couple of bolts and there is everything in easy reach … My saw is a Rikon, and now I complete a blade change in 5-7 minutes. Thanks Alex.

-- Grumpy old guy, and lookin' good Doin' it. ... Surprise Az.

View momalle3's profile

momalle3

12 posts in 959 days


#5 posted 02-06-2016 08:41 PM

Thanks I have watched the video and it’s VERY useful. I added a note and a couple pictures about how I improved a couple of the knobs.

-- Dreading the midas touch of expertise

View jonah's profile

jonah

1837 posts in 3415 days


#6 posted 07-10-2017 03:20 PM

This saw is on sale for $350 now. Any comments a year or so after purchase?

View momalle3's profile

momalle3

12 posts in 959 days


#7 posted 07-13-2017 08:58 PM



This saw is on sale for $350 now. Any comments a year or so after purchase?

- jonah

Yes still very happy with it. It hasn’t bogged down on me and it cuts very true when set right. The blade tension knob is annoying, but I fixed that with the crank. I think it’s a great deal for $350

-- Dreading the midas touch of expertise

Have your say...

You must be signed in to post the comments.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com