|Review by RandyMorter||posted 03-13-2011 07:46 PM||2483 views||1 time favorited||7 comments|
Just so you know, this is the first and only time I’ve ever used a Forstner bit.
I’m working on a toy airplane project and believe I’ll have a need for these (I did in my first toy airplane – for the cockpit). Woodcraft has this set on sale right now for $12.49 (through 4/2/2011) so how can you go wrong?
These bits come in a nice wood case. They are stamped with their size, “China”, and the max RPM on each bit.
I made a couple of test cuts with the 3/4” bit into some redwood. I know, the redwood is soft. I randomly picked this bit size. The person at the store (in Chandler, AZ) said the key to these bits was to use them at 250-300 RPM. My DP will go to 300 so I used that speed. Note that the speed chart that comes with the bits says they can be used a lot faster. The 3/4” states it can be used at 1800 RPM in soft wood.
I used a pretty slow feed rate too, just looking at the thickness of the shavings as a guide.
The bit worked without any issue in the hole in the middle of the work piece. It worked okay on the edge cut too except for my inadequate clamping (you can see the multiple entry cuts in the picture).
The bit seemed to leave a nice smooth cut on the sides and the bottom.
I only rated these 4 stars because you can easily see what looks like burrs and nicks on the cutting edges. These are NOT carbide tipped. The ad for these claims they’re suitable for the hobbyist or occaisional user and I believe they are good for that (which is the category I’m placing myself in).
I wish they had perfect cutting edges and were carbon tipped, but you have to spend more to get that. IF or WHEN I wear these out I’ll replace them with a better set. I just figured these may actually work for me as often as I can see myself using them (I’m 53 years old and never have used them before – these could outlast me!).
For this price I think they’re a great value since the Woodcraft “Quality Forstner Bit, 1/2 Inch” is $12.99 by itself! Yeah, there’s a significant quality difference but since I think I’ll make maybe a half-dozen holes with these each year, this seems like a good way to go.
I used the 3/8” bit last night without issue (in redwood). I really think these will be fine for my purposes. I still think the 4 stars is valid – they weren’t perfect looking out of the box, but I think they’ll do the job. The burrs / nicks don’t seem to make a difference. I don’t think I’ll be drilling hundreds of holes per day in hard wood.
-- Randy Morter, Phoenix, AZ