| Review by moshel | posted 974 days ago | 2395 views | 0 times favorited | 9 comments | ![]() |
![]() |
- Marcou refurb Stanley 4 1/2
- Brand: Marcou | Category: Hand Planes

At last, something you guys in the US can’t get!
Over the NZLJ milling weekend, grimt showed me a plane he purchased some time ago that was refurbished by Philip Marcou. I was most impressed with the plane but it seems that Philip stopped selling them. As you do (or don’t) know, Philip Marcou is one of the top high end plane makers in the world (read the reviews on his site). His planes are beautiful, and probably an experience to use, and just from watching the pictures you want to hug them and cuddle them when you go to sleep.
I decided to ask him if he is still doing it, and hurrey! he had a 4 1/2 (which is what I needed). Apparently he stopped making them because his regular planes are selling well (his regular planes are beyond my budget – 1000-2000$).
The package arrived and in it lay the Stanley (UK) 4 1/2. first impressions where how smooth everything was. the wood parts were finished to perfection
The timber is Affrormosia wood from Zimbabwe.
the sole was satin mirror finish, and so were the sides. he uses a surface grinder for this – you just can’t beat this for flatness.
The blade was cambered and honed. the blade itself was also very flat and smooth. so, out of the box, i could use it right away!!!! such joy!
The 4 1/2 is heavier than the 4 and wider, giving more control and you can skew the plane and still get reasonable width.
the adjustment is very precise – almost no slack in the knob – he milled the knob himself.
This is a piece of Rimu with tool marks on it:
this is the same piece after 30 seconds of planing:
and here are some nude shavings posing for the camera:
All and all, a pleasure to use. I have used it so far to plane my tiny japanese grease box (I would never think on doing this with my old #4), a cheese board and generally every piece of timber in my shop.
-- The woods are lovely, dark and deep, but I have promises to keep...





















9 comments so far
degoose
home | projects | blog
6588 posts in 1520 days
#1 posted 974 days ago
Wonderful story wonderful buy.
-- Drink twice... and don't bother to cut... @ larrysworkshop.wordpress.com For lovers of all things timber...
Shopsmithtom
home | projects | blog
768 posts in 2360 days
#2 posted 974 days ago
I’m a firm believer that some of the best planes are old Stanleys that have been tuned up. Here is another example of that. Great…lucky you.
-- Accuracy is not in your power tool, it's in you
blackcherry
home | projects | blog
2900 posts in 1988 days
#3 posted 974 days ago
Drool City, it a beauty of a plane, lucky you. Enjoy and thanks for posting…BC
grimt
home | projects | blog
24 posts in 1725 days
#4 posted 974 days ago
Glad you managed to get the 4.5 Moshe. Welcome to the PM club! I put a hock blade in mine and it now cuts even better though looking at the shavings in your pictures yours looks just fine with the Stanley blade.
Mr marcou is indeed a fine fettler.
dub560
home | projects | blog
602 posts in 1078 days
#5 posted 973 days ago
i have a smooth plane and just can’t seem to get shavings like what you displaying there ..i envy you
-- Life is enjoyable especially when you borrow from people
moshel
home | projects | blog
838 posts in 1849 days
#6 posted 973 days ago
dub560, i can’t seem to put my finger on what makes this such a great plane – probably the overall tuneup.
I worked for hours (hours? days!) on my old #5 and never got it to work well. I now accept that there are people that just knows much more than me about planes.
-- The woods are lovely, dark and deep, but I have promises to keep...
moshel
home | projects | blog
838 posts in 1849 days
#7 posted 973 days ago
BTW, if anyone wants to buy a genuine Marcou plane, he will be in the Popular Woodworking show in Cincinnati later this month. Bring your Cheque books!
-- The woods are lovely, dark and deep, but I have promises to keep...
moshel
home | projects | blog
838 posts in 1849 days
#8 posted 973 days ago
grimt, you can also post a review about your plane. I must admit the timber on yours is even prettier than mine. BTW, do you have a list of weird words you pick from? (I used to have such a list – must find it).
-- The woods are lovely, dark and deep, but I have promises to keep...
moshel
home | projects | blog
838 posts in 1849 days
#9 posted 971 days ago
Philip just sent me a link to more pictures of his refurb planes http://picasaweb.google.com/philipmarcou/StanleyTypeRefurbishedPlanes#5357140769661252098
-- The woods are lovely, dark and deep, but I have promises to keep...
Have your say...