LumberJocks

All Replies on Building a changing table to be painted. Poplar or is pine ok?

  • Advertise with us
View Zahnarzt's profile

Building a changing table to be painted. Poplar or is pine ok?

by Zahnarzt
posted 06-20-2012 11:32 PM


23 replies so far

View bent's profile

bent

311 posts in 3784 days


#1 posted 06-21-2012 12:17 AM

first off, congratulations.

if you’re painting it, i don’t think poplar vs. pine is a big issue. either wood will be strong enough. just be sure you put a back on it, so that it doesn’t rack. as a far as differences, the pine will dent easier, but will smell better when you’re cutting it. also, i don’t think premium pine from a big box store will be any cheaper than poplar. from what i’ve seen, they tend to charge about 2-3x the normal rate for lumber.

View Zahnarzt's profile

Zahnarzt

29 posts in 2471 days


#2 posted 06-21-2012 12:45 AM

Thanks, bent. I appreciate the input and the good tidings I was planning on using 1/4” ply for the back in addition to 3 rails on the front and back to connect the side frames. I’m not much of an engineer but do you think this will be enough to prevent the racking?

-- That hoopy frood really knows where his towel is.

View Knothead62's profile

Knothead62

2584 posts in 3076 days


#3 posted 06-21-2012 12:50 AM

We had an unfinished pine dresser that we used for a changing table. We used a waterprooof polyurethane for it. Never know when babies are going to surprise you!

View bent's profile

bent

311 posts in 3784 days


#4 posted 06-21-2012 01:00 AM

yeah, 1/4” ply will be plenty strong. the purpose of the back is to stiffen the piece, and not really to provide structural strength.

View Lee A. Jesberger's profile

Lee A. Jesberger

6862 posts in 4095 days


#5 posted 06-21-2012 01:04 AM

Congrats on the new baby.

Personaly, I like to use poplar instead of pine. The reason is the pine is more likely to get dented, and also, knots and sap is far more likely to interfere with the finish.

Lee

-- by Lee A. Jesberger http://www.prowoodworkingtips.com http://www.ezee-feed.com

View Zahnarzt's profile

Zahnarzt

29 posts in 2471 days


#6 posted 06-21-2012 01:45 AM

It is a baby girl so hopefully long distance watering won’t be an issue but waterproof sounds like just what the doctor ordered in terms of finish. This table will hopefully last for one more baby and 2-3 house moves so it sounds like poplar might be a better choice to prevent denting. I’ll get pics up ASAP as I plan to start cutting this weekend.

-- That hoopy frood really knows where his towel is.

View Mike's profile

Mike

60 posts in 2325 days


#7 posted 06-21-2012 01:54 AM

I second what Lee said about knots and sap. I like working with pine, but I never paint over it…that sap just bleeds right through no matter what I’ve used as a primer.I even sanded down a big sappy knot, coated it with Kilz, re-primed it, painted it again and it still bled up through the latex paint. Soft maple isn’t too much more expensive than pine around my area, more dent resistant than pine without the bleed through issues. With that said, I bought an unfinished pine dresser for my son, gave it a light stain and a few coats of poly and it still looks great. Does it have to be painted? Congrats on your future daughter…you’re in for the best time of your life!

View MonteCristo's profile

MonteCristo

2099 posts in 2304 days


#8 posted 06-21-2012 02:19 AM

Shellac is supposed to be the thing to use to seal knots so that you can paint over them. GOOGLE “seal knots with shellac” and you’ll get some hits . . .

-- Dwight - "Free legal advice available - contact Dewey, Cheetam & Howe""

View Dark_Lightning's profile

Dark_Lightning

3220 posts in 3224 days


#9 posted 06-21-2012 02:38 AM

First of all, congratulations! Use poplar, it is WAY easier to get smooth and paint than pine. If you are painting, I’d recommend a product like Zinnser’s sealers. They will even seal the knots on pine boards…though I like the look of knotty pine and use nitrocellulose lacquer on them, myself. Plus, it yellows nicely over the years.

-- Random Orbital Nailer

View BentheViking's profile

BentheViking

1782 posts in 2679 days


#10 posted 06-21-2012 03:29 AM

skip the big box store and go to a lumber yard or mill or even craigslist…get something better for less usually

-- It's made of wood. Real sturdy.--Chubbs Peterson

View lumberjoe's profile

lumberjoe

2899 posts in 2363 days


#11 posted 06-21-2012 12:14 PM

I made some radiator covers. 2 from pine, 2 from poplar. Both primed with Zinnsers (Bulls eye) 123 and then painted some silly named color my wife picked out to match the trim – to me it’s “off white”. After about a year, the pine looks like crap. A lot of the knots are visible – not so much the color, but the outline. The poplar looks great still. Also poplar was so much easier to work with.

-- https://pinepointwoodworks.wordpress.com/

View dhazelton's profile

dhazelton

2789 posts in 2412 days


#12 posted 06-21-2012 01:11 PM

I’d go through the #2 pine and find the cleanest stuff you can. You can cut knots out depending on your cutlist (there will be stuff on the shelves and a cushion and blankets on the top, so you may never even see any knots). Take the money you save on lumber and buy diapers or put it in a college fund. If money is no object and you want an heirloom piece, then go poplar. You could substitute MDF for the shelf panels if you want to even out the cost.

View ChuckC's profile

ChuckC

842 posts in 3050 days


#13 posted 06-21-2012 01:24 PM

Definitely poplar. I stay away from pine almost always but when I use it I only use a clear finish.

I’m also not sure how much you will save if you get premium pine compared to the cost of Poplar? No 2 pine is VERY cheap but it would be a nightmare to get a decent paint finish.

Changing tables are usually considered disposable so maybe go with MDF and use poplar for face frames to hide the edges?

Oh yea, congratulations!

View Bluepine38's profile

Bluepine38

3379 posts in 3200 days


#14 posted 06-21-2012 02:23 PM

Plywood with an edge facing is another easy way to go. My 3rd giggling daughter surprised me with a minor
deluge that went through the cloth diaper and required a mop. Boys may spray farther, but with babies, the
unexpected always seems to happen. Congratulations on your upcoming addition, and may you have many
happy years.

-- As ever, Gus-the 79 yr young apprentice carpenter

View dhazelton's profile

dhazelton

2789 posts in 2412 days


#15 posted 06-21-2012 02:59 PM

That’s why I would only suggest MDF for the lower shelves. Even painted, if it gets wet it’ll swell up like a balloon.

View Puzzleman's profile

Puzzleman

417 posts in 3059 days


#16 posted 06-21-2012 03:50 PM

I would suggest sheet goods as a way to go. Lot easier to work with as well as pints well. My suggestion is to use a 3/4 maple or birch. The maple will give a smoother finish. Trim the front of either with a short piece of maple.

I think will be a quicker and easier way to do it. I make products for babies and children and use all sheet goods. Have never had a problem with splintering or anything else.

-- Jim Beachler, Chief Puzzler, http://www.hollowwoodworks.com

View Zahnarzt's profile

Zahnarzt

29 posts in 2471 days


#17 posted 06-22-2012 02:12 AM

My design is coming together and I’m thinking poplar frames and plywood shelves. I am a Zinsser disciple and use it on almost every project for one purpose or another, but after hearing about all these pee issues I might cover this whole thing with bar-top epoxy!!
I’ve only painted one pine project so far and it was just 2 months ago with (fingers crossed) no problems so far. I wonder if a stiffer gloss contains the sap better…

-- That hoopy frood really knows where his towel is.

View jumbojack's profile

jumbojack

1681 posts in 2739 days


#18 posted 06-22-2012 02:29 AM

Most of the time poplar is going to be cheaper than ‘premium’ pine. It all the time machines better than pine. It takes paint better than pine. Most poplar is knot free, straight grained and does not blow out like pine can. I like Zinsser 123 as a base coat, a light sand, although Zinsser says it does not need it, it does. Then what ever color your wife picks out. If you can spray your paint do so…..wait…...find a way to spray it, you won’t be sorry.

-- Made in America, with American made tools....Shopsmith

View Zahnarzt's profile

Zahnarzt

29 posts in 2471 days


#19 posted 06-22-2012 04:46 PM

My last pre-baby gift to myself will be a compressor and basic HVLP sprayer. After trying to hand paint a few adirondack chairs post assembly, with their endless nooks and crannies, I am very motivated to start spraying.

-- That hoopy frood really knows where his towel is.

View Woodknack's profile

Woodknack

12329 posts in 2495 days


#20 posted 07-01-2012 05:38 PM

Congratulations. Poplar is a little easier to work with, southern yellow pine is actually harder than poplar, both are about 2x harder than white pine. Longleaf pine is the hardest, harder than mahogany.

-- Rick M, http://thewoodknack.blogspot.com/

View a1Jim's profile

a1Jim

117203 posts in 3692 days


#21 posted 07-01-2012 05:44 PM

Congrats on you baby girl. Nothing can be more gratifying than making things for the people you love especially your first child. I agree that poplar is a much superior wood verses pine I also agree the sheet goods are a viable option.

-- https://www.artisticwoodstudio.com/videos wood crafting & woodworking classes

View 404 - Not Found's profile

404 - Not Found

2544 posts in 3084 days


#22 posted 07-01-2012 07:27 PM

I’d go with poplar over pine any day of the week. For the amount that’s in it, the difference in cost shouldn’t be too great. Poplar works really well, especially if you’re routing edge mouldings, and takes paint really well.

View Zahnarzt's profile

Zahnarzt

29 posts in 2471 days


#23 posted 09-30-2012 01:36 AM

Finally finished! Thanks everybody for your advice and opinions. I am psyched with how it turned out!

http://lumberjocks.com/projects/72051

-- That hoopy frood really knows where his towel is.

Have your say...

You must be signed in to reply.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com