Brian,
i just got some hickory from a place in St. Anthony, just off of SR 64, near Huntingburg/Jasper Area.
They are called Indian Creek Wood Products, Address: 6511 South Club Road, St. Anthony, IN 47575
Phone number (812) 326-9802. Gene and Karen are super people that are very accommodating. They are open usually on Saturdays only or by appointment during the week. I always call before I go to make sure they have the material and will be around… they have lots of different types of wood and also can custom kiln dry for you.
I paid $1.50 bf for 4/4 hickory and $2.00 for hard maple. The hickory I got was mostly the white hickory, very little heart. They have always let me select my own lumber as well…
Good luck!