Hello, I am new to the forum so I hope I have posted this in the appropriate area! I am about to glue and screw a cherry coffee table project I have been working on and have tested a few finishes on scrap and looking for some thoughts from others. So far I tried danish oil topped with shellac but will more then likely use rub on poly so it had a little more durability as this will be used in the "man cave" which probably means spills. I like the way the oil looks on the wood but I am seeing the "blotchy" areas or "figure". Otherwise the color and grain looks impressive. I have also tried minwax cherry gel stain which has no blotch but the color is similar to the oil an looks fake or artificial to me. I have let both "suntan" for 12 hours. As this will be In a basement will its darken as much as it would in front of a large window? Also does the color of BLO differ much from the danish oil? Thanks in advance for your thoughts. I have attached a photo of the table dry assembled upside down
great looking table,i've been using the danish oil lately on every project with wipe on poly.sorry i'm not much help but theres some smart people on here that should chime in.
If it were me I would use Waterlox original. Wipe on about six coats, let it cure for 30 days and rub it out. Waterlox will make it "pop" as it has Tung oil in it. Waterlox will provide a durable finish for a man cave. The cherry will darken over time even in a basement.
I do not like poly as it gives the wood a plastic look
That piece came from what I could salvage from an old twisted/checked/bowed chunk of what was a beam. I used a Zar product in cherry finish. Was very light when I made it but a few years later it has developed a darker patina. Given all the worm-holes/tracks on that piece it looks more like an antique now.
I was just experimenting with cherry and pine who both are prone to blotching for a piece I am about to finish.
Indeed gels will eliminate blotching but they change the color. Another option which works well enough is to first use a coat of wax-free shellac diluted to 1lb cut or less. Let it dry and very lightly sand with 320 to remove the nibs. Apply your oil stain on top of that. The shellac will partially seal the cherry (but not completely since its a very diluted one) and allow for the oil stain to penetrate evenly rather than blotch.
I did not come up with this idea, it is a technique that is described by Bob Flexner in his book "Flexner on Finishing".
Once you are satisfied with the look of it, lock in the stain by another few coats of dewaxed shellacs, making sure its dry between coats and using 320 grits each coat. After that's dry, you can apply any kind of polyurethane or other varnish to make it durable.
Just realized I never did post a picture of the finished product. Several applications of Danish oil top coated with wipe on poly. This photo was taken approx a year ago, the cherry is darkening nicely now
A 50/50 mix of BLO and mineral spirits to pop the grain, then wipe on oil base poly, my favorite is min wax gloss or statin to your taste. Mine handles a lot of Vodka Martini spills!!!
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
LumberJocks Woodworking Forum
2.5M posts
96K members
Since 2006
A forum community dedicated to professional woodworkers and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about shop safety, wood, carpentry, lumber, finishing, tools, machinery, woodworking related topics, styles, scales, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!