Reply by Don W

  • Advertise with us

Posted on Which sharpening stones should I get?

View Don W's profile

Don W

18754 posts in 2591 days

#1 posted 02-22-2012 03:26 AM

I started with water stones. My major complaints with them were two fold. First, my shop isn’t heated, so that was a hassle. Second, they needed flattening a lot. I hated the mess. I never really went the sand paper route, but I’m sure they are better than that.

I then managed to pick up some oil stones in a lot of other tools I bought. I essentially got them for next to nothing. What I liked over the water stones was I didn’t need to use water, so I didn’t have the freezing issue or the mess. I used a diesel fuel / mineral oil mix which meant I didn’t worry about rusting my tools. The point I didn’t like was I never knew what grit I was using, (used vintage stones) but they worked well and I still use them. The oil is still messy, but not as near as bad as the water.

I recently caught a buy-it-now on ebay for 4 dia-sharp DMT diamond stones for a really reasonable price. I bought them on a whim. I like them so far. I’ve only sharpened about 5 or 6 planes on them, but they work well. What I like about them is I have a nice uniform set. A course, medium, fine and ultra fine. They do slide around on the bench a lot more than the oil stones, so I’ll need to get them in a base of some sort.

So for a suggestion. If your a flea market, antique shop, trying to find the second hand stuff, go for the oil stones. You can get them pretty cheap, they work really well, and in a reasonable amount of time you can have a set. By a set, I mean a course, medium and fine stone. I’ve got 6 or 8 I’ve picked up over the course of time, some I like, some not so much, but I don’t have $50 in all of them.

If your going new, its a tough call. I would love to have a set of new oil stones. I think in reality for new, diamonds may be a woodwrokers best friend. They never need flattening, you can use glass cleaner, water and murphys oil soap, and a host of other lubricants (I understand you shouldn’t use diesel fuel or similar substrates) and they are suppose to last a very long time.

Its an interesting question. I’m cheap, so I’m glad I found what I did.

-- - Collecting is an investment in the past, and the future.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics