| Project by RedBeard | posted 121 days ago | 438 views | 3 times favorited | 14 comments | ![]() |
For my senior thesis project I wanted to create a tool to help beginning woodworkers learn about good design and craftsmanship. The design is basically a shaker style table with two drawers that has been split in half. One half is loaded with commonly made mistakes, poorly chosen lumber, and a finish that is just disgusting. The other half features beautiful wood, carefully thought-out and executed joinery, solid construction, and a finish that will make you blush. I added an inlay feature on the table-top where the two halves meet. It shows Two-face from batman, done with appropriately good and bad techniques. I created a large (80”x56”) poster which served as a map to the piece, illustrating each of the intentional mistakes as well as explaining their well-crafted counterparts on the other half.Thanks to everyone who helped out with stories of their own mistakes. I have more process pictures and I am trying to find a nice way to display them online. I hope you all like it.
Evan
-- Measure once, cut twice
Your Online Shop - Your Support Is Greatly Appreciated - Your Woodworking Showcase - 3 Ways To Help, Financially - Your Woodworking Community
























14 comments so far
HokieMojo
home | projects | blog
335 posts in 214 days
posted 121 days ago
Despite the intentional “mistakes”, I think the whole thing came out incredible. One of my favorites I’ve seen yet.
Napaman
home | projects | blog
1791 posts in 563 days
posted 121 days ago
i cant tell which side is the side with mistakes—-so tell your professors that your teaching tool is perfect—-because when i get a close-up look..with more pictures I will really learn!!!\
good luck with the grade…personally (and professionally as a teacher) this is an excellent teaching medium. Teaching with metaphor and truly makes people thiink and they will remember the lessons…
Excellent concept…A+
-- Matt, Napa, CA...142 days to sanity...
YorkshireStewart
home | projects | blog
637 posts in 387 days
posted 120 days ago
What an intriguing piece of work RB. I, too, would like to see a series of pictures showing some of the errors. Thanks for sharing it.
-- Res severa verum gaudium - True pleasure is a serious business.
mzmac
home | projects | blog
46 posts in 153 days
posted 120 days ago
This table is quite a statement to your craft. Well done.
darryl
home | projects | blog
855 posts in 812 days
posted 120 days ago
that’s pretty clever.
great looking work.
for me, both would have the same amount of mistakes!!
-- ~ www.darrylmasterson.com ~ www.woodworkingdungeon.blogspot.com ~
Greg Wurst
home | projects | blog
414 posts in 318 days
posted 120 days ago
Heck, your bad side looks better than some of my good projects! ;)
Nice work.
Damian Penney
home | projects | blog
682 posts in 477 days
posted 120 days ago
This is great :)
-- I am always doing that which I can not do, in order that I may learn how to do it. - Pablo Picasso
CharlieM1958
home | projects | blog
4196 posts in 704 days
posted 120 days ago
Great project! I’d love to see it in person, because I really can’t see the mistakes on the “mistake” side.
-- Charlie M. "Woodworking - patience = firewood"
RedBeard
home | projects | blog
7 posts in 148 days
posted 120 days ago
Here are the pictures of the bad side construction. Good side will be up soon.
http://photobucket.com/TwoFaceTeachingTable
Thanks for all of the comments. With the bad side I was trying to show the work of someone who means well, but is either too impatient or just too new to the craft to use proper technique – basically me before I began researching this project. I’ve always had the woodworking bug, but now I have a much greater appreciation for what it takes to do it right. If anyone is near Cincinnati and would like to check this table out just let me know.
Thanks again,
Evan
-- Measure once, cut twice
RedBeard
home | projects | blog
7 posts in 148 days
posted 120 days ago
Here are pics of the good side
http://photobucket.com/TwoFaceTeachingTableGood
-- Measure once, cut twice
jeanmarc
home | projects | blog
1752 posts in 202 days
posted 120 days ago
Very nice work.
-- jeanmarc manosque france
CharlieM1958
home | projects | blog
4196 posts in 704 days
posted 120 days ago
After looking at photos of the bad side, can I get a big “been there, done that” amen? <g>
-- Charlie M. "Woodworking - patience = firewood"
jockmike2
home | projects | blog
4142 posts in 732 days
posted 120 days ago
Very good teaching tool. Mike
-- Mike. Profisher50@yahoo.com
Colin
home | projects | blog
128 posts in 406 days
posted 120 days ago
fascinating, your students will learn a lot from your teaching.
-- Colin, Aberdeenshire, Scotland. "Every craftsman was once an amateur"