| Project by DonH | posted 735 days ago | 4460 views | 61 times favorited | 45 comments | ![]() |
![]() |
This is a quick and easy dust collector improvement (upper canister or bag type) that has unbelievable performance benefits and costs about $10 to do. It is a wood working project as it contains a block of wood.
This mod is based on the new Jet Vortex dust collector technology which is basically a wok type plug in the airflow between the lower and upper bags. To get a proper picture of this, now is the time to go to their web site or Popular Woodworking web site – editors BLOG and search for Jet Vortex. The PW site includes a video and other material that demonstrates the performance improvement. What basically happens is that the vortex of dust particles in the lower bag is prevented from rising into the upper filter area and considerably reduces filter clogging with no apparent effect on air flow. Following is my experience and tests.
First, I could not find an affordable wok of the right size that I was willing to drill a hole into. So my first try was a stainless steel salad bowl 14 inches in diameter. This bowl extended deeper into the lower bag area than the Jet “wok”. After filling the lower bag to about 10% full I removed the canister and found some performance improvement but not up to what the Jet video showed. Apparently the shape of the salad bowl was intercepting some of the incoming airflow and deflecting it upward. When I removed the canister I got about a handful of dust on me and there was some coating the filter. So I cleaned it up and inserted a 14 inch flower pot tray instead. This is a heavy duty version of fairly sturdy plastic and its shape is much flatter than the Jet wok.
I ran the dust collector while planning and sawing some wood until it was about 1/3 full without turning the flapper that cleans the filter – there was no noticeable loss in suction performance (in fact after the thorough filter cleaning it was better than I can remember). I then removed the canister and WOW!!! Less than a tablespoon of dust fell out and the canister was almost as clean as when I started.
I don’t know how well this compares to the Jet performance but it must be close. I am going to run the dust collector, without using the flapper thing until the bag is full and check it out again. I am confident the performance will be about the same. At that time I am going to add a cross brace at 90 degrees to the existing one with blocks under to better brace the dish. I cant see it but it must wobble a bit (this was just a test in the beginning). However, at the 1/3 bag point there was no apparent wear and tear on the dish.
Check out the video and other info and try it – you WILL like it.
By the way, I have a stainless steel salad bowl with a 1/4 inch hole in it for sale – cheap.
Don
-- DonH Orleans Ontario
| Pin It |






























45 comments so far
docholladay
home | projects | blog
1258 posts in 1228 days
#1 posted 735 days ago
That’s pretty smart thinking. A lot less expensive than the Vortex. Well done.
-- Hey, woodworking ain't brain surgery. Just do something and keep trying till you get it. Doc
DonH
home | projects | blog
482 posts in 986 days
#2 posted 735 days ago
Thanks Doc
-- DonH Orleans Ontario
sras
home | projects | blog
3245 posts in 1298 days
#3 posted 735 days ago
Thanks for the tip, I might have to try this.
-- Steve - Impatience is Expensive
jburklow
home | projects | blog
24 posts in 843 days
#4 posted 735 days ago
Thanks for posting looks very interesting! I will definately give this a try. The dust collector is definately the 600 pound gorilla in the room when it comes to emptying it so anything to keep that fine dust in the lower half is very much welcome.
DonH
home | projects | blog
482 posts in 986 days
#5 posted 735 days ago
Thanks guys – and you are right jburklow, having the upper canister dump all over you while changing bags is a big drag – especially as it is the finer stuff in the top.
Don
-- DonH Orleans Ontario
sarahss
home | projects | blog
234 posts in 818 days
#6 posted 735 days ago
I noticed that you have an upper filter. I just have the cheapie HF 2 hp collector—no upper filter. Would this work for it as well?
DonH
home | projects | blog
482 posts in 986 days
#7 posted 735 days ago
No problem – I assume you do have a fliter bag in the upper position?
-- DonH Orleans Ontario
llwynog
home | projects | blog
231 posts in 748 days
#8 posted 735 days ago
This is a neat trick, thanks a lot.
-- Fabrice - "On est bien bĂȘte mais on sent bien quand on se fait mal" - my grandfather
Jahness
home | projects | blog
71 posts in 933 days
#9 posted 735 days ago
Being not to knowledgeable with Dust Collectors, dosen’t this cut off air flow to the upper filter bag? I just bought the HF 2HP recently and am looking foward to improving it as soon as I have a break from work.
Now I just have to steal one of my wifes potting trays to test it.
Thanks
-- John
DonH
home | projects | blog
482 posts in 986 days
#10 posted 735 days ago
Hello Jahness
The airflow does not seem restricted in any way. The 14 inch tray has sufficient space between it and the “collar” that it is mounted to. The square inches of air path is larger than the duct coming in to the machine.
Regards
Don
-- DonH Orleans Ontario
Ken90712
home | projects | blog
12662 posts in 1358 days
#11 posted 735 days ago
Nice work Don I like it!
-- Ken, "Everyday above ground is a good day!"
DonH
home | projects | blog
482 posts in 986 days
#12 posted 735 days ago
Hi Ken – glad you do!!
How is that weather coming? Rain is beginning to let up here and temperature is climbing to 22 degrees Celsius today. May get to the boat soon.
All the best
Don
-- DonH Orleans Ontario
John Stegall
home | projects | blog
355 posts in 1685 days
#13 posted 735 days ago
Rain? What is that? And I love the post about filter/collection improvement. I will soon be setting my old style DC 1100 back up again (no room).
-- jstegall
DonH
home | projects | blog
482 posts in 986 days
#14 posted 735 days ago
Hi John
Good to see you are going to get back into dust collection – that is one tool that must have room found for it.
Don
-- DonH Orleans Ontario
58j35bonanza
home | projects | blog
378 posts in 861 days
#15 posted 735 days ago
I can’t wait to try this on my dust collector.
I have been making a lot of upgrades and I think this will be a big help in keeping my filter clean.
-- Chuck
View all comments »
showing 1 through 15 of 45 comments
Have your say...