| Project by topspin | posted 1142 days ago | 1667 views | 7 times favorited | 15 comments | ![]() |
![]() |
Routed tray made of Walnut and White Oak. Sanded to 200 and finished with mineral oil.
Another LJ posted one of these and made a comment about how much of a pain they are to sand and how wasteful they are of material…. I fully agree on both accounts.
This one was given to a coworker who is a big football fan… sort of looks like a football.
This is based on the Wood magazine article that ran a few months ago.
-- Seems that talent only gets you so far... effort makes you successful.
| Pin It |


























15 comments so far
topspin
home | projects | blog
62 posts in 1588 days
#1 posted 1142 days ago
To any others that make these…. buy your cups before you make your pattern. Every retailer’s are different size (diameter and height) and you’ll need to make adjustments. Also my want to consider the finger holes like I added to make it easier to remove the cups.
-- Seems that talent only gets you so far... effort makes you successful.
NormG
home | projects | blog
2580 posts in 1173 days
#2 posted 1142 days ago
What a great tray. Material loss and sanding aside, great project, great gift
-- Norman
oldskoolmodder
home | projects | blog
761 posts in 1850 days
#3 posted 1142 days ago
At the same time I see the waste of beautiful material, I also fail to “care”, because of the overall quality of the piece. great job!
-- Respect your shop tools and they will respect you - Ric
bigike
home | projects | blog
4023 posts in 1458 days
#4 posted 1142 days ago
great work!
-- Ike, Big Daddies Woodshop, http://www.icombadaniels@yahoo.com
mikethetermite
home | projects | blog
367 posts in 1436 days
#5 posted 1141 days ago
Nice looking tray. Thanks for the tip on the cups.
-- Mike The Termite ~~~~~ Working safely may get old, but so do those who practice it.
woodworm
home | projects | blog
14104 posts in 1760 days
#6 posted 1141 days ago
Very neatly routed tray.
-- masrol, kuala lumpur, MY.
Ken90712
home | projects | blog
12662 posts in 1358 days
#7 posted 1141 days ago
Very nice, I see what you mean on the waste and sanding.
-- Ken, "Everyday above ground is a good day!"
Dave Haynes
home | projects | blog
188 posts in 1523 days
#8 posted 1141 days ago
Very cool!! I know you enjoyed it because I made three of these for Christmas gifts last year and had a tremendous time as well as a ton of fun doing it. The only thing different is that I used hard maple instead of oak for my lighter colored wood. You can read my full article on the project (if interested) on my website at: http://www.oldaveswoodshop.com/Snack%20Tray%20Project.php By the way, the finger holes was an excellent idea! After my girls got their trays, one of them made a comment that it would be easier to get the cups out for refilling if there was a “finger hole”.
-- Dave Haynes, Indiana, http://www.oldaveswoodshop.com
Dave Owen
home | projects | blog
225 posts in 1244 days
#9 posted 1141 days ago
Beautiful job! Several friends have made these, but they all seem to have had trouble getting the router marks out of the inside bottom. Did you use a special bit – or did you just spend a lot more time sanding?
-- Dave O.
Jason
home | projects | blog
629 posts in 1678 days
#10 posted 1141 days ago
Great stuff.
A couple of thoughts/questions I have:
-I like the finger holes you added and assume you could also drill a hole underneath the cup compartment to ease removal of the cups.
-What about gluing up pieces around the edges and where the cups sit to reduce the amount of material “wasted”?
Regardless, I will have to give this a try.
-- Jason - Colorado Springs
topspin
home | projects | blog
62 posts in 1588 days
#11 posted 1141 days ago
Thanks all for the many positive comments.
To DaveOwen – I sanded… a lot to get the internal marks out. I used a bowl sanding pad with the star/wavy sand paper on the drill press to do most of the inside and a sander on the outside. If you’re careful about the routing not to have any tips it’s actually not too bad.
Jason – all good thoughts. I didn’t want a hole all the way through the last layer…so the finger holes. Eventually I’ll figure out how to do this with smaller pieces. Though to an extent I don’t like the way the joints look on the sides…
-- Seems that talent only gets you so far... effort makes you successful.
Dave Owen
home | projects | blog
225 posts in 1244 days
#12 posted 1141 days ago
Thanks for your reply regarding the sanding, Topspin. With a lamination like you used, here’s another thought about the wasted wood. You could rough cut the center out of the top two layers before laminating and use those pieces on a smaller project. That would also significantly reduce the amount of routing.
-- Dave O.
WistysWoodWorkingWonders
home | projects | blog
11517 posts in 1326 days
#13 posted 1139 days ago
great looking tray, seen a few of these pop up on this site, but this is in the top of them all… love the contrast…
-- New Project = New Tool... it's just the way it is, don't fight it... :)
Dennisgrosen
home | projects | blog
10854 posts in 1285 days
#14 posted 1134 days ago
niice tray
and I´m with Dave Owen rough cut the top layers first
Dennis
learnin2do
home | projects | blog
849 posts in 1021 days
#15 posted 1004 days ago
-i don’t understand how it wastes more than other pieces. -i understand the consideration -i hate scooping walnut shavings after ripping it and i want to make all of the dust into filler
-yeah -it is perfectly beautiful -sanding those types of work and rotary carvings can be really grueling and use up materials
-- christine
Have your say...