| Project by Don | posted 2343 days ago | 4595 views | 12 times favorited | 14 comments | ![]() |
![]() |
This small box was quite a challenge. I believe the wood is Douglas Fir, or what is referred to as Oregon in Australia. The dark wood in the lid is Ebony. The complexity is all in the joints. The finish is pure Tung Oil.
For scale, the Aus 50 cent piece is similar in size to a US silver dollar.
CCA = Constructive Criticism Appreciated
-- CanuckDon "I just love small wooden boxes!" http://www.hillsbiblechurch.org/
| Pin It |



























14 comments so far
oscorner
home | projects | blog
4565 posts in 2483 days
#1 posted 2343 days ago
That’s a very interesting miter joint. What possesed you to make this joint? Strength, the look of the joint or the challenge?
-- Jesus is Lord!
Dick, & Barb Cain
home | projects | blog
8681 posts in 2472 days
#2 posted 2343 days ago
An interesting looking joint. Do you use a router for this ? I don’t recall if I’ve ever seen a joint like this.
Do you have a diagram ?
-- -** You are never to old to set another goal or to dream a new dream ****************** Dick, & Barb Cain, Hibbing, MN. http://www.woodcarvingillustrated.com/gallery/member.php?uid=3627&protype=1
Gary
home | projects | blog
819 posts in 2497 days
#3 posted 2343 days ago
That’s really nice; a cool design and interesting joinery.
Do the sides slide together like a half-lap bridle joint?
Merry Christmas,
Gary
-- Gary, Florida. http://www.penturners.org/forum/f70/servicepens-2013-a-98908/
Ethan Sincox
home | projects | blog
764 posts in 2346 days
#4 posted 2343 days ago
Don,
I really like the creative thinking on the use of the interlocking miter joints – and the skill to pull them off with such exacting detail should be noted, as well!
I’m intrigued by your choice of woods. Douglas fir is pretty much on the extreme soft end of the Janka Hardness Table (coming just after most of the pines), while ebony is certianly on the opposite extreme. What criteria do you follow for wood selection? Is it strictly asthetic value? Or is it availability? Or maybe something else?
I find the ebony slightly distracting… I think there is too much competetion for attention between the lid and the joints of the box. After some thought, I don’t even think it is the wood selection (though in a larger piece, you might have some concerns with the wood movement of the douglas fir compared to the wood movement of the ebony). I think it is the way the ebony protrudes above the level of the lid. Maybe if it were more of an inlay, instead, that might turn the ebony into more of the accent I think you were trying to go for?
If you were to go that route, I would further suggest the lines of the inlay somehow mimic or enhance the lines of the box. For example, inlay a square in the lid, where the outer edges of the ebony inlay are lined up with what would be the inner edges of the box. Or expand the lid dimensions slightly and then make it so that the ebony inlay falls exactly on the sides of the box.
-- Ethan, http://thekiltedwoodworker.com
Philip Edwards
home | projects | blog
244 posts in 2612 days
#5 posted 2343 days ago
Wow! Love the box!
Isn’t the joint of Japanese origin? How did you cut it?
Cheers
Phil
Don
home | projects | blog
2592 posts in 2349 days
#6 posted 2343 days ago
Thanks guys. I’ve just posted a blog that should answer your question on this joint. It’s from an article I wrote about the subject for a club newsletter. If after reading that article, you still have questions, just ask and I’ll do my best to answer them.
-- CanuckDon "I just love small wooden boxes!" http://www.hillsbiblechurch.org/
Don
home | projects | blog
2592 posts in 2349 days
#7 posted 2343 days ago
Ethan, I appreciate your observations.
In this case I choose the wood partly on what was available in my supply, and also for the aesthetics.
AS for the design, it’s not mine. It’s based on a Tony Lydgate design. He calls it the Castle Box, but I don’t like that name. I believe the primary design influence is the work of Green & Greene of the ‘arts and crafts’ movement. This style features exposed joinery and dark wood. Post and beam structures also feature prominently.
I take your point about the design, Ethan, but as I am not taking credit for the design, I’ll have to direct your criticisms to Lydgate.
-- CanuckDon "I just love small wooden boxes!" http://www.hillsbiblechurch.org/
scottb
home | projects | blog
3648 posts in 2499 days
#8 posted 2342 days ago
I like the design and I don’t mind the protrusions on the top, and I’ll bet Ethan might as well if the sides were also Quartersawn to match the top (perhaps the top could have been a bit larger, but I wouldn’t know unless I could compare). I think the plainsawn sides/qtr sawn top is distracting… The reverse would have probably worked, if not all qtr sawn though. so as to have fewer competing focal elements – (but don’t paint it) – Just my two cents.
-- I am always doing what I cannot do yet, in order to learn how to do it. - Van Gogh -- http://blanchardcreative.etsy.com -- http://snbcreative.wordpress.com/
Don
home | projects | blog
2592 posts in 2349 days
#9 posted 2342 days ago
Scott, good comment, and I must take responsibility for this. I think you are correct in your observation.
I can’t recall now, but the way I cut the wood may have been a consequence of the available material. Although, I must confess this aspect of the design didn’t enter my mind. It’s something I will need to be conscious of in the future.
-- CanuckDon "I just love small wooden boxes!" http://www.hillsbiblechurch.org/
Shawn
home | projects | blog
225 posts in 2326 days
#10 posted 2326 days ago
you sir, are an ispiration
-- Cheers
Shawn
home | projects | blog
225 posts in 2326 days
#11 posted 2326 days ago
you sir, are an inspiration
-- Cheers
Dan'um Style
home | projects | blog
10811 posts in 2155 days
#12 posted 1930 days ago
another interesting box. very well done.
-- keeping myself entertained
rikkor
home | projects | blog
11296 posts in 2047 days
#13 posted 1930 days ago
This is a great box. It really shows some precise woodworking skill. Thanks for posting it Don. (Gee, you’d think you like small wooden boxes)
SCOTSMAN
home | projects | blog
4312 posts in 1758 days
#14 posted 1675 days ago
Unusual very nice reminds me of some of the japanes joints wood joints that islol.well done thanks for sharing.Alistair
-- excuse my typing as I have a form of parkinsons disease
Have your say...