| Project by Don "Dances with Wood" Butler | posted 266 days ago | 1238 views | 2 times favorited | 26 comments | ![]() |
![]() |
Either Sears, Roebuck & Co. or Montgomery Ward had this piece built in South Bend, IN just after the turn of the 20th century. The page shown in the Sears catalog is from the 1904 edition. I believe this is the Motgomery Ward cabinet.
The cabinet was seriously abused by all the former owners and was heavily coated with nine coats of badly applied paint of various colors. I gather the first finish was a thinly applied, colored varnish over the maple/poplar wood used to make it. The joinery was decently done but no glue or screws were used, not even where dowels were used and the joints at the corners and dado joints were NAILED! Seriously!
Much of the wood was worn out, especially the drawer sides where they slid against the cabinetry. Some parts had to be replaced with carefully copied woodwork.
The original work top was gone. In its place was poplar planks nailed onto the casework and covered with old, oil based linoleum.
Since my wife wanted a French Country theme in the kitchen, and since the woodwork in the cabinet was so dinged and dented, we painted it a buttery yellow with an antique looking blue trim. I added some scrollwork fancies on the sides of the topper because I felt it was too plain.
The ugly work top replacement was tossed out and a beautiful, custom made piece of granite was used instead.
One of the legs was unusable and a new one was made and then new ends were made for all four of them. They were designed to fit plastic low friction slider pads and made wider to spread the, now heavier, weight of the unit.
New die cast, nickle plated hinges were installed on the doors.
Low profile electrical receptacles were installed in the back panel.
It took most of a Summer and Autumn to do the work.
I’m happy with it and, most importantly, She Who Buys Me Tools is pleased.
-- If a man says something in the forest and there's no woman to hear it, is he still wrong?






























26 comments so far
jeh412
home | projects | blog
131 posts in 269 days
posted 266 days ago
Beautiful cabinet! I’ll bet that looks fantastic in your kitchen.
There was a similar cabinet in my parent’s basement when I was growing up, and it hadn’t been terribly abused. Unfortunately, the basement got five feet of water from Hurricane Agnes in the early 1970s and the cabinet just crumbled. The only thing that we salvaged from the basement was a six-foot-long wood chest that had been in my grandparent’s kitchen when my father was growing up. The lids show the wear of children’s butts since dad and his brothers used it as their seats at the table. That chest is now in my dining room.
-- John, co-owner Sawdust 'n Stitches
David_Bethune
home | projects | blog
243 posts in 287 days
posted 266 days ago
That my friend is STUNNING! My wife also likes that type of thing. I’m no letting her see this.:)
WoodSpanker
home | projects | blog
298 posts in 286 days
posted 266 days ago
wow, heck of a restoration! :)
-- Adventure? Heh! Excitement? Heh! A Woodworker craves not these things!
prez
home | projects | blog
111 posts in 305 days
posted 266 days ago
if she’s happy….all LJ’s are happy! :)
-- George..." I love the smell of a workshop in the morning!"
CodyC
home | projects | blog
30 posts in 323 days
posted 266 days ago
Wow, I bet it’s worth more than the $8.95 price in the catalog! Do you have any pictures from before the restoration?
-- Cody Crisp - http://www.ruggedcrosswoodworks.com
clieb91
home | projects | blog
681 posts in 829 days
posted 266 days ago
Very nice restoration.
Welcome to LJs.
CtL
-- Chris L. "Don't Dream it, Be it."
Don "Dances with Wood" Butler
home | projects | blog
279 posts in 289 days
posted 265 days ago
I’m embarassed to admit, I didn’t take any “before” photos.
Boy, do I feel stupid!
d
-- If a man says something in the forest and there's no woman to hear it, is he still wrong?
Woodchuck1957
home | projects | blog
950 posts in 658 days
posted 265 days ago
From the advertisement ad it looks like it was quartersawn oak.
MsDebbieP
home | projects | blog
14156 posts in 1054 days
posted 265 days ago
oh to have this in my kitchen!!!!!
-- ~ Debbie, Canada (http://www.execulink.com/~yohan)
Woodchuck1957
home | projects | blog
950 posts in 658 days
posted 265 days ago
Ms Deb, I’ve got a oak kitchen Hoosier with flour sifter and frosted pattern glass doors. It needs to be refinished, but the good part is that it was never painted. Someday I need to either refinish it or sell it, it’s been sitting in the basement for 20 years. I have another one that is oak and was painted and not quite as nice that I refinished back down to the bare wood, stained, and finished about 15 years ago, that sits in the kitchen now. I guess the reason I never got around to refinishing the other one is I want to do it when I feel comfortable enough to do it without damageing the frosted glass. I have refinished alot of old furniture over the years, so it’s not that refinishing is the problem.
SCOTSMAN
home | projects | blog
2238 posts in 479 days
posted 265 days ago
you have a kitchen Ms Debbie well I wish I had a kitchen my wife cooks out of an old cardboard box.Alistair
-- excuse my typing as I have a form of parkinsons disease
tinnman65
home | projects | blog
243 posts in 308 days
posted 265 days ago
Beautiful work Don, I like the old toaster on the top it fits nicely. Exactly how many tools is a restoration like that worth to the wife?
-- Paul Sayre Creativity is a drug I cannot live without. Cecil B. DeMille (1881 - 1959)
Don "Dances with Wood" Butler
home | projects | blog
279 posts in 289 days
posted 265 days ago
Woodchuck,
I know the illustration in the catalog looks like oak, but the actual unit is maple where it shows and poplar inside and underneath.
Refinishing furniture with glass parts shouldn’t be any different from other refinishing projects. Just remove the glass first. Look carefully in the back of the glass where it’s fastened. Variously you may find clips, moldings or whatever that can be gently removed. In the rare case where the glass was glued in with caulk, it needs to be cautiously sliced with a sharp carton knife. Work slowly and be careful. In the event that the glass breaks, a good glass shop will be able to match it with new stuff.
If you can, take a close up photo of the glass where its fastened in and post it here. I think many of us would be able to give some good advice about removing it.
Paul,
Marge buys me tools all the time. If she bought me another major tool I’d have to sell something to make room for it.
Remember, the Outback has to be garaged EVERY night! ;-)
d
-- If a man says something in the forest and there's no woman to hear it, is he still wrong?
Woodchuck1957
home | projects | blog
950 posts in 658 days
posted 265 days ago
The glass is held in with 1/4” oak molding, nailed. I know it’s probably going to be a slow process, but then again maybe not, I don’t know yet. But I do know that the glass would be fairly expensive to replace, there is a pattern that is etched into the glass, and if I can’t get one panel of glass to match perfectly, color also, then I’m pretty much committed to replaceing all 4 panels.
MsDebbieP
home | projects | blog
14156 posts in 1054 days
posted 265 days ago
Woodchuck.. be still my heart!
I saw a cabinet at an antique store. The wanted $1200 for it.
Scotsman: I count my blessings every day.
This is a cabinet that I do have. It was my parents (when they had only boxes for a kitchen). It’s really “cheap” but it’s family history. It was cut in half at one point and has been in my basement for years. When I started gathering antique items for my kitchen I brought it up from the basement and cleaned it up as best as I could.
If only I had donbee’s skills to rejuvenate it.
-- ~ Debbie, Canada (http://www.execulink.com/~yohan)
Woodchuck1957
home | projects | blog
950 posts in 658 days
posted 265 days ago
Kitchen Hoosiers aren’t cheap, thats for sure.
joey
home | projects | blog
289 posts in 798 days
posted 265 days ago
I have refinished a few these in my career, and you did a great job on this cabinet. most of the one’s I have had the pleasure of working on have been in bad repair much like the one you have. nails holding joints together glue on top of glue, and many coats of paint. rusted flour bins and hardware. but I manage to bring all but one of them back from the edge. the one I didn’t still gets used as a plant stand by my in laws and they love in its present state. Once again, fine job, they are alot of work to restore but well worth the effort.
Joey
-- Joey~~Sabina, Ohio http://sleepydogwoodworking.blogspot.com/
Don "Dances with Wood" Butler
home | projects | blog
279 posts in 289 days
posted 265 days ago
Debbie, Don’t be afraid of it, you can do it!
Take apart what comes apart and reglue or refasten whatever came apart but shouldn’t have.
Then strip or sand the old finish and put on new stuff. It really is as simple as I just said.
Having said that, I do emphasize that making new wood parts may be beyond your skill level, but find someone to partner with for that.
I feel very strongly that this project is very do-able.
Jump in there, Debbie!
Just do it!
Best regards,
Don
-- If a man says something in the forest and there's no woman to hear it, is he still wrong?
MsDebbieP
home | projects | blog
14156 posts in 1054 days
posted 265 days ago
Well thanks for thinking that I can do it….. I’d be so afraid of it all falling apart.
-- ~ Debbie, Canada (http://www.execulink.com/~yohan)
Don "Dances with Wood" Butler
home | projects | blog
279 posts in 289 days
posted 265 days ago
Well, if it all falls apart, believe it or not, THAT’S GOOD!
Howcome?
You will then have the opportunity to put it all back together again with fresh glue. It will be like a new piece, then.
Come on Debbie, don’t let this hunka wood buffalo you!
d
-- If a man says something in the forest and there's no woman to hear it, is he still wrong?
DaveR
home | projects | blog
1517 posts in 614 days
posted 265 days ago
Nice work on that Don. You do good stuff.
-- Until you spread your wings, you'll have no idea how far you can walk.
ND2ELK
home | projects | blog
6174 posts in 668 days
posted 265 days ago
Beautiful job on this piece. Both you and your wife should very pleased the way it came out. Thanks for posting.
God Bless
tom
-- Mc Bridge Cabinets, Iowa
MsDebbieP
home | projects | blog
14156 posts in 1054 days
posted 264 days ago
yah.. well…. when it starts to wobble, I’ll take it apart and fix it up :)
and i’ll be looking you up for tips! :)
-- ~ Debbie, Canada (http://www.execulink.com/~yohan)
janice
home | projects | blog
299 posts in 319 days
posted 264 days ago
I just seen this. Wow. It’s really nice. You did a very impressive job with it.
-- Janice
Don "Dances with Wood" Butler
home | projects | blog
279 posts in 289 days
posted 264 days ago
Thank ya’ thank ya, thank ya verra much.
-- If a man says something in the forest and there's no woman to hear it, is he still wrong?
Mike
home | projects | blog
140 posts in 277 days
posted 257 days ago
That is a project. I got an old Sears Book. I will check and see if one like it in there. I’ll try and find the book that my Dad had tomorrow.
-- Mike, VT