| Project by Moai | posted 279 days ago | 2984 views | 17 times favorited | 25 comments | ![]() |
![]() |
This Traditional workbench was posted before, I left the forum for some time but I’m back!
Built back in 2006 based on the plans of Frank Klauzs (Fine woodworking Magazine #53, July/August 1985). Has some modifications, the solid top is a bit deeper, I opted for this type of front vise instead the shoulder vise on plans(big mistake! this vise deals with a lot of raking)
The top is in Hard Maple, legs and stretchers in soft maple. The front vise hardware and bench dogs from Lie Nielsen, Tail Vise screw and legs bolts from Lee Valley. Tung oil + wax finish. Pictures about all the construction process can be found at http://www.flickr.com/photos/franciscoluna/sets/72157610132682106/
As memberTrifern say, All comments, especially critiques, are welcomed and appreciated.
-- Francisco Luna, San Francisco Bay Area.
































25 comments so far
PurpLev
home | projects | blog
2760 posts in 545 days
posted 279 days ago
thats a master piece! loved the construction process also, helps to see how it is made.
Thanks for sharing!
question – on the breadboard piece near the face vice – it looks like the breadboard is made of 2 laminated parts – one wide, one narrow – whats the reason behind it?
-- When in doubt - There is no doubt - Go the safer route.
CharlieM1958
home | projects | blog
7662 posts in 1115 days
posted 279 days ago
Fantastic piece of woodworking! You wouldn’t actually risk scratching that up by working on it, would you? :-)
-- Charlie M. "Woodworking - patience = firewood"
Moai
home | projects | blog
721 posts in 290 days
posted 279 days ago
Purplev,
I was out of wood to make that block solid, so I took a bunch of pieces of similar wood and made the exterior “skins” in hard maple…take a look on this picture
Charlie, somebody else, somewhere in Santa Rosa CA is scratching it up! I sold the bench last year, I am planning the second one!
-- Francisco Luna, San Francisco Bay Area.
SteveE
home | projects | blog
40 posts in 406 days
posted 279 days ago
[Drooling] What a nice bench [/Drooling]
-- Measure twice, cut once, bang into place
PurpLev
home | projects | blog
2760 posts in 545 days
posted 279 days ago
Thanks Doubthead. I thought that might be the reason, but was curious to know if there was maybe a different one. is the next bench similar in design to this one?
-- When in doubt - There is no doubt - Go the safer route.
8iowa
home | projects | blog
592 posts in 658 days
posted 279 days ago
Doubthead:
It is simply magnificent! Too beautiful to use. I’ve been looking for a bench with this type of tailstock.
-- "Heaven is North of the Bridge"
Bullgoose
home | projects | blog
53 posts in 290 days
posted 279 days ago
I am terribly envious…an absolutely beautiful workbench!!! Great job!
-- When I die I want to go like my grandfather did...peaceful, in his sleep...not screaming like the passengers in his car.
Blake
home | projects | blog
2760 posts in 771 days
posted 279 days ago
Oh I want one Sooooo bad! Really nice job and great photos.
-- Check out my new website! http://www.blakeweberwoodworking.com
Moai
home | projects | blog
721 posts in 290 days
posted 279 days ago
Purplev, definitely not. I had the time to try it, to tested. these are the issues I found:
1. It is too big (84” long, 32” deep). New dimensions, 60” x 24
2. This front vise in particular is a hassle, a lot of racking. this one was made in Germany, sold by Lie nielsen. I’ll go for a twin screw vise.
3. The tail vise, as it’s made totally in wood, tends to move when placed trough forces (my dovetails and junctions were VERY tight). After some use, loss alignment with the rest of the bench.
4. The legs are nice looking, solid, but don’t provide any support or way to hold the work. Chris Schwarz has better options in his book.
Thanks all for the comments!
-- Francisco Luna, San Francisco Bay Area.
PurpLev
home | projects | blog
2760 posts in 545 days
posted 279 days ago
Thanx! , cant wait to see the new beast.
-- When in doubt - There is no doubt - Go the safer route.
DocK16
home | projects | blog
710 posts in 983 days
posted 279 days ago
SWEEEEET. Thanks for posting the pics I have wanted to build one of these for a long time. Gotta check out the FWW site see if the plans are avaliable there.
-- DocK, WV
Todd Thomas
home | projects | blog
4831 posts in 345 days
posted 279 days ago
man that is one fine bench… would hate to mark it up…great job
-- Todd, Oak Ridge, TN, Hello my name is Todd and I'm a Toolholic, I bought my last tool 10 days, no 4 days, oh heck I bought a tool on the way here! †
SteveKorz
home | projects | blog
2030 posts in 610 days
posted 279 days ago
HolySchmolies that’s a nice bench! I would reallllllly like to make one of these someday….
-- As iron sharpens iron, so one man sharpens another. (Proverbs 27:17) †
blackcherry
home | projects | blog
730 posts in 720 days
posted 279 days ago
Thanks for the pro and con on this bench and the vises. With that said the bench is a eye candy gem…thanks for sharing both the bench and review. Blkcherry
WoodSpanker
home | projects | blog
298 posts in 288 days
posted 279 days ago
It certainly is nice looking… sure hope it works as good as it looks for you! I’m certain it will, looks like a fine bench.
-- Adventure? Heh! Excitement? Heh! A Woodworker craves not these things!
kolwdwrkr
home | projects | blog
2249 posts in 487 days
posted 278 days ago
wow, I want one
-- ~ Inspiring those who inspire me ~
Popeye Jr.
home | projects | blog
110 posts in 319 days
posted 278 days ago
That’s one fine piece of work! Great job.
-- People who say it cannot be done should not interup those who are doing it
mjpierson
home | projects | blog
77 posts in 890 days
posted 278 days ago
beauty
-- Mike - Columbus, Ohio
TraumaJacques
home | projects | blog
383 posts in 397 days
posted 278 days ago
sweet so when are you bringing it to my shop? Just kidding well done I wish I had the space….
-- All bleeding will eventually stop.
Beginningwoodworker
home | projects | blog
4197 posts in 569 days
posted 277 days ago
Nice Workbench!
-- CJIII Future cabinetmaker
groland
home | projects | blog
26 posts in 308 days
posted 277 days ago
Hi,
Beautiful bench! Really wonderful work. I have a question. I notice your tail vise seems to be sized so that the narrow end, towards the side vise, will close tightly leaving a gap in that part of the vise that goes across the end. I have observed this in other’s tail vises and wondered why both surfaces don’t close up at the same time. Doesn’t this difference make it hard to place narrow items in the back end of the tail vise?
Appreciate your insights,
George Roland
groland
home | projects | blog
26 posts in 308 days
posted 277 days ago
Hi,
Beautiful bench! Really wonderful work. I have a question. I notice your tail vise seems to be sized so that the narrow end, towards the side vise, will close tightly leaving a gap in that part of the vise that goes across the end. I have observed this in other’s tail vises and wondered why both surfaces don’t close up at the same time. Doesn’t this difference make it hard to place narrow items in the back end of the tail vise?
Appreciate your insights,
George Roland
Moai
home | projects | blog
721 posts in 290 days
posted 277 days ago
Roland,


That’s a good point.
Take a look on this picture:
I think one of the reasons both parts don’t close at the same time is because the movable Jaw was designed a little bit longer to have more chances when working with long pieces on the bench, PLUS you have five Bench-dog slots on the vise. The back of the vise is not really used when holding work.. Also, at the picture you can see there is enough room for the screw length (comercially availables)
-- Francisco Luna, San Francisco Bay Area.
mmh
home | projects | blog
1385 posts in 619 days
posted 272 days ago
Very nice! If I send you the logs will you make me one?
-- "They who dream by day are cognizant of many things which escape those who dream only by night." ~ Edgar Allan Poe
celtmann
home | projects | blog
3 posts in 501 days
posted 171 days ago
Beautiful! Excellent work!
-- I know my machines as well as I know my ten fingers... (well, my 9.3 fingers)