Maybe i’m just being the picky sort. But i believe wood, possessing a directional grain, pretty much demands its dimensions be given in a standardized way. I can’t count the number of times i’ve run into problems with people giving wood dimensions in every way imaginable. Which can very easily manifest itself as a crap load of 14” long x 29” deep cabinet ends for a job having the wrong grain direction.
I was personally always taught that it should be expressed as thickness x width x length. Yea i know. On the other side of the pond they believe it should be the exact opposite. Kind of like the way they choose to express the day, month and year when giving a calendar date.
I hereby resolve that no expression of dimensions is inherently superior to any other. Perhaps whats needed is an international coin toss to decide once and for all a standard that will be recognised across the planet. I’ll even vote for lumberjock Stewart from Yorkshire be allowed to flip the coin!
-- miles125, Alabama.."Architecture is frozen music""






















13 comments so far
Thos. Angle
home | projects | blog
4015 posts in 841 days
posted 334 days ago
OK,LOL
-- Thos. Angle
Peter O
home | projects | blog
1005 posts in 753 days
posted 334 days ago
It would be great if everyone could agree on a format for dims, but I don’t know if it’s going to happen. What if we all agreed to label our dims with a descriptive letter? w=width, l=length, h=height, d=depth, t=thickness. I find that these are really helpful to me when I forget what order I took measurements.
-- http://www.north40custom.com -- http://north40studios.etsy.com --
Russel
home | projects | blog
2033 posts in 818 days
posted 334 days ago
I agree with Peter. Remember the correct order is difficult. I’m still having trouble with the order of my kids.
-- When you give someone a chance it may well be their last.
rikkor
home | projects | blog
11338 posts in 753 days
posted 334 days ago
So would a 2×4 be a 4×2 if used on edge?
mmh
home | projects | blog
1366 posts in 601 days
posted 334 days ago
Thanks for the lesson as I’ve wondered what was proper. Being an untrained newbie, I always use the (T), (W), (L) with measurements just to make things more precise and understood since my memory has a deficit. I’ll try to keep that one in my head.
-- "They who dream by day are cognizant of many things which escape those who dream only by night." ~ Edgar Allan Poe
miles125
home | projects | blog
1414 posts in 884 days
posted 334 days ago
Rikkor, i would say in solid wood the smallest side would always be considered the thickness and noted first. As in 4 3/4” thick x 5” wide. The real problem of all this isn’t really noticable until you get to sheet goods with a grain direction.
Take the example of an adjustable shelf going in a cabinet where its deeper than it is long and you want to apply a nosing to the front edge. A 12” x 25” shelf is not the same thing as a 25” x 12” shelf, and it gives you a false indication of which edge is to be nosed regarldless of the graining problem.
-- miles125, Alabama.."Architecture is frozen music""
TimberMan
home | projects | blog
106 posts in 343 days
posted 334 days ago
I’d agree with the letter. I personally don’t care what order they are in just put a letter indicating what each stands for and everyone can figure it out.
Rogue
home | projects | blog
87 posts in 349 days
posted 334 days ago
It seems like the standard is to have no standard. Any real woodworker I know experesses their measurement in the same way you do. But that’s the “real” problem. In my small area I can count on both hands the number of real woodworkers. The rest are “wanna bees”, “neverwas” or my favorite “doneven tries”. Working in a commercial cabinet shop is like spending your days in a game of twenty question with people who know what they want but have no idea the proper way to ask for it. Even guys who work in the shop can be like little baby balling for their bottle because they don’t know how to say I’m hungry.
-- Rogue
Dusty56
home | projects | blog
3401 posts in 567 days
posted 334 days ago
how deep is the water ? how deep are your counter tops / cabinets ? How wide is your sideboard ? how long is your kitchen table ? There must be a book out there somewhere that lists all of the standard terms that we use and from what angle things are viewed from . L O L…this is a great subject , Miles ! : )
-- You know you're getting old when you know the difference between you're (you are) and your (belonging to you) AND how to use them in a sentence .
Grumpy
home | projects | blog
14852 posts in 730 days
posted 334 days ago
Good luck Miles. But I don’t like your chances. LOL
-- Grumpy - "Always look on the bright side of life"- Monty Python
jockmike2
home | projects | blog
7222 posts in 1125 days
posted 333 days ago
When I worked construction Miles, I was working with a newbie and he was shouting measurements to me. One and only once, he called out” 4 and four little marks”. I said are they the real little marks or the inbetween marks, he looked real hard and said, no, the’re the real little marks. I went to the boss and told him to get rid of the guy, or at least move him he was no help to me. It could have been 4 1/8 or 4 1/2 . I told him what happened, the boss asked me if he could shovel, I said that is something he might be able to do.
-- Mike. mwurm13@yahoo.com
MsDebbieP
home | projects | blog
14096 posts in 1039 days
posted 319 days ago
I guess I’m back to being the shop-sweep. I measure by the “little marks” method, unless of course I have the measuring tape that labels the little marks :0
I agree with the confusion – with measuring and with dates (I’d love it if people stopped doing the /08/12/08 method for the dates , let’s just call it like it is! Dec. 8, 2008 or Aug. 12, 2008.) and for measuring remembering that you may not be talking to a professional, the L W H T letters are really helpful (even though I have to admit I would have been scratching my head at the “T” part) :)
Good discussion
-- ~ Debbie, Canada (http://www.execulink.com/~yohan)
spanky46
home | projects | blog
735 posts in 269 days
posted 230 days ago
I was in the packaging business for twenty years and it was always length, width, and depth!
-- spanky46 -- Never enough clamps...Never enough tools...Never enough time.