I sketched up a couple designs in my notebook, this was another one I did that I liked. I’d make it out of ash. What do you guys think? Would this be good enough to submit for the bookscase contest?
-- Chuck [Elgin, IL]

| Blog entry by chazmonro | posted 197 days ago | 166 reads | 0 times favorited | 6 comments | ![]() |
I sketched up a couple designs in my notebook, this was another one I did that I liked. I’d make it out of ash. What do you guys think? Would this be good enough to submit for the bookscase contest?
-- Chuck [Elgin, IL]
Your Online Shop - Your Support Is Greatly Appreciated - Your Woodworking Showcase - 3 Ways To Help, Financially - Your Woodworking Community
DISCLAIMER: All views and comments posted by members are not necessarily those of LumberJocks.com or of those working on the site.
| Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics
|
Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics
|
6 comments so far
DAN
home | projects | blog
3218 posts in 469 days
posted 197 days ago
nice design. try it in sketchup in 3d
-- ..... art for lifes sake ... danwalters@lumberjocks.com
rikkor
home | projects | blog
7687 posts in 360 days
posted 197 days ago
Go for it!
-- Maplewood, MN
MsDebbieP
home | projects | blog
11928 posts in 646 days
posted 197 days ago
I agree…. Sketchup it.
-- "Functional WoodArt" by Debbie, Canada (http://www.execulink.com/~yohan)
chazmonro
home | projects | blog
37 posts in 358 days
posted 196 days ago
Don’ t you guys think its a bit simple? I mean I don’t think the pages of popular woodworking would build something so simple. Any ideas to maybe dress it up a bit?
-- Chuck [Elgin, IL]
Gary
home | projects | blog
325 posts in 810 days
posted 196 days ago
Don’t take this as being critical. My thought is it’s not so simple, and here’s why:
A bookcase has to be functional. It’s not a display case—it’s for books. Books are heavy.
You’ve designed a suspension bridge. How will you carry the load without having the shelves sag?
I’m not knocking your design. For this to work, you need to consider the weight and determine if you can manage the joinery so it’ll stand the test of time without sagging or failing.
In an online article here Simon Watts wrote:
” ...As a rough guide, figure that 15 average-size books take up 1 foot of shelf. Keep in mind that paperback books weigh about 7 1/2 pounds per linear foot, hardcover books 13 pounds, magazines 26 pounds and reference works as much as 34 pounds per linear foot. ...”
The sag he refers to in the article is for wood supported on both ends.
Go forth and do good work, and good luck with your bookcase. I’m looking forward to seeing your solution.
Cheers,
Gary
chazmonro
home | projects | blog
37 posts in 358 days
posted 196 days ago
Gary, thats the reason I posted this here, It was just a sketch that I threw together an illustration of really quick, I haven’t even begun to think about construction or how it would work. Do you have any suggestions?
Chuck
-- Chuck [Elgin, IL]