LumberJocks

Making a Small Wooden Box #6: Confessions of a Box Maker

Blog entry by Don posted 391 days ago 907 reads 0 times favorited 14 comments Add to Favorites
« Part 5: More Detail Part 6 of Making a Small Wooden Box series Part 7: The Fiddly Bits »

Quote Bwillie:Looking at these dividers reminds me that I always struggle here to get the dimensions spot on. Especially since I use felt on the ends that touch the sides of the box, I have to account for those. Usually on every box on some portion of the dividers I compound an error, and before I know it, I’m all out of whack.

When I read this comment in my last episode in this series, it caused me pause. What Bill was describing was exactly my experience; small errors compounding each other until the divider grid was nowhere near perfect. I don’t know if Bill could observe these errors or just being honest about his own experience.

However, as I hold him in high esteem as a box maker, I decided to re-make my divider grid. And to be honest about this second attempt, it was no more successful. There it was again, not quite perfect, joints that didn’t quite fit, and segments that were out of square. Now I’m not talking about large errors, in fact they were so small, I couldn’t photograph them for this blog – when I tried, they didn’t show.

Some of my best wood working is done in bed. I normally fall asleep at night thinking about my current project. Often I rehearse in my mind the steps I need to take next in a project. That’s when it occurred to me. It I cut all of the half-lap dadoes at the same time with each like piece ganged up against the next, make one pass over the dado blade, move to the next cut, (ie. notch), then each would have to line up with the next. So that’s exactly what I did and it worked.

Below I have lined up all of the component parts for the lower dividers to test for fit and accuracy.

I still found it easy to make a mistake during assembly, because, although each piece in theory was the same end for end, I found in practice this wasn’t quite the case. A discrepancy of .025mm is enough to throw things out and that is the kind of mismatch I’m talking about when you flip a piece end for end – not much, but enough to spoil a good fit.

To avoid this, I drew arrows and made notes on the bottom of each piece. I needed to be certain that the advantage gained by cutting all of the dadoes together wasn’t lost by inadvertently swapping one piece end for end.

Close-up showing markings to avoid confusion.

The fit is so exact and snug, I only glued up the perimeter pieces.

Here’s the third and final attempt. If I do say so myself, it’s a perfect fit, and absolutely square at all intersections of the dividers.

-- CanuckDon "I just love small wooden boxes!" http://www.canterburybaptist.org/

View Don's profile

Don

2586 posts in 658 days


Entry tags/keywords

View Blog Archive
Subscribe to blog entries (RSS)


By subscribing to the RSS feed you will be notified when new entries are posted on this blog.

Recent Entries


14 comments so far

View Tony's profile

Tony

567 posts in 512 days


posted 391 days ago

I did not think it would be so difficult to make a divider, but I guess when you are looking at 0.025mm (1 thou) accuracy, I do not think I can measure less tha 0.01mm on my vernier. you certainly are a perfectionist.

By the way love the work on your web sites – Keep it up

-- Tony - All things are possible, just some things are more difficult than others! - SKYPE: Heron2005 (http://www.poydatjatuolit.fi)

View mot's profile

mot

4837 posts in 518 days


posted 391 days ago

Anything worth doing is worth doing right, eh Bob? This is one of the reasons I haven’t tackled the small box a whole lot. My desire for detail exceeds my skill at attaining it. Nice blog entry!

-- You can discover more about a person in an hour of play than in a year of conversation. (Plato)

View Lee A. Jesberger's profile

Lee A. Jesberger

2750 posts in 461 days


posted 391 days ago

Don;

With guy’s like you running around loose, working to that kind of tolerence. I might have to go back to the plumbing business, where they only have two rules.

Nice work and photo’s!

Lee

-- by Lee A. Jesberger http://www.prowoodworkingtips.com http://www.ezee-feed.com

View MsDebbieP's profile

MsDebbieP

11909 posts in 642 days


posted 391 days ago

well done!! Great determination.

Tom, I love that quote – here is the second part: anything that is worth doing, it is worth doing wrong. (For those people who don’t try because they know they won’t get it right.

-- "Functional WoodArt" by Debbie, Canada (http://www.execulink.com/~yohan)

View Thos. Angle's profile

Thos. Angle

3236 posts in 444 days


posted 391 days ago

Don,
That’s pretty tight tolerances. I guess that’s why you’re the “Box Master”. Good blog by the way. We are learning a lot.
Lee,
You forgot rule #3 in plumbing; payday’s on Friday.

-- Thos. Angle, Owyhee Design, Oregon

View snowdog's profile

snowdog

627 posts in 464 days


posted 391 days ago

“My desire for detail exceeds my skill at attaining it” Mott – that is a keeper

I know what you mean Don, most of my problem solving (at least the problems that I can not solve off the top of my head ) is done in bed before sleep. There is a lot of science to back that idea up but I wont drone on with the details since it has to do with rats and mazes <laugh>.

-- "so much to learn and so little time"..

View Obi's profile

Obi

2152 posts in 718 days


posted 391 days ago

First of all, if it was easy, anybody could do it.
Secondly, I make all the mistakes I possibly can on the first one so I can hopefully not make them anymore.

When I first started making these magazine tables, the original was a wreck. ( I recently sold it for $50.00 to someone who wanted one, but didn’t want to pay the full price.) And I learned that by sanding the rough spots out of the legs I clamped the four legs together. I used the bench mounted belt/disc sander and found a new mistake. A little out of level and the legs got smaller and ended up looking bow-legged. Since I found out by individually sanding them to the point of “Fine Furniture”, they were niether bow-legged nor perfectly the same but the differences were so minute they couldn’t be seen. And when the craftsman can’t see the differences, then chances are niether can anyone else.

-- http://ye-olde-cabinet-shoppe.com/

View gbvinc's profile

gbvinc

362 posts in 428 days


posted 391 days ago

Nice series! I am learning a bunch. Keep them coming.

View Chip's profile

Chip

1058 posts in 574 days


posted 391 days ago

Don, I’m in the process of finishing up the carcasses of a couple of new boxes and begining the insides. I was wondering what your thoughts were on the thickness of the wood you use for the compartments. I was thinking of making them a bit thin and more refined but notice you keep yours fairly thick. Is this because experience has taught you they will hold up better of just a personal preference? I can understand it on the trays but was just curious about the permanently set components.

Thanks for any feedback you may have and, as always, your work is terrific.

-- Better to say nothing and be thought the fool... then to speak and erase all doubt.

View cajunpen's profile

cajunpen

5348 posts in 547 days


posted 391 days ago

Thanks Don for sharing your wisdom. I suspect that I’m not the only woodworker here that has improved their craft because of your work and wisdom.

-- Bill - "Suit yourself and let the rest be pleased." http://www.cajunpen.com/

View Bwillie's profile

Bwillie

103 posts in 587 days


posted 390 days ago

Ah Don…from eyes so far away,

not the smallest of details go unoticed.

Yet to the Masters hands and eye to detail

my friend from down under, has had a good day!

This is a great and inspiring work at the bench that we all can learn from. I love seeing how you progress through the steps, and your thoughts on how to take each one. I promised not step through showing my wifes J-Chest, but I’m almost finished and will post the pictures when done. Keep the chin up, and next time you lay down to sleep…just sleep, you work too hard and are tiring me out :-).

Your friend

-- ICN, Bill, (http://www.beavercreekfitness.com)

View Don's profile

Don

2586 posts in 658 days


posted 390 days ago

Chip, you are correct, the dividers for this box are minutely over 1/4” thick. They do look a little on the heavy side, and perhaps I should have gone with something closer to 1/8” stock. I settled on this size because that is the narrowest dado cut I can get from my dado set using both outside blades with no chippers in between them. Remember, in a half lap joint, it’s this cut that determines the stock thickness.

My other choice would be a single blade curf cut but that just seemed too thin to me. I could also have cut the dados for the half lap joints on my router table, but again, the smallest router bit I have is a 1/4” router.

Also, the design of the lower dividers is such that the front and back rail support the upper trays. You will see that these two components of the lower dividers are higher than the others. To have made these narrower than 1/4” would provide very little surface on which the trays would sit, although I suppose I could have left these two parts at 1/4” and the rest at 1/8”.

Just thinking out loud here, but it gives you an insight into how I approached this project.

-- CanuckDon "I just love small wooden boxes!" http://www.canterburybaptist.org/

View Bwillie's profile

Bwillie

103 posts in 587 days


posted 390 days ago

Master’s hands (Don’s)

-- ICN, Bill, (http://www.beavercreekfitness.com)

View Chip's profile

Chip

1058 posts in 574 days


posted 390 days ago

That makes very good sense to me Don. Appreciate the reply.

-- Better to say nothing and be thought the fool... then to speak and erase all doubt.

You must be signed in to post the comments.

Your Online Shop - Your Support Is Greatly Appreciated - Your Woodworking Showcase - 3 Ways To Help, Financially - Your Woodworking Community

Woodworking StoreApparel StoreMake a Donation
Bookmark And Share This Page
  • View all advertisers
  • Advertise with us

DISCLAIMER: All views and comments posted by members are not necessarily those of LumberJocks.com or of those working on the site.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

GardenTenders.com :: gardening showcase