LumberJocks Woodworking Forum banner

Project Information

I saw the idea of converting the standard Harbor Freight Dust Collector with a separator and Thien Baffle on a mobile cart here on LJ's. I want to first begin by thanking Cory and Bert for sharing their ideas and creativity here. These two projects inspired me to make my own version.

Cory http://lumberjocks.com/projects/29578
b2rtch http://lumberjocks.com/topics/46668

I used this DC as it came out of the box for a couple months before I decided to make the changes. The original mobile base worked great but added to the height of the collector. My basement workshop has low headroom and the ability to wheel it around was limited with obstructions like lighting, pipes, and duct work. Even though I'm a weekend warrior woodworker, I found the collection bag filled quickly and was cumbersome to remove and put back on. But, overall I thought this dust collector was a definite improvement over using my shop vacuum set up that I've been accustomed to and sick of dealing with for so long.

One of the priorities in a design change was to have a mobile base that would keep the DC low to the floor. So, where could I go wrong if I used a Harbor Freight Mobile Base for my Harbor Freight Dust Collector? I wanted a separator with a Thien Baffle to the capture the chips and keep most from entering the collector bag. I also wanted to upgrade the 5 micron bag to a Wynn Cartridge Filter to reduce dust in the air and my lungs, and have an added bonus of lowering the height of the collector.

And now after a couple more months of use, but this time with the upgrades, I am quite pleased and think this was worth the money and time. This mobile DC will probably remain parked in a corner of my workshop for most of its use, but steers around pretty good clearing all the obstructions as I move it around when I need it to. The motor and impeller housing support post assembly is very solid. The trash can separator with Thien Baffle performs great. Having the remote is just plain convenient. The Wynn Filter Cartridge improved air quality for the health of the workshop and myself.

I did a run of 4" S&D pipe 15 feet long to reach my table saw. But for the other tools, they are on mobile bases as well and I can maneuver them from against the wall to out in the middle of floor and close to the DC. For all that I purchased Rockler Dust Right Fittings for the tools and a long enough Dust Right Hose to reach them. I thought I'd might buy the Dust Right Storage Rack and Floor Sweep Kit but had sticker shock when I seen the amount they added to the bill with all the Dust Right Fittings and Hose. I came up with a cheap alternative using PVC and a hose spring clip to contain the Dust Right Hose and all that is explained in detail in a photo below. And the other cheap alternative that works great is the floor sweep I made up from the wands and floor nozzle I saved from a burned out shop vacuum. I took a 2-1/2" to 4" Dust Right Fitting and fitted to the end of the wand and used a hose spring clip to contain it on the cart. You can see that in the project post photos.

I took the provided dimensions of Cory's and Bert's mobile carts, the ideas I had, and winged it from there. Pretty straight forward build with everything mechanically fastened with a combination of simple joinery, glue, lag screws, carriage bolts, hex bolts, and screws. I didn't prep the lumber much at all. At the big box store I sorted through all the crooked until I found nice straight pieces. I did however apply a finish of a home brew wipe on poly.

The picture below shows the cart without the separator, hose, and floor sweep for clarity. That short piece of PVC and hose spring clip works great to contain the Dust Right Hose when not in use. I cut a wooden disc that is the same diameter as the inside of a repair coupling and screwed to the plywood, and then the repair coupling is screwed to the disc. The PVC fits into the coupling and is topped with a knockout cap to keep dust and debris from falling down inside. The Long Range Switch mounted nicely between the 4×4's with the supplied hardware. The power cord for the Harbor Freight DC tucks away in behind the motor bracket while the Long Range Switch power cord has a cord wrap for when I move the cart around.



The picture below shows the Peak Post Anchors. I painted them black. They are mounted to the 4×4's with supplied hardware and that assembly is secured to the double layer of ¾" plywood with carriage bolts. Also, you can see how I attached the double layer of ¾" plywood to the mobile base. I drilled holes in the metal corners of the mobile base with corresponding holes in the plywood and fastened with hex bolts. You may notice that the post anchors are mounted off center from the cart. This was done to allow room for the 4" Dust Right Hose and the PVC to support it.



The picture below shows how the DC motor bracket is mounted to the 4×4 posts. There's spacers between the 4×4's and the motor mounting bracket. The spacers are 2×4's planed down to 1-3/8" to align the center of the impeller inlet with the center of the garbage can lid inlet. The spacers are lagged into the 4×4's. The machine thread to wood thread dowels go through the spacers directly into the 4×4's. Short lag bolts hold the impeller housing brackets to the spacer.



In the picture below shows the riser for the collection bag, donut ring, and Wynn Cartridge Filter. Because I wanted a good amount of clearance for the garbage can separator I needed this riser to raise everything 3-1/4". The riser is made from 1×4's with mitered corners. Screw cleats fasten the riser to the cart from the inside and screw cleats fasten the single layer of AC plywood from the outside. Lags were used to fasten the legs.



31 Gallon Trash Can Separator With Thien Baffle

Along with the information I gathered from Cory's and Bert's projects, I also found everything I needed to make my version here.

http://www.jpthien.com/

This separator with the Thien Baffle performs great and is super easy to access and empty compared to the collection bag. I've emptied the trash can a handful of times in the couple months since making the upgrades. With only about a couple cup fulls of dust in the collection bag, I don't expect to empty it any time soon. I seen performance gains with the new motor and impeller configuration and using the Wynn Cartridge Filter, but most of that was lost when I added the separator. With no way to measure this accurately, I will play it safe and say the collector performance gains and loses factored together is about a wash. From what I've read, my situation is par with others who did the same type of upgrade.

In the two photos below you can see what I did to get started. After cutting 4" holes the integrity of the garbage can lid weakened, so I beefed it up with a MDF insert. The insert fits the contour and recessed nicely in the lid. The insert is fastened to the lid with Quick Grab adhesive and pan head screws. While it adds a little weight, it is really ridged and provided a flat surface to mount the elbow and Thien Baffle.





I didn't want a sharp bend in the Dust Right Hose as seen with Cory's and Bert's versions. In the photo below shows that I chose to build the separator with 2 opposing elbows. I used a street elbow down inside the can. The "shoulder" of the street elbow rests in a bead of silicone on the MDF insert as it passes through the opening. The elbow on top is a standard elbow that I scribed and cut to fit the contour of the lid. I secured it with a pan head screw and ran a bead of silicon sealing it to the lid.



The 5" to 4" reducer didn't extend into the center area of the baffle far enough. I read on the Thien website that this inlet needs to extend into the baffle area by a ratio of ½ the diameter of the elbow. The photo below shows I extended this to two inches using a 4" long piece of S&D pipe. I first fit the reducer into the opening in the garbage can lid and tacked it into place with hot melt glue. I then put a bead of silicon on the rim on one end of the S&D, flipped the garbage can lid over to fit the S&D through the opening in the MDF insert and into the reducer to adhere the two together. And finally, I ran a bead of silicon to seal the S&D to the MDF insert and the reducer to the garbage can lid.

The Thien Baffle secures to the MDF insert with ½" dowels. The dowels connect into holes in the insert and baffle with glue. Before I just grabbed a drill and drilled the holes with a ½" bit I found that the dowel from the big box store was slightly undersized. I drilled a test hole on scrap with a 15/32nd drill bit and it was a perfect size for a tight fit. The large diameter of the baffle begins just behind the end of the street elbow. There is about 1" clearance in between the bottom of the street elbow and the baffle so chips can pass underneath without issue.



In the picture below, going left to right, shows the connection of the Dust Right Hose to the separator. First is a Dust Right Swivel connected to a 3" DWV to 4" S&D adapter. Connecting the adapter to the elbow is a piece of S&D pipe cut 4" long. The fittings are secured with screws and a hose clamp. The 5" hose that connects to the impeller is a piece I cut from the hose that came with the Harbor Freight collector. I swapped out the hose clamps that came with the collector with better ones.



In the photo below is all the fitting I needed to put this all together.



Materials List
Harbor Freight Dust Collector
http://www.harborfreight.com/2-hp-industrial-5-micron-dust-collector-97869.html

Harbor Freight Mobile Base
http://www.harborfreight.com/300-lb-capacity-mobile-base-95288.html

Lumber listed below is rough size unless noted in parenthesis
1-4' x 8' sheet 3/4" AC Plywood (mobile cart platform and riser)
2-2×2 x 6' SPF stud grade (planed to 1-1/4" x 1-1/4" for Harbor Freight Mobile Base)
1-1×4 x 8' SPF #2 and better (ripped to 3-1/4" for riser)
2-3/4×3/4×8' scrap bin material (screw cleats for riser)
2- 4×4 x 5' SPF #2 and better (DC motor and impeller housing support post assembly)
2-2×4 x 16" SPF stud grade (spacer planed down to 1-3/8" for DC motor and impeller housing support post assembly)
1-2×6 x 2' SPF stud grade (also a 1/2"x 5-1/2" x 1' scrap material as a spacer for the DC motor and impeller housing support post assembly)
1-1×3 x 16" pine from scrap bin (for cord wrap)
2- Peak Post Anchors (DC motor and impeller housing support post assembly)
http://www.menards.com/main/building-materials/fencing/all-fencing-products/4x4-plastic-post-anchor/p-1380343-c-13961.htm
1-3" x2' PVC (restraint for 4" Rockler Dust Right Collection Hose - cut to 16" long)
1-3" PVC Repair Coupling and a scrap piece of wood cut into a disc (restraint for 4" Rockler Dust Right Collection Hose)
1-3"' PVC Knockout Test Cap (restraint for 4" Rockler Dust Right Collection Hose)
2-4" Dust Collection Hose Spring Clip (restraint for 4" Rockler Dust Right Collection Hose and Floor Sweep)
http://www.ptreeusa.com/dusthose.htm
Shop vacuum wands (2) and floor nozzle (1)
PSI 110 Volt Long Range Dust Collector Switch With Remote
http://www.amazon.com/PSI-Woodworking-LR110-3-110-Volt-Collector/dp/B00004S9AI/ref=pd_cp_hi_0
Wynn 35A274BLOL 80/20 Blend Cartridge Filter
http://wynnenv.com/woodworking-filters/
3/4", 1-1/4", 2" and 2-1/2" drywall screws (DC Mobile Cart)
5/16" x 1", 2-1/2", 3-1/2", and 4-1/2" lags with washers (DC Mobile Cart)
1/4" x 2-1/2" carriage bolts washers and nuts (DC Mobile Cart)
5/16" x 2-1/2" hex bolts washers and nuts (DC Mobile Cart)
4" machine thread to wood thread dowels with washers and nuts (DC Mobile Cart)

Behrens 31 Gallon Galvanized Trash Can
4" Rockler Dust Right Collection Hose - 3' Compressed Expands to 21'
http://www.rockler.com/dust-rightreg-expandable-hose-expandable-hose
4" Rockler Dust Right Multi Port Quick Release Kit
http://www.rockler.com/dust-right-multi-port-quick-release-starter-kit
4" Rockler Dust Right Swivel
http://www.rockler.com/dust-right-4-swivel
1/2"x 2'x4' MDF (Separator and Thien Baffle)
1/4" x 2' x 2' hardboard (Separator and Thien Baffle)
1/2" x 2' poplar dowel rod (Separator and Thien Baffle)
2- pieces of 4" S&D pipe 4" long (Separator and Thien Baffle)
1- 3" PVC DWV to 4" S&D adapter (Separator and Thien Baffle)
1- 4" S&D standard elbow (Separator and Thien Baffle)
1- 4" S&D street elbow (Separator and Thien Baffle)
1- 5" to 4" dust collection hose reducer (Separator and Thien Baffle)
http://www.grizzly.com/products/W1037

1-5" dust hose (cut off from hose the came with the HF dust collector) (Separator and Thien Baffle)
2- 5" hose clamps (Separator and Thien Baffle)
http://www.grizzly.com/products/5-Wire-Hose-Clamp/W1318
3/8" and 1/2" pan head screws (Separator and Thien Baffle)
Clear Silicon (Separator and Thien Baffle)
Quick Grab Adhesive (Separator and Thien Baffle)
Hot Melt Glue (Separator and Thien Baffle)

Gallery

Comments

· Registered
Joined
·
1,675 Posts
Thanks Randy The payback was great with all the changes I did here. Glad to be of help !
 

· Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
As others have said, this is a great set up, and a very helpful write up!! I just picked up the HF DC last weekend, and have been looking for effective mods. Many thanks for the details!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,584 Posts
I will have to add that this will be on my to do list.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
55 Posts
Thank you.
Following.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,054 Posts
The Cadillac of dust collection ! Crisp and clean..very well done : )
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,243 Posts
Great job & wonderful instruction info.
Thank you for taking the time to share all of this.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
Wow that looks really slick!! I have had one of these for a few years now and really need to do the upgrades. How do you like the HF base? It looks really nice , i was wondering how the casters lock, and if its put together well. I was thinking of using somthing like this for my jointer, its a really heavy PM 50 and i wonder if it would be rugged enough for it. Thanks again for all your documentation, its blogs like these that are so cool because it gives you so many ideas. Thanks again!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,675 Posts
kooldecker….Thanks for the compliment !.....I think those HF mobile bases are a great bang for the buck. With those 20% coupons they are about $32.00. The castors don't lock but are elevated by the knobs to the left and to the right of the castors. In an elevated position, the base stays steady and doesn't move under normal circumstances. They are rated for 300 lbs. They are build solid. It comes with everything except the 2×2's. Those get planed down to 1-1/4" to fit into the channels.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,675 Posts
Everyone ...again thanks for all the compliments and adding this to your favorites !...
 

· Registered
Joined
·
457 Posts
Awesome work. I'm going to use some of your ideas to improve my original design. I would like to have more room for the can under the motor. I also want to get a 90* elbow coming out of the can. Again, great job.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,675 Posts
Cory....it was your work that inspired me as I stated in the introduction….Thank You for sharing this !

I saw the idea of converting the standard Harbor Freight Dust Collector with a separator and Thien Baffle on a mobile cart here on LJ's. I want to first begin by thanking Cory and Bert for sharing their ideas and creativity here. These two projects inspired me to make my own version.

Cory http://lumberjocks.com/projects/29578
b2rtch http://lumberjocks.com/topics/46668
 

· Registered
Joined
·
7,502 Posts
Yes, outstanding doesn't even cover it. Very fine job and picture blog/how to. I'll be doing something similar to this hopefully within this year. My only difference is, I have an O'Neida cyclone to add to the works. I still need to get that Wynn filter. Thnx for your very informative post. I'll bet that really sucks… :)
 

· Registered
Joined
·
69 Posts
Dear KDC,
You are making everything you do of such fine quality and are to be praised for this.
I have struggled for a while with the dust that still comes thru pleated filters and bags of various materials.
After building a Thein seperator on a 44 gal drum I found that there was barely a third of a cup of dust getting thru to the plastic bag below the filter, and this was after filling the 44 gal drum with thicknesser shavings and tablesaw dust.
THE ANSWER--Save space and dump the filters. Just send the exhaust air straight outside thru the workshop wall and down into the garden without any filtration.
This theoretically will reduce the air resistance offered by the filters and hence increase the air speed thru the Thein seperator making it work better.
I have also mounted the fan on 4 rubber engine mounts and reduced the noise level by probably 50%.
Now I have room for more shelves of tools where the filters used to be.
Cheers from Hobart , Tasmania
Ron
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,675 Posts
Roger...your compliments are always appreciated….thank you !

ronniebo... thank you for the compliment, very much appreciated !
 

· Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
Ronniebo I have struggled with this concept myself. I am going to do a mod to mine like cory did here,, I thought about sending my exhaust out the wall. but I keep coming up with the fact that I would have to open a vent somewhere to have a draw. if not I would think that it would become bound pulling a serious vacuum in my shop. I do heat it and A/C it when I need to , so I don't want to lose that air. anybody have any thoughts?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,675 Posts
kooldecker.....my thoughts is much like yours. My basement workshop is conditioned space and having the DC exhaust to outdoors could impact the heating and cooling. Also, another concern with exhausting the DC outdoors in my basement workshop is the gas furnace and water heater. There's a potential of pulling carbon monoxide away from the flues and into the shop….

These are the reasons plus I wanted my DC to be mobile and that's why I built this the way I did

Post #35…....I am going to do a mod to mine like cory did here,, ….....

Here's a link for Cory's project…..Good luck with your conversion

http://lumberjocks.com/projects/29578
 

· Registered
Joined
·
69 Posts
I appreciate your concerns and they are real.
I can only say that I have solved those AC problems by living in Sunny Hobart Tasmania where the climate is perfect one day and ideal the next.
Don`t tell anyone else tho or everyone will crowd me out.
Good luck with the dust.
Ron Booth
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,567 Posts
Sweet project, I love your detail on it. Very fine job!! One to be proud of!!...........................Jim
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,675 Posts
Thanks Jim ! I appreciate the compliment !!
 
Top