LumberJocks

Handplane Performance Tuning #5: Schwarz On Honing - Guides vs Freehand

  • Advertise with us
Blog entry by OSU55 posted 109 days ago 984 reads 0 times favorited 8 comments Add to Favorites Watch
« Part 4: Frog / Lever Cap Part 5 of Handplane Performance Tuning series no next part

The Church of ‘Leave me Alone, Please’

By: Christopher Schwarz | May 1, 2014

During the last 17 years that I have been using a honing guide to sharpen, I’ve been approached (sometimes nearly assaulted) by people who want to teach me to sharpen freehand.

My response: “I sharpen freehand all the time.”

They don’t believe me, and so they spend an hour or so to show me how they hone their edges. Then they want me to try their technique and say: “That’s fantastic! I’m throwing away my guide.”

So far, that hasn’t happened.

Some backstory: When I first learned to sharpen in 1993, instructor Lynn Sweet insisted we learn to do it freehand. He didn’t even tell us that honing guides existed. Later, when I joined the magazine staff in 1996, I asked then-Associate Editor Jim Stuard to show me his sharpening regimen. It was freehand. And so that’s how I learned how to do it.

After reading Leonard Lee’s book “The Complete Guide to Sharpening” (Taunton Press), I decided to try an inexpensive Eclipse guide (what we now call the side-clamp honing guide). It gave me edges that were consistent, less-prone to error and (with apologies to the freehanders) faster.

And so during the last 10 years, I have taught both freehand sharpening and sharpening with a guide. I think it’s useful to know both techniques. I like to use a side-clamp jig for edges that are straight or slightly curved. And I like to sharpen freehand for edges that are skewed, curved, V-shaped or weirder.

I’ve also spent a lot of time observing the sharpening routines and edges produced by freehanders, both professional and amateur. While they tell me they can produce a good edge from a completely dull edge in less than a minute, I have yet to see someone do this before my eyes and let me use their edge. Either it takes them five or six minutes, or the finished edge is sub-optimal compared to what I use.

But these are just my observations. I’m sure there are people out there who can do this; I just haven’t encountered them yet.

So I’m going to ask you one last time: Please don’t try to convert me, and I won’t try to convert you. And why are we discussing something that is as enjoyable as taking out the garbage? Making tools dull is far more fun than making them sharp.

— Christopher Schwarz



8 comments so far

View JayT's profile

JayT

2187 posts in 844 days


#1 posted 109 days ago

All I can say to that is …..

Amen!

-- "The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money." Alexis de Tocqueville, 1835

View Tim's profile

Tim

1245 posts in 595 days


#2 posted 109 days ago

I agree, but it’s not fair to copy his whole article. A link to it or reasonable size excerpts is better.

View Julian's profile

Julian

507 posts in 1324 days


#3 posted 109 days ago

Totally agree. I started out using a honing guide and later learned to hone by hand. Now I usually hone by hand because all I’m doing is refreshing the edge. But when a edge needs significant work, I use a guide. To each his own.

-- Julian

View Fettler's profile

Fettler

117 posts in 630 days


#4 posted 109 days ago

I originally started off with a honing guide as Jim Tolpin teaches at the Port Townsend school of working but since taking a handtool workshop from Rob Cosman I’ve converted to free hand (for most things). I’ve always thought it would be interesting to have a bake off of recognized woodworkers results of sharping (it’s definitely something that’s measurable). Hard to argue with science.

But as you said, sharpening is something tedious and whichever system is the least unpleasant is personal preference.

-- --Rob, Seattle, WA

View OSU55's profile

OSU55

100 posts in 623 days


#5 posted 108 days ago

Well, I gave full and complete credit to the author for an article that is in the public domain (subscription not required), so I don’t believe it’s an issue. PM me if you have a problem. It’s a short article that I thought folks might find interesting and otherwise might miss.

My personal position on sharpening: use a jig if at all possible. I agree with Schwarz that freehand can’t provide as good an edge as jigs. Also, I don’t debate the issue because science proves one is better than the other.

View Don W's profile

Don W

14883 posts in 1201 days


#6 posted 108 days ago

It sure sounds like he trying to convert free handers to me.

-- Master hand plane hoarder. - http://timetestedtools.com

View camps764's profile

camps764

791 posts in 993 days


#7 posted 108 days ago

I read this a while back on their site and totally agreed. It’s weird to me that people do this. I was at the woodworking shop last year buying a honing guide. While I was standing in the aisle talking to the owner about which guide to buy – veritas vs. eclispse style – a random shopper walked up and said “real woodworker’s sharpen freehand…” I chose to ignore him and continued my convo. There’s an old saying about opinions that came to mind.

-- Steve. Visit my website http://www.campbellwoodworking.com

View smitty22's profile

smitty22

592 posts in 1580 days


#8 posted 72 days ago

Thanks again, hadn’t seen that from Schwarz before, and enjoyed the read.

A comment fwiw, I’m just learning use of hand tools, just part way into Chapter 1 “sharpening”, and so far the honing guide is producing best results for me for chisels and plane irons. Have tried, but results from free-handing have been inconsistent at best.

Dale

-- Smitty

Have your say...

You must be signed in to post the comments.

DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user.

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

HomeRefurbers.com

Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries | Latest Forum Topics

GardenTenders.com :: gardening showcase