The story is told that after the Great Fire of 1666, the architect Sir Christopher Wren was commissioned to rebuild St. Paul’s Cathedral in London.
Upon the completion of this huge undertaking, Queen Anne reviewed the work and is said to have declared that it was, “Awful, amusing, and wholly artificial.” Wren was quite pleased to receive such a compliment from the Queen! The English language has a sneaky way of changing over time, and a lot of woodworking definitions have changed or been lost as the language changed. Many woodworkers can not explain the difference between a dado, a groove, a rabbet, and a fillister. “Mullion” and “muntin” have become virtually synonymous. Many professional woodworkers don’t know the difference between a smoothing plane and a jack plane. I don’t think the change of definitions is either good or bad – it just happens.
.
“Jig” and “fixture” are two more words that have become virtually synonymous. Even though most of the books I have on the topic use both words in their title, none of them even make an attempt at explaining the difference, and Webster’s definitions aren’t very helpful, either, so we are stuck with my definitions. In my mind, a “jig” holds or guides a tool and a “fixture” holds or guides a workpiece. Unfortunately, these definitions fly in the face of many common uses (whoever heard of a “honing fixture”?), and there are any number of devices that hold and guide both the tool and the workpiece! I will abandon my definitions without hesitation if I think the “correct” usage might cause confusion or seem redundant. Generically, I tend to refer to jigs and fixtures as “jigs”.
-- http://www.north40custom.com -- http://north40studios.etsy.com --






















11 comments so far
Thos. Angle
home | projects | blog
4013 posts in 861 days
posted 714 days ago
How about; a jig guides and a fixture holds. We could always go back to doo-hickey and thing-a-ma-jig.
-- Thos. Angle
dennis mitchell
home | projects | blog
3791 posts in 1213 days
posted 714 days ago
...you lost me at “fillister”. Never heard of it.
-- http://www.woodsongsfurniture.com
Peter O
home | projects | blog
1027 posts in 773 days
posted 713 days ago
Thos – that’s what the definitions boil down to, most of the time. Except when you have a doo-dad on the whatcha-ma-callit.
-- http://www.north40custom.com -- http://north40studios.etsy.com --
Peter O
home | projects | blog
1027 posts in 773 days
posted 713 days ago
Dennis – you can hold your mouse cursor over the president to get his definition, or …
A fillister is an old word which is almost never used anymore – which was the point of course. It’s basically the same thing as a rabbet, but a rabbet goes across the grain and a fillister goes along the grain. I learned the difference fairly recently when I was reading about old hand planes, and learned that different planes were used for making rabbets and fillisters. Now we generally use the same kind of tool to make both, so the distinction between the two becomes less important. It’s interesting that the cross grain words – dado and rabbet – have continued in common use, and the with-the-grain words – groove and fillister – are less used.
-- http://www.north40custom.com -- http://north40studios.etsy.com --
mrtrim
home | projects | blog
1698 posts in 779 days
posted 713 days ago
im not sure if this is on topic or not . if not please excuse me and ignore it . two terms i see most commonly misused in my industry are window sill and window stool it would seem the definitions have been blured somewhere along the line my two scents ( assuming im tax exempt on lj if not 1 scent ! )
mrtrim
home | projects | blog
1698 posts in 779 days
posted 713 days ago
p s i think that very pic of bush might well end up on the one dollar bill one day !!lol
SPalm
home | projects | blog
951 posts in 781 days
posted 713 days ago
I always like the term ‘awfully good’.
I guess it means it is so good that it makes you full of awe.
But the ‘amusing’ usage above has me baffled.
I want to go with Thos’ answer, but I tend to use ‘fixture’ only when holding the workpiece, not the tool. (?)
Thing-a-ma-bob is my preferred.
-- Stevethepeeve -- I'm no rocket surgeon
GaryK
home | projects | blog
9549 posts in 887 days
posted 713 days ago
I prefer the technical and proper term “Thingie”.
-- Gary, East TX -- The longest journey begins with a single step.
Karson
home | projects | blog
25811 posts in 1299 days
posted 713 days ago
Now you know why I don’t use them. I do searching and never find what i want. So I do without.
-- What happens in the workshop stays in the workshop. No wait that doesn't sound right. Karson Southern Delaware karson_morrison@bigfoot.com †
MsDebbieP
home | projects | blog
14174 posts in 1059 days
posted 712 days ago
and now .. we know!
or do we?? “that’s some groovy dado” is probably a really confusing phrase.
-- ~ Debbie, Canada (http://www.execulink.com/~yohan)
Peter O
home | projects | blog
1027 posts in 773 days
posted 712 days ago
Just think how people will be talking in another 300 years!
-- http://www.north40custom.com -- http://north40studios.etsy.com --