Thanks for the information from all! I went and got some Naval Jelly from Lowes (you should have seen the look on the Customer Service lady’s face when I asked for that!) I did three different applications of Naval Jelly, making sure to rinse throughly after each one. Once that was done, I took a fine steel wool and a little bit of oil to the top making sure to work it in small circles to get into the little groves. When I felt good about it, I wiped the whole thing down with some isopropyl alcohol and let dry. I then applied some SC Johnson Paste Wax leaving a thin coat for about 10 minutes. Then I buffed it off by hand and applied another coat. I left this one on for about 30 minutes and then buffed it off by hand. I then wiped on a thin coat of protective oil. So far i’m happy with how it’s going.
-- Jon | Rigby, Idaho