I know you guys think I’ve vanished but to your dismay I am still here. It happens that a couple of french friends have come over to visit the country and they are staying over at our home for two weeks so I am quite busy showing them the area.
Although after reading Hawg's post I couldn’t help but remember my close call with a spinning blade. Too close for my taste.
It was a few years ago and I was building a new porch for a friend of mine. Her house is an ancient (170 years old) log house and the front porch was badly rotten so I teared it down and proceeded to build a new one. Mind you, this was a completely “on-site” job and my choice of tools was very limited (and there goes my entry for the Understatement Of The Year Awards…).
I was ripping very long 4×4s (not SUVs!) with a portable circular saw. Sure enough, the saw was too small for the job and I had to do it in two passes from opposite sides as the blade only went about 60% of the required deep.
.
.
They were about 10 ft long if I recall correctly so, at the end of the last cut, the thin but long slice of wood closed down on the back of the saw and Mr. Kickback showed it’s ugly face. The saw jumped back out of my hand -literally- and landed on the floor on my side. Not to brag about it but I’m a pretty strong guy and I could never have imagined that such a small tool could exert that kind of force.
In the heat of the moment I didn’t felt anything, I guess it was the adrenaline rush, but immediately I started inspecting my hands trying to convince myself that I was still in one piece.
Then I saw it.
And I was afraid.
Very scared I should say.
Of course when you are building fine furniture you have to compromise in some security items because, after all, you can’t expect great results if you are wearing boxing gloves. But I was just rough cutting posts and boards in a makeshift workbench and I confess that I’ve never trusted portable circular saws. I think it’s pretty easy to get confident with them and the retractile guard is not enough to keep you safe. So I am glad on that day I was wearing thick leather contractor gloves. I am glad because it’s the only thing that saved my right thumb. And not that I want to, but if I have to choose, I can’t think of a worse finger to loose.
Here’s the picture of my right glove after the accident:
.
.
It was when I looked down and I saw this image that I was scared. I was afraid of taking the glove off and see what was inside. Even if it’s not easy to appreciate in the picture, the upper and lower holes are connected by a cut all the way through the leather and fabric.
Lucky me, once I saw the extent of the lesion I was very, very relieved. Still shaking but relieved nonetheless. This is a picture of my “two thumbs up” three weeks after the accident:
.
.
The part of the lion is not facing the camera, just behind the left bump. That was the entry point and the saw ran across the top of my thumb, following the scar and exiting in the small dark patch on the right side.
Worse comes to worst, and to add insult to the injury (pun intended), after a couple of hours and some painkillers, once the throbing thumb was a little bit better I was stupid enough to go back to work… Obviously, I was somewhat stressed out and I managed to cleanly cut… the power cord of the saw! Yep, after that I called it a day and take the rest of the day and the following one off.
Lessons learned that day:
- Stabilize well your blanks, AKA you can never have enough clamps.
- If cutting such long pieces, insert a scrap halfway through the cut and fix it with a clamp. This would prevent the gap from closing down on the blade.
- Don’t do such kind of cuts alone. A helping hand on the other end would have prevented this.
- As for your enemies, never trust or misjudge any machine, no matter how small and innocent it would look like.
- Be paranoid about safety. I am and always been and yet…
- If you have suffered a stressful situation, stop, think about what and why happened and, if you don’t feel totally confident, call it a day. The hardest thing to learn in aviation, and the one that causes the highest number of casualties is learning to recognize when to say NO and where to stop before errors pile up.
And last but not least:
- If a friend of yours ever asks you to build her a porch, do like I did and be sure beforehand that she’s a certified nurse. Otherwise change your friends! :o)
Take care folks, I have to go now because tomorrow the frenchies will come back from Hiroshima and I will be busy again (By the way, and in a complete non sequitur, visiting the Peace museum in Hiroshima changed my life, that is scary!)
-- Jojo, shopless in Kyoto · http://twitter.com/kagushokunin






















9 comments so far
mot
home | projects | blog
4904 posts in 935 days
posted 839 days ago
Thanks for sharing this story and description. I’m sure every member of this site has done something that seemed like it would be fine…and then ended up, not so much. Glad you still have all 10!
-- You can discover more about a person in an hour of play than in a year of conversation. (Plato)
TheGravedigger
home | projects | blog
211 posts in 923 days
posted 839 days ago
Close call indeed, and excellent safety points.
I think you (and my old flight instructor) are right—aviation’s “get-home-itis” and woodworking’s “get-through-itis” are VERY closely related! Both usually result from impatience, overconfidence, and a chain of events that could have been stopped at any point (but the end, of course).
-- Robert from Raymond, MS. "We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence is therefore not a practice, but a habit." - Aristotle
Thos. Angle
home | projects | blog
4013 posts in 861 days
posted 839 days ago
I guess I got lucky. I used to use the same technique to rip 16 foot 4×6 ’s for horse drawn mower tongues. Luckily this never happened to me, but it sure could have.
-- Thos. Angle
Hawgnutz
home | projects | blog
522 posts in 975 days
posted 839 days ago
Jojo,
Glad we both ‘escaped’ real injury in our accidents! Kickback is not only a frightening occurance when it happens, but it happens, littertally, in a FLASH!
Circular saws scare me more than table saws, and that is saying a lot!
Keep them fingers!
God Bless,
Hawg
-- Saving barnwood from the scrapyards
oscorner
home | projects | blog
4572 posts in 1209 days
posted 839 days ago
That looks pretty bad from my perspective. Leather gloves are good, but I don’t think they offer a whole lot of protection against a circular saw blade. The Good Lord was with you that day, same as with Hawg and me when I’ve had my near misses. I’m glad that you still have two of them.
-- Jesus is Lord!
Jojo
home | projects | blog
581 posts in 871 days
posted 839 days ago
As Hawg said: ”Kickback is not only a frightening occurance when it happens, but it happens, littertally, in a FLASH!”
Tell me about it! The very moment I felt the saw stall it was already flying off of the lumber and past my arm. I can’t even recall the path it took. There’s a lot of truth in you being more afraid of portable saws. At least with a table saw you can always know where is the blade. On the other hand, with the handheld you have a 10.000 rpm thing full of sharp teeth spinning freely and exercing a gyrostatic momentum in one hand… and this is not safe in my books.
You are right Oscorner, gloves are a mere retardant and not a real shield but I was fortunate that the teeth of the saw catched up the leather and this slowed them down quite a bit and did keep them relatively apart of my flesh.
BTW, I was left with a perfectly normal-looking and fully-fuctional hand with only an almost invisible scar. So, at the end, and as many of us, that day I won the lottery.
-- Jojo, shopless in Kyoto · http://twitter.com/kagushokunin
Bob Babcock
home | projects | blog
1808 posts in 985 days
posted 838 days ago
Its not a question of if it will happen. It happens to everyone. All we can do is try to be a safe as possible. I try to think through every cut and of course still get the occasional surprise. One thing I always do…..stand to the side. Whether table saw, circular saw, chainsaw (shedded the leg of a good pair of jeans to learn that one), keep to the side of any potential kick.
-- Bob, Carver Massachusetts, Sawdust Maker http://www.capecodbaychallenge.org
MsDebbieP
home | projects | blog
14174 posts in 1059 days
posted 838 days ago
ouch.. very lucky.. very lucky.
thanks for sharing another warning
-- ~ Debbie, Canada (http://www.execulink.com/~yohan)
Bill
home | projects | blog
2561 posts in 1060 days
posted 832 days ago
Glad to hear it was not a worse accident Jojo. Let’s hope it was your one and only major accident.
-- Bill, Turlock California, http://www.brookswoodworks.com