I made my first hand cut dovetail today. To get me started I decided to start of with “the five-minute dovetail”.
I don’t know how long it took me, but it wasn’t too long (a bit more than 5 min).
Here is my first attempt: 




At least it is a nice tight fit
Lessons learned:
1) A cheap dovetail saw does not help in making nice dovetails
2) Your chisels need to be very sharp.
3) Hogging out the waste with a hacksaw does not give very good result.
4) Don’t be in a hurry and forget the 5 minute part of the 5 minute dovetail practice session :-)
I think I will continue with the 5 minute practise dovetail until my skill level has improved enough to try a full set of drawer dovetails.
-- Integrity is doing the right thing when no one is watching.

















7 comments so far
Ryan Haasen
home | projects | blog
340 posts in 567 days
#1 posted 315 days ago
Turned out way better then my first. I find using soft woods more tough because they are so easy to chip and dent around the dovetails when cutting.
-- Ryan
Kookaburra
home | projects | blog
744 posts in 390 days
#2 posted 315 days ago
Oh, thank you for the link – I am embarking on a move to hand tools and dovetails scare me. I am going to try this too!
-- Kay - Just a girl who loves wood.
GrandpaLen
home | projects | blog
952 posts in 438 days
#3 posted 315 days ago
George,
That’s a good 1st attempt. Might I suggest that you pick up some harder wood to practice with. Poplar isn’t really a hardwood but it’s much better to practice on than pine, and poplar is relitively inexpensive.
You’re spot on about the sharpness of your chisels, that makes all the difference in the world.
Practice on a small set of dovetails each time you’re in the shop, even like the one you have posted, and before you know it you will have a handle on it. Use this as a warm-up exercise prior to your other shop projects.
Work Safely and keep your irons Sharp. – Grandpa Len.
-- Mother Nature should be proud of what you've done with her tree. - Len ...just north of a stone's throw from the oHIo, river that is, in So. Indiana.
George_SA
home | projects | blog
171 posts in 379 days
#4 posted 315 days ago
Ryan & Grandpa Len
Thanks for the encouragement. I have some free pallet wood which is much harder than the pine off cut that I used for my first attempt. I used some today to make a Fibonacci gauge. This will also give me some practice in hand planing with my Stanley no 6. Before I do my next exercise I will first spend some time sharpening :-)
Kookaburra, I must say that it was not as difficult as I had anticipated it to be.
-- Integrity is doing the right thing when no one is watching.
rance
home | projects | blog
3855 posts in 1326 days
#5 posted 315 days ago
Good one. Cut it off, date it, and put it in a bag for later inspection of your chronological progress. Also try Poplar or mahogany, they work well. Pine is the pitts. Keep on practicing and posting results. After 2 good ones, then try making all 4 corners of a box.
-- Backer boards, stop blocks, build oversized, and never buy a hand plane--
rilanda
home | projects | blog
118 posts in 320 days
#6 posted 314 days ago
I cut my first dovetail when I was 11years old at school, I remember well the problems I had with accuracy and quality of fit, but that soon changed. I had a first class teacher who saw something in my work that I believed didn’t exist. with his encouragement and tuition I went on to make some show cases for a local museum, 9 lap dovetails across each corner, 4corners to each cabinet and 3 cabinets later I had learned to cut dovetails. Much later in my working life I worked for a shopfitter where all drawers were dovetailed by hand that was another valuable experience, working shoulder to shoulder with men of the old school who taught me a thing or two about dovetailing for production and there are shortcuts. For a first effort the result is commendable (I remember my own was not as good), better will come with practice. Believe in yourself and your own abilities and enjoy the process and perfect dovetails will become a regular thing. Marking out, good quality tools and exceedingly sharp chisels are the secret to good end results. Try to use a better quality timber it looks very fast grown and the spring wood looks very soft, a timber that was a little denser may have produced a better result?
regards
Bill
-- Bill, Nottingham. Remember its not waiting for the storm to end, but learning to dance in the rain that counts. If you dont make mistakes, you make nothing at all.
George_SA
home | projects | blog
171 posts in 379 days
#7 posted 314 days ago
Bill
Thanks for the encouraging words. Sharpening my chisels and dovetail saw is definitely in the agenda before the next try.
Rance
Thanks for tip of dating. I already started off with numbering, but dating gives a better reference later on.
I am actually looking forward to the next try.
-- Integrity is doing the right thing when no one is watching.
Have your say...