A while back I posted a review of Major League Woodworking’s Home Run 4-Pak.
Anyway, my current shop project is a four drawer storage cabinet that sits below my Table Saw. Building this gave me the opportunity to use dovetail joinery for the drawers and putting the 4 Pak to work.
After watching Tom McDonalds videos on how to cut DT’s I started hacking away. Below you will see a picture ofmy first attempt at hand cutting DTs.

I used the 4-Pack marking gauge to layout the base lines for all the pins and tials, and the paring block to lay out the pins. Then I used a Marples Japanese Pull saw to cut the pins on both drawers. Like Tommy says…. practice practice. The first set of tails I tried to cut are on the top. Easy for all to see that GAPS…. The bottom drawer came out a lot better but still, not of the quality I’ve seen produced here by our fellow LJ’s.
I called Tommy at his shop and spoke to him. He suggested two things: 1. Watch the videos again and notice how he says…... “Cut to the outside of the tail line” and 2… Get a DT saw. I took his advice. Here is a look at the corners of the DT’s I cut on my second attempt at hand cut DT’s for the second set of drawers.

By the way, the black lines you see on the tails are the pencil marks Tommy said to LEAVE… I think Tommy’s advice helped a lot.
-- I love the smell of sawdust in the morning....






















12 comments so far
PurpLev
home | projects | blog
2733 posts in 541 days
posted 102 days ago
very nice, even the first set looks good… but obviously the 2nd attempt is much tighter!
-- When in doubt - There is no doubt - Go the safer route.
ChrisN
home | projects | blog
155 posts in 666 days
posted 102 days ago
They look good to me, the bottom box in the first picture looks tight as a drum…I need to get over my fear and give it a try!
-- Chris N, Westford, MA - "If you won't eat something from your fridge that turned green...why would you eat something that started out that way?"
cwdance1
home | projects | blog
186 posts in 152 days
posted 102 days ago
Most days I have trouble cutting a 45 let alone a dovetail. Great job
dustyal
home | projects | blog
443 posts in 368 days
posted 102 days ago
I enjoyed your post… thanks. Second set does look better than first set… practice, practice… etc. I posted my first cut and haven’t had the nerve or the time to get back to it… but I need to. How quick we forget. Dovetail saw is something I’d like to have. I used a flexible flush cut saw and that created a little problem. Also, I need to learn how to stop more cleanly and uniformly at the depth line. I over-shot by the depth of a saw tooth on a few and that makes things a bit unsightly.
Anyway… again… nice job.
-- Al H. - small shop, small projects...
Karson
home | projects | blog
25792 posts in 1293 days
posted 102 days ago
Nice job and a great learning curve. I guess. Practise makes perfect.
-- What happens in the workshop stays in the workshop. No wait that doesn't sound right. Karson Southern Delaware karson_morrison@bigfoot.com †
Marc5
home | projects | blog
56 posts in 235 days
posted 102 days ago
Good Job – Keep it up. I find it very satisfying when I complete a dovetailed drawer or box.
-- If you are not living on the edge you are taking up to much room.
Beginningwoodworker
home | projects | blog
4123 posts in 566 days
posted 102 days ago
Nice work on the dovetail!
-- CJIII Future cabinetmaker
FlWoodRat
home | projects | blog
582 posts in 802 days
posted 102 days ago
Gentlemen, thanks for your kind words.
Dusty, your first cut’s looked great. I’d be proud of those as they were definitely much better than my first attempt.
Rat
-- I love the smell of sawdust in the morning....
JJackson
home | projects | blog
106 posts in 975 days
posted 102 days ago
FL,
Good start! I think they look very good for your first attempt. You might check my profile, I have some of my practice HT Dovetails pictured there. I learned how to cut mine from Rob Cosman. You may want to check out some of his DVD’s. Let me know if I can help you in anyway. Great job so far, keep at it!!
Jeff
By the way, I love you raised panel jig for the tablesaw! Where do I order one from you?? : )
-- Jeff, Indiana
patron
home | projects | blog
2376 posts in 234 days
posted 102 days ago
very well done , my man .
you are getting better !
a friend of mine had a 600 year old chinese trunk ,
that was heavily carved ,
all dovetailed .
upon inspection ,
it was like your first one .
some filler in the joints here and there !
-- david ,new mexico ,allheart
John Gray
home | projects | blog
1751 posts in 778 days
posted 101 days ago
Good job!!
-- Only the Shadow knows....................
matt garcia
home | projects | blog
716 posts in 565 days
posted 101 days ago
Great job!! I need to work on my handcut dovetails!!
-- Matt, Houston Texas