I hadn’t planed on buying the #2 sized plane because of the price and the fact that its small size is not much use for me. Well a few weeks back this #2 plane was up for sale on Ebay and it caught my eye. The plane was in rough shape and the price was lower then what I see a lot of Stanley #2’s sell for. My love for collecting these things got the better of me and I placed my bid. I won the auction for what I feel was a decent price.
To restore or not to restore that is the question….
Collector value comes into question with this plane but the truth of the matter is I don’t ever plan on selling this plane so the actual collector value really means very little to me.
This plane was defiantly a heavy user plane for someone. The plane had a decent amount of rust, there were paint drops on the handles and the iron had seen a lot of grindings. The back tote was broken at the bottom and a piece was missing and the round part of the sole behind the tote was broken off. The plane was probably dropped a few times. So all in all the plane was not all that pretty and it needed some attn before it could be placed on my shelf next to my others. I debated on how far I was going to go on the cleaning/restoration of this plane and I decided to just start working on it and see where it took me.

I took the plane apart and soaked the metal parts in EvapoRust. As they were soaking I cleaned up the handle and knob. I didn’t get extreme here, I just scrapped the paint off with a razor blade and then gave them a light sanding. After that a few coats of lacquer and called em good.
After the metal parts soaked for a few hours I pulled them out and gave them a light polishing. The sole was begging me to repaint it but I decided not to. I just cleaned it as best as I could and waxed it to prevent further rust.

The sides were cleaned and lightly polished. I flattened the face of the frog and polished it a little as well. I didn’t get extreme when cleaning the brass but I gave it a good cleaning/polish. I flattened the sole and I cleaned the blade with a wire wheel and then ground a new bevel on it. After flattening the back and honing a micro bevel it now cuts fine shavings.
After using this plane I realized what I had all ready expected and that is this plane is much to small for me to use. However its the perfect size for my boys to use once they are ready to start learning. I plan on hopefully teaching all 3 of my boys how to use a hand plane using this #2.








-- Dan - "Collector of Hand Planes"

















12 comments so far
DaddyZ
home | projects | blog
2003 posts in 1208 days
#1 posted 696 days ago
Nice Job! Since you said the plane is broken. Shouldn’t that lower the value enough to make the restoration Acceptable.
-- Pat - Worker of Wood, Collector of Tools, Father of one
PurpLev
home | projects | blog
7741 posts in 1816 days
#2 posted 696 days ago
nice score. as I started reading I too starting thinking this would be a perfect plane for younger kids to start learning with as it would be easier and more comfortable for them to hold and use. good thinkin!
-- ㊍ When in doubt - There is no doubt - Go the safer route.
WayneC
home | projects | blog
9596 posts in 2265 days
#3 posted 696 days ago
Nice to see him returned to use. The boys will treasure the plane. I’m really glad you did not repaint the body. I prefer them with original japanning even if a fair amount is missing.
-- We must guard our enthusiasm as we would our life - James Krenov
Dan
home | projects | blog
3479 posts in 1048 days
#4 posted 696 days ago
Daddy Z – the fact that its broken did lower the value because I paid less for this one then I have seen most other #2’s sell for. I am sure my cleaning and tuning has probably increased the value but again its not really an issue because it wont be sold by me. I did skip on repainting it but who knows maybe I will do that in the future.
-- Dan - "Collector of Hand Planes"
Mauricio
home | projects | blog
5114 posts in 1319 days
#5 posted 696 days ago
Dan, what method do you use to flatten the frog?
-- Mauricio - Woodstock, GA - "Confusion is the Womb of Learning, with utter conviction being it's Tomb" Prof. T.O. Nitsch
Dan
home | projects | blog
3479 posts in 1048 days
#6 posted 696 days ago
Wayne- I have repainted enough of my planes to realize how much I hate doing it. To get a perfect paint job there is so much prep work involved and with the time it takes I am thinking my repainting days are behind me for the most part.
However if I notice the rust coming back on this plane I will probably paint it. It was not too badly rusted so I should be ok.
-- Dan - "Collector of Hand Planes"
WayneC
home | projects | blog
9596 posts in 2265 days
#7 posted 696 days ago
For rust, I use a coat of schallac over the areas that would be japanned and then I wax it. I’ve not had any rust issues. Also, you can easily remove the schallac if needed.
-- We must guard our enthusiasm as we would our life - James Krenov
David Grimes
home | projects | blog
2114 posts in 807 days
#8 posted 696 days ago
Nice looking plane and restoration, Dan.
-- If you're going to stir the pot, think BIG spoon or SMALL boat paddle. David Grimes, Georgia
Don W
home | projects | blog
9947 posts in 735 days
#9 posted 696 days ago
Very nice Dan. I’ve been watching but like you, don’t want to pay what I’ve been seeing. I’ll be patient. #4 1/2 are going pretty high as well. Hope the cycle dips soon. I’m dying to try a 4 1/2. That is one fine shaving in the last 2 photos.
-- There is nothing like the sound of a well tuned hand plane. - http://timetestedtools.wordpress.com (timetestedtools at hotmail dot c0m)
Dan
home | projects | blog
3479 posts in 1048 days
#10 posted 696 days ago
Mochoa – To flatten the frog I usually remove the Y york and then flatten with sandpaper on a piece of glass, tile or mdf. To get the very top around the lever adjustment I have just started using small sanding sticks made from scrap hardboard. If the frog is way off I will sometimes use a mill file.
-- Dan - "Collector of Hand Planes"
RGtools
home | projects | blog
2832 posts in 822 days
#11 posted 694 days ago
Beautiful job, make that thing sing the same song it sang to previous generations.
-- Make furniture that lasts as long as the tree - Ryan
hhhopks
home | projects | blog
546 posts in 545 days
#12 posted 484 days ago
Nice.
I always have trouble tuning my planes to take full thin shavings.
Very impressive.
-- I'll be a woodworker when I grow up. HHHOPKS
Have your say...